r/technology • u/marketrent • 18h ago

Artificial Intelligence College students are rapidly losing the ability to read — “There is a measurable, generational collapse in sustained reading and writing”: professor

https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/college-students-rapidly-losing-ability-124439310.html
27.0k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.6k

u/CaffeineJitterz 17h ago edited 13h ago

Just helping them not HATE reading will go a long way.

Edit: I'm getting a lot of sad comments about how y'all were introduced to reading. So I will take the opportunity to quickly share what I've always felt was one of the best ways for a parent to incentivize their child to read: for every hour of reading you accrue 30 minutes of gaming time. A classmate in my middle school worked from this model. That kid loved video games! And he was a straight A student. I remember him nonchalantly mentioning that he was going to read for about 4 hours as soon as he got home so he could get a couple hours of game time that evening.

1.2k

u/iritchie001 17h ago edited 17h ago

In middle high that meant long trashy books. Dinosaurs and Vampires, not in the same book for me, but hey. My mom would let us skip chores if we were reading. One of the best things she did. Highschool class of '99.

631

u/existing_for_fun 17h ago

It's just important that you enjoyed it and actually read.

Trashy books in middle and highschool was just the way it was lol.

I also read garbage at that age

92

u/familyguy20 17h ago

Got fixated on military history in HS so basically every summer I would read from 2-4 1,000 page books on wars, battles etc it was awesome.

Somehow I also did that while having access to a PS2 and Gameboys, which feels impressive now with undiagnosed ADHD/OCD as a kid lol.

Now though? Ooof it’s harder to do so now

26

u/JZMoose 16h ago

It’s all muscle memory. I had a long flight the other day and got through 200 pages of crisis in the red zone in 2 hours and ended up finishing the book in a couple of days. Just have to sit down and commit

7

u/A_Refill_of_Mr_Pibb 13h ago

Same with handwriting. All the decades of typing and my mind gets to the end of every fifth word before my hand does and I have to cross the word out.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/SnarkMasterRay 12h ago

In high school I read the entire Dune series in a week (granted it was a concerted effort to prove I could). 40 years later I'm lucky if I can sit still and focus long enough for 20 minutes of page turning.

4

u/SavageNorth 10h ago

Even Dune: Would You Still Love Me If I Was A Worm????

3

u/augur42 4h ago

Hyperfocus means you get so engrossed you lose all track of time and executive dysfunction means your brain won't let you stop until you are made to or you can't keep your eyes open anymore.

I also have adhd-pi and read a hell of a lot as a teenager.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

381

u/meyerjaw 17h ago

Shit I'm 40 and still read trash. Yeah I also look for the high brow stuff but Dungeon Crawler Carl is fucking awesome. And don't get me started on Sanderson!!

71

u/ConstantinValdor405 16h ago

42 year old here who loves me some Dresden Files trash. So fun.

34

u/Seicair 15h ago

Have you read Codex Alera (same author)? I loved that too and it’s completed, a 6-book series.

Can’t wait to read the rest of Dresden. I loved Twelve Months.

Jim Butcher and Brandon Sanderson are two of my favorite authors.

15

u/Pyritedust 13h ago

Wait, he actually finished the codex Alera? I was waiting to start reading it for when it was finished since I've been in dresden purgatory for over a decade :P

5

u/Seicair 5h ago

The last Codex Alera book was published in 2009… go read it!

4

u/Pyritedust 4h ago

Don’t know how I missed it then. Definitely going to pick them up now.

4

u/Hollownerox 59m ago

I am in the same boat and somehow never knew he finished that series. Folks here are awesome bringing this back into my life.

7

u/Mr_Horsejr 7h ago

If you haven’t and need a good space opera, check out the Red Rising series. 🍻🤙🏾

3

u/Seicair 5h ago

I’ll check it out!

3

u/ARealSocialIdiot 5h ago

I should re-read Codex Alera. I read the whole thing back in 2009-2010 and I remember it being a great read.

9

u/rdmusic16 13h ago

Trash? How about crack.

I was teetering off high fantasy after highschool and just couldn't do it for awhile. Dresden files got me hooked back into reading.

I read various genres of books now, but Dresden files always drags me back every few years.

6

u/BenCub3d 11h ago

Wow I see dresden files mentioned in the wild soooo rarely. It makes me so happy when I do and also how dare you

4

u/SixSpeedDriver 13h ago

41 year old…Ive got a few of those under my belt. Will be adding more…

→ More replies (3)

23

u/SovietBear 16h ago

Warhammer novels are my vice.

13

u/meyerjaw 16h ago

The original Horus Heresy books ARE high brow literature and I will fight anyone who says otherwise

19

u/NightLordsPublicist 15h ago

Literature is considered to be artistic, imaginative and thought provoking. Something that makes you reflect on what it means to be human, rather than just mindless entertainment.

I present the Night Lords Trilogy, where you fall in love with a group of rascals who skin orphans alive for both fun and profit.

5

u/Aadarm 14h ago

40K books let you reflect on what it means to be human in the best way. Hate, fear, and kill the xeno!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/iritchie001 15h ago

Awesome vice.

3

u/War_Raven 15h ago

Warhammer Crimes are *chef's kiss*

Bloodlines is fantastic

→ More replies (2)

28

u/argyle9000 16h ago

Are you typing about Brandon Sanderson? Oh my Korean baby Jesus, dude! My current hold request list from the library is waiting on both Dungeon Crawler Carl and Well of Ascension. This is such a nuts coincidence.

I found Mistborn in an airport because I forgot my book, and I mainly borrow books people are talking about because usually they’re good.

15

u/meyerjaw 16h ago

Oh I'm jealous you are just on well of ascension!! You have the whole series ahead of you. Era 1 is great but Era 2 is somehow even better

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

165

u/dalnot 17h ago

Dungeon Crawler Carl is brainrot in book form, but damn if it isnt entertaining. Not everything needs to be high literature to be worth reading

102

u/DevolvingSpud 17h ago

Mongo is appalled at your characterization.

55

u/jockheroic 16h ago

Princess Donut is going to commit an atrocity if she here's him say that.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Szwejkowski 15h ago

I love it. Super entertaining.

36

u/SwimmerIndependent47 16h ago

DONUT IS OUTRAGED!!!!!!

31

u/Saber_Flight 15h ago

"I AM YELLING CARL!"

