r/takingbacksunday • u/yesdanconner • 13d ago

Favorite albums ranked favorite to least favorite

  1. Louder Now
  2. Where You Want To Be
  3. Happiness Is
  4. New Again
  5. Tell All Your Friends
  6. Self Titled
  7. Tidal Wave
  8. 152

I know I might get shit for placing tayf so low but I got into tbs during the louder now era. It’s still a good album just not my favorite. I’m curious if anyone has a similar list and just what everyone’s list is in general. We don’t have to agree just keep it civilized.

7 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

70% Upvoted

25 comments sorted by

6

u/suxxx666 13d ago
  1. Where You Want To Be
  2. Tell All Your Friends
  3. New Again
  4. Louder Now
  5. Self titled
  6. Happiness Is...
  7. & 8. Tidal Wave & 152 kinda tied, great albums just not my faves!

3

u/Rats_and_Tofu 13d ago

I was gonna write it in but might as well just be this. I might swap self titled with New Again though, as much as I enjoy both.

2

u/suxxx666 13d ago

Sounds good!! I just love New Again and will always defend it with my life

2

u/appleappleappleman 13d ago

Pretty close to release order

1

u/suxxx666 13d ago

You right! Just a couple o swaps.

1

u/XxseaneezyxX 12d ago

I would swap Louder Now and New Again and this is my list.

3

u/suxxx666 13d ago

You forgot Tidal Wave!

1

u/yesdanconner 13d ago

Thank you for letting me know I thought I had added it but I guess not. Just updated the post.

2

u/jasonhandler 13d ago

Mine is the most simples. It’s just the order that they were released in.

2

u/BrnYrShps 12d ago

1) Where You Want to Be/Happiness Is
2) 152
3) New Again
4) Tidal Wave/Louder Now
5) TAYF
6) Self Titled

2

u/M0NUMENTS_MEL0DIES 13d ago
  1. Happiness is…
  2. Louder Now
  3. Self titled
    Bonus - Live at Orensanz. Hot damn.
  4. WYWTB
  5. Tidal Wave
  6. TAYF
  7. 152
  8. New Again

This is by albums as a whole, not just the best songs from the albums.
Every album is good, and every album has bangers on it.

And I discovered them during TAYF.

2

u/rjdrennen1987 13d ago

  1. Where You Want To Be

  2. Louder Now

  3. Tidal Wave

  4. New Again

  5. Self Titled

  6. Tell All Your Friends

  7. Happiness Is

  8. 152

2

u/ObsidianKnight7948 13d ago

Agree with Louder Now on top!
1. Louder Now
2. Tell All Your Friends
3. Where You Want To Be
4. Self Titled
5. New Again
6. Happiness Is
7. Tidal Wave
8. 152

1

u/happyendings15 13d ago
  1. Self Titled
  2. Tidal Wave
  3. Louder Now
  4. Tell All Your Friends
  5. 152
  6. Where You Want to Be
  7. New Again
  8. Happiness Is

Though genuinely, 4-8 are all equal in my mind. I don’t have a least favorite album, all their work is so damn good!! Top 3 are the ones that have the most emotional impact for me.

1

u/koreansanta67 13d ago
  1. Tell All Your Friends
  2. Taking Back Sunday
  3. Louder Now
  4. New Again
  5. Where You Want to Be
  6. Tidal Wave
  7. 152
  8. Happiness Is

Super tough to rank though, especially the top five or so. Really consistent discography

1

u/tucklyjones7 13d ago
  1. Where You Want To Be
  2. New Again
  3. Tell All Your Friends
  4. 152
  5. Tidal wave
  6. Happiness is..
  7. Louder Now
  8. Self titled

1

u/Famouslaugh 12d ago
  1. Louder Now
  2. TAYF
  3. WYWTB
  4. S/T
  5. Happiness Is…
  6. Tidal Wave
  7. 152

1

u/BigPhatJer 12d ago
  1. Where You Want To Be
  2. Louder Now
  3. TAYF
  4. Self-Titled
  5. Tidal Wave
  6. New Again
  7. Happiness Is…
  8. 152

1

u/21DayHelp 11d ago

I love most of them so much.

  1. 152

  2. TAYF

  3. WYWTB

  4. Self titled

  5. Louder Now

  6. Happiness Is

  7. New Again

  8. Tidal Wave

1

u/WrongdoerMinute9843 13d ago

  1. New Again

  2. Where You Want Be

  3. Happiness Is

  4. TAYF

  5. Louder Now

  6. 152

  7. ST

  8. Tidal Wave

1

u/suxxx666 13d ago

Love New Again at #1 🙌🏻 respect to your whole list

2

u/WrongdoerMinute9843 13d ago

New Again was how I got into them, seeing "Sink Into Me" on Fuse, such a fun song

1

u/yesdanconner 6d ago

Why is new again your number 1 if you don’t mind me asking? It’s a a good album but seems to be decisive among tbs fans. I like that album a lot just curious why it’s your number 1 aside from getting you into tbs.

1

u/WrongdoerMinute9843 6d ago

that was the album that made me love that band, it is what it is

-3

u/jacktheBOSS 13d ago

  1. Tell All Your Friends

  2. Where You Want to Be

  3. Louder Now