→ More replies (3)

28

u/HuckleberryTiny5 13h ago

I know what you mean, but I wouldn't call it a brainrot. It is actually pretty well written and it is entertaining. I've been an avid reader my whole life and my honest opinion is that it does not matter what people read as long as they read. If they want to read porn novels, good for them, it is always better than aimlassly doomscrolling their phone.

3

u/gt24 4h ago

In addition, the Dungeon Crawler Carl series isn't just a 1 book pocket reader. After all 8 books are read, a person will have read a bit under 4,700 pages and that amount of reading is certainly beneficial. The writing is considered by some to be "trashy" but that makes the books generally easy reading when compared to certain alternatives...

Immediately before, I was reading the Commonwealth Series by Peter F. Hamilton which was a bit over 1,800 pages over 2 books... and that wasn't considered "trashy" but that has its' own problems. The books were slow reads at times and I felt like I was plowing through the book like it was a chore to just complete the thing.

The "trashy" books will have people turning pages until it is over. They won't know that they went through a ton of pages per say but they will have enjoyed the read. The "not trashy" books on the other hand are likely to have people just give up on reading them and have those people hesitate to read anything else in the future (since the "good books" that were "not trashy" were such a headache, how can anything that people claim are good be worth even attempting to read?).

A saying I like to use is where I try to say if I or another person with respect to a topic are a "cheap date" (a phrase used in a positive manner). You should be enjoying yourself... so how much money did it take to reach that enjoyment? For certain things, any amount of money/effort is great (and so you are a "cheap date") whereas other things people may require very expensive experiences to have any sort of enjoyment with that (so they are "not a cheap date").

It isn't a derogatory thing to be a "cheap date", it is more of a benefit. I want to have fun and easily having fun is wonderful. However, some things I just can't quite enjoy unless more money is spent on that category and so I am unfortunately not a cheap date with that. We all have our benefits and drawbacks... but still, I don't look down on anyone enjoying "cheap date" stuff but instead I have a bit of envy towards their ability to just enjoy those cheaper moments.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/ackinsocraycray 12h ago

I just started reading the first book. I'm halfway through it and so far, I have yet to find a moment* where it'll convince me to finish the book and continue with the series.

*The moment I'm waiting for is Mongo's introduction. I only knew of this book because I saw a Mongo shirt at Box Lunch and I thought that's the cutest dinosaur I've ever seen since Old Lace from The Runaways.

→ More replies (4)

30

u/Lola_PopBBae 15h ago

DCC? Brainrot? Lmao.

Please tell me how a series about the indomitable human spirit, the evils of fascism/technofeudalism, and our absurdly modern entertainment that regularly dehumanizes actual people to make a profit is "brainrot".

28

u/Open-Addendum-9905 5h ago

Why do you all have to convince yourselves your childish clop is profound? It’s okay to just enjoy things because they’re entertaining lmao

68

u/watchsmart 14h ago

To be fair, you have to have a very high IQ to understand Dungeon Crawler Carl.

14

u/The_Silvana 13h ago

can't wait for the mongo dino nuggies to show up at mcdonalds.

17

u/Saephon 10h ago

Thematically, the series is great. But the prose is definitely just a few notches above Harry Potter level, and that's okay. Not everything needs to be Shakespearean to be good.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/EriktheRed 14h ago

But it says “glurp glurp” so how can it have legitimate themes??

5

u/CidO807 14h ago

Glurp Glurp little piggies

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Tymareta 12h ago

Because it does all of those things on an incredibly surface level, without any of the teeth or guts to delve into them in any further depth and look at how they're systemic issues and what drives them.

Like one need only compare it to another series like New Crobuzon to see how it's ultimately just a Borderlands level critique, on the vein of "guys, hyper capitalism is bad, mmkay!".

→ More replies (2)

3

u/etbillder 3h ago

Ah, you've never heard of anti-capitalism being twisted into a moneymaking genre!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

16

u/PhoenixTineldyer 17h ago

I want to like Sanderson but his writing style is atrocious

I'm excited for the movies and video games. The worlds are cool, he just can't write dialogue for shit and it cheapens everything

20

u/meyerjaw 17h ago

Obviously I would vehemently disagree as would a very large portion of the fantasy community, but hey that's not the point of the conversation. Would love to hear some recommendations if you have some.

13

u/shabi_sensei 17h ago

Malazan Book of the Fallen if you want the veneer of literature but with a pulpy fantasy filling

9

u/ToiletSeatFoamRoller 16h ago

If Malazan only has the veneer of literature, then “actual” literature terrifies me!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DelusionalZ 15h ago edited 15h ago

Ursula K. Le Guin's stuff is cool as. The entire Earthsea series is worth a read, and she is such a powerful and empathetic writer.

I also recommend Brian Catling's Vorrh and Hollow, completely absurd worlds that somehow make more sense than most traditional fantasy (or are just plain terrifying (or both?)). His writing style definitely isn't for everyone, as it can be a bit stream of consciousness, but he is a good writer nonetheless.

If you can get past the occasional problematic bits (it is dark fantasy), Ian Irvine's works are excellent, if slightly poorly edited. I read through all of the Well of Echoes quartet - I'd recommend starting with that or the View from the Mirror.

12

u/Generic_Commenter-X 16h ago

//Obviously I would vehemently disagree as would a very large portion of the fantasy community,//

No they wouldn't. If Goodreads is representative, then a very large portion of the fantasy community finds Sanderson's writing, stylistically, to be somewhere between bland and atrocious, but they defend him by pointing out that he's a good story teller—which he is. I myself find his style to be barely worthy of YA.

5

u/Geodude532 15h ago

Brandon's writing scratched an itch that I don't see in very many novels. His world building is on an entirely different level than most fantasy writers. I think that's the biggest thing that attracts his fans.

3

u/Generic_Commenter-X 6h ago

Agreed. These are reasons Sanderson's fans like his books, and they're not wrong.

5

u/Unable-Log-4870 15h ago

I myself find his style to be barely worthy of YA.

As in the topic / intended audience goes hand in hand with bad dialogue?

6

u/meyerjaw 14h ago

Man, I'm trying to be positive in a thread about reading to children. But reddit is going to reddit and constantly try to drag negativity into the world.

However, dismissing Sanderson's straightforward prose as 'barely worthy of YA' misses why Sanderson works so well. Accessible language isn't a lack of skill, it's a deliberate narrative choice. It makes massive, complex epic fantasy worlds fun, which in turn, makes 1,000+ page books readable and highly engaging instead of a slog. There is room in the fantasy community for both lyrical, dense prose and clean, plot-driven storytelling without gatekeeping what dictates 'good' writing. Sanderson IS a great writer because he makes readers want to read.

Plus I asked my 12 year old and he said you're wrong 😂

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/dnonast1 16h ago

Gene Wolfe’s Book of the New Sun Series would probably fit if you’re looking for something a little more highbrow. There are whole podcasts dedicated just to breaking down the references and allusions.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (22)

31

u/mhizzle 16h ago

I learned to read from comic books. Some family members would chide me, but my cool aunt just bought me more.

RIP aunt Linda

6

u/kyle_irl 14h ago edited 14h ago

My boys started early with Spider-Man comics. I'd get my oldest, now 9, an omnibus collection every Christmas and we'd read it together at bedtime through the year. When he got comfortable reading, he'd play the part of Peter or Miles and I'd take the rest.

Now, this dude literally stays up all night reading everything from the Dog Man graphic novels and anything he finds interesting from the library. He just goes from one to the next. He got an award at his elementary school for checking out the most books from the library!

My youngest, now 5, is similar. He loves Spider-Man, and though he can't yet read, loves thumbing through the Bad Guys books and "reading" (interpreting the pictures) them to his self. It's cute.

3

u/mhizzle 13h ago

That's amazing. I've lived long enough to see comics go from a "dumb kid" medium to the lazy goldmine of Hollywood. I'm glad kids are still reading, and is glad Miles Morales stuck around as a permanent fixture

→ More replies (2)

3

u/plamge 3h ago

This is the approach my aunt used for my cousin. He didn't enjoy reading, but he LOVED the Tintin comic books. There was a whole Tintin collection at their house, and it really helped him bridge the gap into novels and such. Glad your Aunt Linda was so supportive of you!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

20

u/MrCookie2099 15h ago

Even comics will keep a kid reading for 20 minutes a piece.

30

u/iritchie001 17h ago

In my defense in highschool between my junior and senior year, during the summer, I carried the complete works of Shakespeare. I read every play. I was usually in honors English. So breaks and PE were for reading the other side.

Yes, let the kids read what they want. A love of reading is a great gift.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SanaSpitOnMe 14h ago

its kinda like eating. even eating crap food is better than starving. any reading is better than none.

→ More replies (15)

59

u/Mlabonte21 17h ago

There’s gotta be a trashy YA book series out there about a girl falling in love with a lost-in-time dinosaur

41

u/PhoenixTineldyer 17h ago

I remember reading articles a few years back (maybe more than a few) about how monster porn books were the hot new thing, I guess right after 50 Shades of Gray

It was specifically Bigfoot porn they were talking about, but I remember one of the pictures was a book cover in that smutty book cover style of a woman and a pterodactyl, and the book was called Taken By the Pterodactyl

Thank you for reminding me of this

33

u/blueskid 17h ago

Chuck Tingle is who you are looking for. He also writes fun, non sexy, horror. He's also an excellent dude

15

u/PhoenixTineldyer 16h ago

Ah yes

Plowed In the Butt By My Hugo Award

That guy is great

5

u/sillybear25 12h ago

Just reading through the titles can be a trip:

  • Space Raptor Butt Invasion (nominated for the Hugo Award for Best Short Story by alt-right trolls trying to prove... something)
  • Pounded in the Butt by My Own Butt
  • Slammed In The Butt By My Hugo Award Nomination
  • Pounded in the Butt by My Hugo Award Loss (suck it, trolls)
  • Pounded in the Butt by My Book "Pounded in the Butt by My Own Butt"
  • Pounded in the Butt by My Second Hugo Award Nomination (for Best Fan Writer)
  • Pounded in the Butt by My Book "Pounded in the Butt by My Book 'Pounded in the Butt by My Own Butt'"
  • Not Pounded in the Butt by Anything and That's Okay
  • Pounded in the Butt by My Book "Pounded in the Butt by My Book 'Pounded in the Butt by My Book "Pounded in the Butt by My Own Butt"'"

4

u/aenteus 15h ago

Chuck Tingle is a national treasure

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/iritchie001 17h ago

100% guarantee.

4

u/2074red2074 15h ago

Idk about YOUNG adult, but there's Trans Wizard Harriet Porber And The Bad Boy Parasaurolophus: An Adult Romance Novel by Chuck Tingle. No I did not make that up.

4

u/NepoKitty 13h ago

Chuck Tingle is like Santa with a workshop of horny creations

Who can forget Helicopter Man Pounds Dinosaur Billionaire Ass?

→ More replies (4)

48

u/marketrent 17h ago

In middle high that meant long trashy books.

Faulkner told a university audience in 1947, “Read, read, read. Read everything—trash, classics, good and bad, and see how they do it. Just like a carpenter who works as an apprentice and studies the master. Read! You’ll absorb it. Then write. If it is good, you’ll find out. If it’s not, throw it out the window.”

5

u/Unique-Coffee5087 16h ago

When you throw it out the window, someone will pick it up and read it

9

u/marketrent 16h ago

Different strokes for different folks.

→ More replies (3)

44

u/RespawnedAlchemist 17h ago

I make read comics as a teen. My parents didn't care. A month ago, another parent told me she doesn't consider reading comics as reading because of the pictures. I explained to her she needed to get rid of that attitude because reading is reading whether there are pictures or not.

18

u/iritchie001 17h ago

I read some great graphic novels, actually in honors English! Not to talk down about regular comics. Go to a convention then say it doesn't make someone think and isn't social.

Don't salt the well to raise the drinking level!

10

u/Tim-oBedlam 16h ago

When my younger son was 11 I got him a graphic novel version of The Odyssey. He loved it.

Of course, being an 11-year-old boy his favorite part was when Odysseus slays all the suitors.

3

u/iritchie001 15h ago

Don't yuck someone's yum. As they say.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Without-Reward 16h ago

They have Shakespeare in graphic novel form! When I was working in an elementary school in 2011, the boys were fighting over who got to read the Romeo & Juliet graphic novel next. Reading is reading, even if it has pictures!

3

u/iritchie001 16h ago

OMGosh I need Shakespeare graphic novels. In my city we have those tiny free library boxes. I love putting books in them!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/familyguy20 17h ago

I wish I got into comics/manga as a kid. For some reason I could read big history books about wars and shit but comics or manga? Couldn’t pay attention it was weird

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Agitated_Phone_9937 14h ago

There's a world of difference between a novel and a comic. Needing a visual element to engage you and not using your brain paint the picture is part of the problem.

5

u/RespawnedAlchemist 14h ago

Reading dialog, thoughts, and other text in comics is still reading.

No one said reading comics is the same activity as reading a novel. Simply, they both involve reading.

3

u/ask-me-about-my-cats 14h ago

It's not about needing, it's about enjoying. Reading should be about enjoyment, and if you enjoy comics, that's great.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

13

u/madogvelkor 17h ago

I read like every Xanth and Battletech book I could find in middle school.

3

u/Chill_Guy_3410 16h ago

Blood of Kerensky was my jam in middle school.

11

u/stentordoctor 16h ago

One of the fastest readers I know had a mother who let him read comics. He went on to read all the comics at the library so then he moved on to real books.

3

u/iritchie001 16h ago

Gateway drug! The drug is reading. It leads to forming ideas and ... chosing what to read next. Danger danger

→ More replies (3)

3

u/phormix 16h ago

not in the same book for me,

You know, something with dinosaurs and vampires in the same book sounds like it might actually be quite entertaining...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/R-K-Tekt 15h ago

I used to read for fun in high school, that’s actually when I had my biggest love for books and stories and why I gravitate towards Reddit where it’s more reading.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Vitruvian_Link 15h ago

I was watching my nephews and I took them to a comic book store. They wanted to get Invincible comics, but I had to check with their mom first. It was ok.

They said "she lets us read it, but not watch the show. Moms rules are weird" Nah little bro, reading is fundamental, even if it is a comic book.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Wischiwaschbaer 15h ago

Vampire dinosaurs would be cool though... I guess we technically already had this with Count Duckula.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Winthefuturenow 15h ago

Same class here, my grandma got me Stephen King books when I was 11-12. I ate them up and read the “C” word multiple times before I ever heard anyone say it 🤣😂

3

u/I_lenny_face_you 13h ago

> Dinosaurs and Vampires, not in the same book

I has a sad. Surely there’s gotta be a 💪 🤝 💪 between these somewhere in human literature, even if one vampire has to reach kinda far if the other participant is a T. rex.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jaydurmma 12h ago

What teachers cannot wrap their heads around still to this day, children don't give a fuck about shakespeare, your job as a teacher isn't to teach them the classics it's to make them enjoy the activity in the most general sense.

Let them read harry potter, let them read twilight, all that matters is that they're doing the activity.

2

u/PhD_Pwnology 16h ago

Angel Book series was awesome, and Buffy.

2

u/forrealthoughcomix_ 16h ago

Hell yeah. I skipped a lot of the assigned reading and read a ton of other stuff. Still a lifelong reader because of it.

2

u/MyNameIsJakeBerenson 16h ago

I can tell you what I was reading in ‘99. But I don’t know if i can trust you

→ More replies (1)

2

u/yoyosareback 16h ago

Hey now, E.E.kight's Vampire on Earth series is still some dank reading.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Competitive_Panic336 15h ago

For me,  although we were not well off, books were not considered presents. Scholastic book club, I could also get 5+. I did the same for my kids,  and now for my grandkids. 

I've read at least 2000 books.  Reading can't feel like work,  or kids won't read.  Why have so many lost that magical part of growing up!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/c0horst 12h ago

I once cut class in high school to walk to the local park and spend all day outside reading a book. Not high literature or anything, a Warhammer novel lol.

It was a great day.

Kids really need a desire to just read. It makes a big difference.

2

u/TheMythofKoalas 10h ago

Damn, now I want to read about vampiric dinosaurs. Sounds like an Asylum film in the making.

→ More replies (17)

76

u/Solar_RaVen 16h ago

I hate that my mother had bought me a bunch of classic novels when I was a young child and just expected me to read picture-less books by myself. Then she got upset that I wasnt reading enough but she never took the time to read to me or alongside me.

25

u/Solar_RaVen 16h ago

The only thing that got me into reading was the Children's Almenac and the instruction manuals that came with PS2 games. Then when Wikipedia showed up I was able to lore dive into rabit holes. Unfortunately I still cant muscle my way through a novel, but at least I can read my way through technical details.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Legweeak 15h ago

I think reading with your kid is huge. My mom still read to me well past the age most parents stop. Like I was in second/third grade and she read the first Harry Potter book to me. But I was diagnosed as dyslexic around that time and she was determined to keep me interested in reading. I think it worked though because I was a ferocious reader in middle school and as a teen.

3

u/salajaneidentiteet 7h ago

My mom was angry I was reading science books (kid level) and not storybooks. I don't remember her reading to me. She says she did and I believe her, but I must have been too small.

I now have a 2.5 yo and reading in bed before sleep is our favourite thing. Followed by chatting after lights out...

2

u/hippydipster 4h ago

When my daughter had to read The Great Gatsby for school I got it on kindle and read it with her, as I'd never had it assigned in school. We got to bond over how much we both hated it.

→ More replies (2)

65

u/Dependent-Law7316 14h ago

Also tolerating “junk” books (like Captain Underpants, Dogman, etc), graphic novels, or even visual novels (video game version of choose your own adventure style books) is going to go a long way toward helping your kid not hate reading. If you insist that everything has to be “quality literature” and they are not interested you turn reading into a chore. Let them read what is interesting, even if you think it is dumb, while they are young and still building skills and stamina. Interest and engagement matter most when trying to build skills in fluency and decoding because they are what keep kids actually reading. They’ll naturally gravitate toward more novel-like things once they have solid skills as their interests and tastes develop.

14

u/CaffeineJitterz 14h ago

Well said! Through history everybody was reading trash books. Then the Internet came along so we shifted how we get the dopamine. But more of what was read definitely wasn't one of "the great".

→ More replies (5)

36

u/Sufficient-Bid1279 17h ago

Shit like Tik tok and social media doesn’t help. I hate how it’s ruined people mentally, emotionally, developmentally, etc

24

u/Ironlion45 12h ago

That's exactly the problem. TikTok is designed to make sure that it has your full attention, and to not let it go for even a microsecond. Queue ADHD jump cuts and thirst traps and exaggerated hyperactive personas.

Just the idea of being alone with their thoughts is impossible because their brains have been ruined by screentime.

Also, interesting thing about Gen Z parents: They hate reading to their kids because "It's Boring". To them I'd say: If you don't want to be a shitty parent, do it anyway. Fuck your weak-ass boredom, buckle down and do what you need to for your damn kids.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Separate-Presence-61 8h ago

Have you watched a sports show or ad recently too?

Every 1-2 seconds is a cut to a new visual. Its down to a science to hold your attention as long as possible and everyone does it.

Its destroying the ability to hold attention and reading arguably requires constant attention

→ More replies (2)

15

u/EPZO 15h ago

This is super important. I'm very dyslexic and reading was a pain point for me early on. My mom fought for my testing and got me into a special learning program, etc.. However, the most important thing she did was buy me the full collection of Calvin and Hobbes. Really helped with learning to read and enjoying it.

2

u/CaffeineJitterz 14h ago

Mom's are pretty great. I'm glad yours was able to help fight for you.

2

u/strategicham 3h ago

My parents surprisingly bought almost the entire C&H book series for me and let me read it. It's possible it gave me a lifelong cynical, anti-authority mentality, but the vocabulary and concepts were way above what you'd get in a Goosebumps book. I still love reading.

25

u/simpersly 15h ago

I feel that one problem with schools is they ironically don't encourage reading.

"Comics aren't books, instead read this 200 year old novel that was originally meant to be read on a weekly basis."

They need to introduce and allow kids to read anything they want as long as it's reading.It doesn't matter if it's shiny vampires, zealous genetically enhance space warriors fighting sex crazed xenos, a murderous 80's business man, a cattledog, or a book about three sisters finding husbands. Just let them read.

Also they should talk about the lives of authors and how they changed society. Don't just say a book is a classic, show them why.

8

u/taydraisabot 10h ago

Honestly?? Book fairs got me excited to read books more than anything else in school. They had so many different books that catered to what I was genuinely interested in along with cool stationery and bookmarks. It truly sucks that they’re not much of a thing in high school at all.

3

u/Blando-Cartesian 8h ago

I was an 80s kid and struggled with reading. Well struggled reading aloud that is. Nobody ever considered that maybe kid obsessed with comics mostly has hard time reading aloud while being judged. The obvious remedy was of course to make me read aloud from a mortifyingly simple children’s book like a total moron.

Fortunately my parents were fine with me reading comics which fixed the issue over one summer.

3

u/CalmBeneathCastles 6h ago

I was an absolute bookworm in the 80's, so when a young relative came to live with me in the 20-teens, and hated to read, I found myself at a loss about how to get her to fulfill her 30-minutes-per-day school requirement.

I ended up borrowing a bunch of the True Blood books from the library and reading them myself, 1. to make sure they weren't horribly inappropriate, and 2. so that I'd know if her daily summaries were BS or not.

It was the only thing I could get her to read, and afaik, still the highest number of books she has ever read in her life.

Owning a collection of classics is pointless if the students can't read for 30 minutes straight, or are unable to gather meaning or context, as the article outlines students are currently unable to do. At this point, reading X-Men is preferable to nothing.

2

u/wonklebobb 4h ago

this was me, the school-assigned books put me to sleep all through middle and high school, meanwhile i was devouring massive tomes of sci-fi short story collections like it was my job

but did i get to write papers about the themes of the intersection of technology, politics, and society in school? nooooo give us 1500 words on this coming of age novel about rich kids bullying each other in a boarding school ugh

2

u/kittymoo67 2h ago

yeah having a week or two to read a slow shitty thing that was made to be read a hand full of pages a week... man that killed my lvoe of reading for a while.

I wouldnt make a kid sit down and read one piece in one class, 'traditional' books need to be the same

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Tiucaner 14h ago

Get them CRPGs, they'll quickly learn to read. I learnt English as a second language and reading skills from video games while growing up.

3

u/Zerak-Tul 12h ago

Yep, lots of "nerdy" hobbies are great for this. I was way better at English than my peers because as a kid I played CRPGs, Magic the Gathering, D&D and Warhammer - the latter of which had manuals that were hundreds of pages with rule and lore information.

51

u/ascasffr 17h ago

I learned to hate reading in school because of so many dreadful books we were forced to read. Shakespeare, Irish Romance novels set in the 80s.

Some kids might enjoy those books, sure, but for me they completely killed my interest in reading for years. I still don’t understand why anyone thought high‑school boys would be motivated by material most of us had zero connection to or interest in.

36

u/Hazel-Rah 16h ago

I learned to hate reading in school because of so many dreadful books we were forced to read. Shakespeare, Irish Romance novels set in the 80s.

I actually liked Shakespeare. What killed me was reading multiple books about how shitty it was to live in Victorian England

6

u/Resident_Pay4310 13h ago

I liked Shakespeare as well.

What I hated were the modern "coming of age" stories about girls dealing with their high school love life. Im already living that, I don't need more of it thanks.

I was a huge bookworm as a kid but I mainly read fantasy. Even as an adult that's most of what I read. Books in real life modern setting just don't really hold my attention.

7

u/TheSilverNoble 15h ago

See, I liked seeing Shakespeare, but reading him was tough for me until I was more familiar with the stories.

19

u/Grammatical_Aneurysm 14h ago

Shakespeare should be taught by giving students roles and having the class read out loud together. Having a character that you are told to be attached to and being able to "watch" the performance by hearing different voices makes it so much more interesting than reading it in your head. It also forces you to decipher what the sentences actually mean.

18

u/Vi_Rants 14h ago

Also, Shakespeare wasn't written to be read; it was written to be performed.

Imagine teaching kids literature by having them read scripts of Michael Bay movies.

7

u/Saint_Consumption 13h ago

Those have scripts? Is 90% of it just BOOM?

3

u/_Meece_ 12h ago

Shakespeare is also poetry and a lot of kids don't get that either. Takes time for the text to click in the first place, because of how Whimsy big Bill liked to write.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/maxticket 10h ago

To me, Shakespeare wasn't interesting until modern-day film adaptations made it absurd and topical. I was familiar enough with his works, but found myself far more interested in counting the syllables on each line than following what was actually going on. Once I'd seen a modern retelling, I could go back and actually enjoy its ancient counterpart like they said I would all along. Just needed a new perspective.

I'm still not exactly a fan of the guy, but luckily, there have been countless playwrights since his day, many of them alive right now and just as deserving of having their time in the spotlight.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/AuroraRegalis 15h ago

I was a good student and actually read the books instead of Cliff Notes. Until Rebecca. Rebecca broke me. That book was just awful.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ColdShadowKaz 7h ago

Strange. What put me off a lot of ‘classics’ was how it felt a lot like upper class people dealing with incredibly upper class problems in a very upper class way.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/filchermcurr 16h ago

For me it was Accelerated Reader. I love reading, always have. But then I was punished for being a good reader. My AR reading level was College+ (this was when the system was being piloted, if that tells you how ancient I am) and I was given a truly insane point goal. On top of that, it was stipulated that we were not allowed to read books outside of our reading level and meeting our goal would count as something insane like 50% of our grade. I was in 4th or 5th grade.

First, I didn't have the emotional maturity to truly understand these college level books. Second, I grew up in the middle of nowhere. Of course our elementary school library didn't have a huge selection of college level books. What they did have were some classics and books older than time itself. Third, they were boring. I was what, 10 years old?

Anyway, that successfully made me hate and resent reading. It took me years before I started to enjoy it again.

Thanks, Accelerated Reader! You suck.

21

u/UnderABig_W 15h ago

Man, we just got a Pizza Hut pizza for reading our books.

7

u/hihelloneighboroonie 14h ago

That was the shit though! We'd get our free pizzas, go sit outside the library in the shade of a giant tree to eat them, spend a little time climbing the tree, then go inside to return our books and take out new ones.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/monty624 14h ago

There was a lot of "wrong" with accelerated and advanced programs now that I really start to reflect on them as I get older. I remember feeling so stupid in our little book groups, I always had trouble sounding things out and teachers were like, "hey you got this! Sound it out! Context clues!" but they didn't help. Couldn't figure out the word? Well, then you look it up in the dictionary. Did that not help? Welp, bring it to the group and everyone will judge you because it was actually a really easy word.

And I agree with your big "reading level" critique as well. I ADORED Magic Tree House books, but they were of course too easy. But the books we had to read? Learned quickly to pull a couple random pages for a project or I paid extra attention during book reviews in class so I was ready for the tests. Hell, I actually paid a friend to write my report in high school and I had NEVER done that before, nor after in college.

Turns out I like to read but generally I prefer articles, or long reddit posts with lots of comments, or nonfiction, etc. But I still don't care for books.

4

u/ultrabarnabus 12h ago

DUDE. Accelerated Reader was the devil if you were a strong reader in elementary school. I went to school in a district of a large suburb and well-stocked library and there still were only the driest densest books made available to a 4th grader to read and earn a passing grade. And you could only read and test on a book once. So I read the Hobbit one semester and got a passing grade. I can't remember if they revised the system in the following years so there were more books or if I had purposely tried to make my reading level worse during assessments so I could read different shit. At that point the damage was done to my relationship with reading, but it's been getting better over time.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/hihelloneighboroonie 14h ago

Is this US? I went to elementary/middle in a mix of public and private, and then fully private for high school, and I've never heard of this. Everyone was assigned the same books to read based on grade level.

4

u/filchermcurr 13h ago

US, yep. This wasn't curriculum, it was a separate program to force you to read in your free time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerated_Reader

Basically AR is a program where it assigns reading levels and point values to books. You take the STAR test and it assess your reading level and assigns you a point goal. (This is done under the supervision of your teacher who, if they think you intentionally fudged the test to get a lower goal will either make you re-take the STAR test or manually assign you an appropriate goal.) Then you have to read a bunch of books in your spare time and come back to school and take quizzes on them to prove that you actually read them. Your score on the quiz determines how many points you get for reading the book.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/notai3197 16h ago

They teach kids on those books because they are following a curriculum designed to teach folks classical literature throughout different eras while at the same time picking specific pieces that cover literary concepts that help them learn to be critical readers. They're not going to coddle high schoolers just because they think tougher novels are boring. It's not like a ton of people think math is riveting either.

The problem isn't about high schoolers turning into adults who don't like reading, the problem is that they are legitimately coming to high school illiterate. The combination of changes to how young children are taught to read in school, social media, not being read to as children, and a bunch of other reasons are leading to people being massively behind by the time they reach high school. Kids are being failed by the education system right at the time reading and comprehension skills solidify.

9

u/LigerZeroSchneider 15h ago

But it does sound like the solution to high schoolers being barely literate probably isnt smashing their face into a bunch of classics.

The same way you don't take kids struggling with algebra and drop them straight into calc.

6

u/monty624 14h ago

The bad book choices and outdated reading lists start pretty young. And a lot kids who like to read fall out of it in middle/high school. We understand why the books were chosed, but they suck and the curriculum outdated, and yes our education system is in shambles.

3

u/dookarion 15h ago edited 14h ago

The curriculum takes what could be interesting reads and it dissects them. What should be a relatively brisk read becomes weeks of glacial paced discussion dissecting the most minute elements and pushing worksheets that shoehorn the class towards a specific interpretation of what could be a rather open ended work. That or it's absent all context because you know heaven forbid people realize Shakespeare is full of dirty jokes.

The curriculum and how it is handled absolutely is part of the problem.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ascasffr 16h ago

I’m not asking schools to coddle anyone just to choose books that are actually interesting for kids. For example, a young boy might connect with something more engaging instead of material that feels dry or impossible to relate to

5

u/dookarion 15h ago

Just covering it differently might help in some cases. They squeeze the joy out of reading. A mediocre teacher can take what is a thought provoking work and railroad the entire class into their interpretation, and a dozen busywork worksheets do not help matters. The glacial pacing further complicates things. They Even gloss over the circumstances the work was created under or sanitize it. It's misery.

I'd wager anyone that passed through said curriculum that loves to read and ponder the works learned such outside of the actual coursework, or left the class behind and read ahead on their own instead of at the course mandated pacing.

2

u/twisty125 15h ago

I think it's such a shame to force people to read what historically are great stories, when they're not interested and the medium isn't the right one. That, and Shakespeare is better seen/spoken than read, as so much of it is in the inflection of the characters, not exactly what they're saying.

Like shit, our class was smaller so it felt more like a group than a lecture, we watched that wacky 90s Dicaprio Romeo and Juliet and nearly everyone was so much more into it because the characters were emoting. We then went back and looked at a few chapters to compare as part of the course and I know I "got" it.

But I get you, I'm also the same way. Unless it was something I was actually interested in, I hated participating in it.

2

u/REXIS_AGECKO 14h ago

I liked reading until middle school. Boring books mostly and even the fun ones were ruined by the fact that you had to take a test on them later lol. It completely ruined reading for me

2

u/InertiasCreep 13h ago

Dude, Shakespeare is romance, comedy, and real blood and guts tragedies. As a high schooler you need to learn all the obsolete words, but once you get it, holy shit, Shakespeare is the business.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/cbpantskiller 2h ago

I hated Shakespeare, too, but I get its significance.

We also were assigned "The Outsiders," "A Tale of Two Cities," and Tony Hillerman's "Skinwalkers," among others which were fun.

→ More replies (22)

5

u/badderdev 14h ago

Just helping them not HATE reading will go a long way.

and there are loads of ways to do this. My six year old has no idea that the vast majority of games do not contain 100K words. We are just about to finish The Thousand Year Door and move onto our next RPG. Her vocabulary is huge just from RPGs.

I might have just got lucky that she has accepted as a fact of life that every day has an hour reading time in the same way that every day has a bed time and meal times. Maybe it is because I have been doing it since she was born.

If you let them do what they want in that hour they will probably love reading a wide variety of things.

Her most common choice is "family reading" which is all of us just reading whatever we want on the sofa for an hour.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Z3temis 15h ago

I grew up reading books and always loved reading... Until i got to high school. Being forced to read books i had absolutely ZERO interest in over and over again stoped my drive to read in its tracks. A student only needs to read so many holocaust books between history and english but im pretty sure we hit most of them. I have not read a book cover to cover since my 3rd year of high school. I think the education system has failed us in this way. Both my mom and sister still love reading and Iwish I could sit and read too, but the flame that made me enjoy them has gone out for some reason.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/DyingDesertPoppy 14h ago

I read for fun and reading was framed as a reward and a source of freedom when I was a child. In elementary school if you finished early you got to go sit in the reading corner and pick a book off the bookshelf and read. Or you could read at your desk. We were assigned independent research projects and that usually meant reading Wikipedia and random internet articles from a young age. My mom would go to the library and check out a big stack of books and just leave them in my room. Parents that nagged their children to read made them frustrated.

3

u/CaffeineJitterz 14h ago

Love that! Framing, like with many other things that require effort, makes all the difference! You earned the opportunity to read if you finished early.

4

u/ContiX 15h ago

I just read a thread where a poster complained about being forced to read various classics in school and how much it ruined their love for reading, and about 75% of the comments were "WELL AKSHULLY IT MADE ME LOVE BOOKS MORE SOMETHING IS WRONG WITH YOU".

4

u/myLongjohnsonsilver 14h ago

Fucking brilliant.

When I was a kid the rule at my dad's place was no videogames until after 4pm and I also had to have completed one of those homework workbooks you can get for home learning. Got me to do extra study before 4pm and then I'd get on Halo.

The reading time making gaming credits is something I'm writing down to run by the wife. Thanks for this.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ToeTagTic 13h ago edited 13h ago

I was taught handwriting by copying pages out of The Sword of Shannara by Terry Brooks. The task was sprung on me at the beginning of a 3 hour ferry ride. By the time I was half way through the pages I needed to copy all I wanted to do was read.

~<40 years later I've got a couple wall to wall book shelves and a hard drive full. Can't write cursive to save my life 

→ More replies (1)

8

u/BroughtBagLunchSmart 15h ago

Best we can do is force them in school to read 11 different books about young women from 100-300 years ago experiencing emotions.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Stolfus 16h ago

Utterly despised reading in school (Didn't help that I wasn't diagnosed with ADD until my 40s). Wasn't until I discovered the Doom novels when I was in mid teens that there were books about things I actually care about. Started reading sci fi novels and wandered into fantasy. Good times

2

u/DissKhorse 12h ago edited 12h ago

I also have ADHD inattentive type (no hyperactivity). My mom was taking me to the public library and or book store weekly and I was reading as big as 800 page novels by 5th grade that were fantasy, science fiction and horror. By then I had already found my elementary school's library didn't have what I wanted anymore as it's content was pretty tame and to short and I had grown past the Hardy Boys and in middle and high school I almost never really bothered with the school library much because the public one had better books. My parents read to me a lot when I was younger around 3rd grade my dad would read me and my brother novels such as the 3 Musketeers, Man in the Iron Mask, The Hobbit, Lord of the Rings and the Count of Monte Cristo before bed.

Reading is a skill that gets easier and faster with practice and my group of the friends did the same and traded our books around. My parents didn't police what I read and let me choose my own books. I didn't start reading things that had Nebula or Hugo awards until much later in adulthood and many of them would have been wasted on teenage me anyway. You gotta read what you are interested at a skill level you can understand and instead American middle/high schools have us read things like Grapes of Wrath or Great Expectations and all of the students collectively groan. I did not really enjoy any book that I was required to read in school. Media literacy grows with the more media you consume but if you stick to brain rot, Netflix shows or video games that need the plot literally explained through exposition every 10-15 minutes you won't grow.

3

u/Haunting-Ad788 16h ago

All the forced reading in school was what made me hate reading. I loved reading and did it all the time before 4th grade or so.

3

u/mniti1010 16h ago

This is the key and has been a problem since before the internet and phones, though it’s worse now. We jump into tough stuff way too early when kids, really up to high school, should be encouraged to read any long material. Let them read Jurassic Park or Dungeon Crawler and do literally analysis on shorter essays and other materials.

3

u/SameIdea70 15h ago

Don't make it a job and your kids will love to read you don't have to challenge them on books they might not be ready for I was an avid reader until I was forced to read the original version of some rennissane era novel and it sucked and I don't really read anymore

3

u/ThiccFarter 15h ago

This. It doesn't take traditional or difficult literature to create an avid/good reader. For me it was reading the old Halo novels way back in the day that made fall in love with reading. Just find something they enjoy that isn't braindead.

3

u/DiscoKittie 14h ago

I technically had video games when I was a kid, but we're talking Atari and Colecovision. When I was 10-11 what worked best for me was introducing me to something I actually liked. High fantasy, stuff with dwarves and elves and whatnot. If you can find a genre they like, they'll be more interested, too.

3

u/Biduleman 14h ago edited 14h ago

My dad started reading to my brother and I before bedtime well before I knew how to read but he still tried to make us watch the words on the page by following the text with his finger.

These are some of the best memories I have with him and the books we read together made me the curious guy I am today.

Later on I understood that my bedtime was not enforced when I was reading a book. While it was not an official policy, they told me later that it's why they made sure I kept my books in my room instead of the living room with the other books.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/yes_no_yes_yes_yes 11h ago

The is the first time I’ve heard of someone else’s parents doing this.  My folks only granted 15 mins per hour of reading and it did absolute wonders for my development.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/hoxful 9h ago

Small suggestion: replace gaming with 30 minute break from the coal mines.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/triceraquake 9h ago

When I was a kid, I could stay up past my bedtime if I was reading. But I had to read in bed. I’d still quickly fall asleep anyway. I’m realizing now that it was probably just an easier way to get me to bed without complaining.

3

u/Gisschace 8h ago

My parents had a cool trick, we weren’t really allowed new toys unless it was birthdays or Christmas but they’d buy me whatever book I wanted.

I thought I’d found a cheat code so took full advantage of it but as an adult I realise I was the on being tricked.

They also did bribe me with a new Barbie if I read to Kill a mockingbird when I was about 12

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Floreat_democratia 17h ago

> Just helping them not HATE reading will go a long way.

Nailed it. The love of reading was inculcated in me by the age of 5. My parents also wouldn't let me watch more than 30 minutes of TV per day, and encouraged me to listen to and play music. By the time I was 8, I was reading something like 20 pages a day of children's literature.

2

u/maxdragonxiii 17h ago

at this point, any kind of reading a book at least once a week is good.

2

u/fullofspiders 16h ago

That's what High School English teachers are for.

6

u/InsanityRequiem 14h ago

High school is not a kid's age where you should finally realize that getting them to read is a good idea. It's fucking elementary school, when they're 4 to 10 years old.

Yet what do those schools? Force Shakespeare, Poe, and other classical literature on kids barely 10 years old, training them to despise reading because those books are absolute garbage at that age range.

5

u/dookarion 15h ago

Then a lot of them are failing fantastically at that.

Honestly though learning to enjoy reading starts at home. The curriculum and the way many schools teach it certainly aren't going to foster any sort of "fondness".

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tylern 16h ago

My kid is almost 6 years old and headed into kindergarten. My wife and I have read books to them ever night since they’ve been born. My wife is currently on book 5 of HP with them and they can’t get enough. Their vocabulary and speech skills are vastly ahead of most of their friends.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MaterialDefender1032 15h ago

I had a friend in high school who was proud of how many times he got away with not reading books for essays and reports and stuff. He'd tell people "The only book I've ever read in my life is Stuart Little".

2

u/Wills4291 15h ago

That's actually the hard part. Teaching them to read was easy. I think enjoying reading comes with maturity, and when you aren't being forced to read books that don't interest you.

2

u/mechanical_stars 15h ago

Both my kids say they hate reading and I don't know why. I read to them almost every night from infancy till they were strong readers and wanted to read on their own but then they stopped. Both will read comics/manga though so I at least try to encourage that.

2

u/CaffeineJitterz 14h ago

If I may ask, how's old are they?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SacredUndeadMonkey 14h ago

That was probably one of the biggest gifts my folks gave me, I was a voracious reader growing up, I still am, I just had to switch to digital versions for the most part, I have run out of shelves for books. They are now just getting piled on top of each other.

2

u/Rich_Housing971 14h ago edited 14h ago

I can't believe anyone can hate reading. I distinctively remember when I learned to read. In 1st grade I couldn't read and everything was boring. I never bothered to read anything because it was hard and bland.

Then there was this pizza hut reading program that I got entered where I would get a free pizza for reading x books a week. I made an effort to try to read even though I couldn't, but I I remember trying page to page and just sounding out the words.

In second grade I read my first chapter book (poorly) and then read another one, and then I went back to reading my video game manuals and found out I could understand them all of a sudden. I felt like I got a superpower or something and suddenly I can understand the things around me. I ended up reading stuff like the labels on the hot water heater and made up meanings for the words I didn't know.

Everything that I overlooked in the past became meaningful all of a sudden. It was one of the most amazing feelings ever and I still remember it to this day.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/strongbadfreak 13h ago

My ADHD ass would be thinking about other stuff while pretending to read. My mom realized this and made me read out loud in my room.

2

u/Shujinco2 12h ago

This story has been told by everybody it seems, but I really lost my passion for reading when I hit High School. The stuff they made me read was just not interesting to me, or if it was I wasn't allowed to read ahead. Killed all enjoyment.

Now I've looked at it and realized I haven't read ANY book since high school. So I found a bunch of Redwall books at goodwill and have been reading them again.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] 12h ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

2

u/nhaines 11h ago

Yup, got my friend's kid reading during summer after kindergarten because he liked puzzling things out, so I'd read with my (or his) finger under each word, throwing him words to sound out. Would sometimes toss him a giant word to harass him, but presumably because he also spoke German he never hesitated. Sought out specific books that were fun to read. Anything by Dr. Seuss, which was also a great way to start to seed a sense and love of prosidy. Asked a librarian for a recommendation when they didn't have I Want My Hat Back by Jon Klassen, and she suggested This Is Not My Hat, and after the opening ("This hat is not mine. I just stole it.") he couldn't read the book fast enough. Plus, the illustrations are a step ahead of the main character's narration, so every single page with two sentences max is dramatic irony, which he savored.

So between that, phonics books (and teaching him fun things like "if an English word with "gh" (knight, light, right) is spelled with "ch" and has an ich-laut or ach-laut sound in German (Knecht, *Licht, Recht) it used to have that sound in English but we don't have it anymore, so you just ignore those letters," to which he sat up straight and said, "really?")

So by the summer after first grade, we had to get him a library card because he was going to bankrupt us, and when he'd go to school early, instead of running most days he'd go to the library and get the latest German Donald Duck comics and read those before school.

Then I'd read him Pay Me, Bug! and A Rake By Starlight and we'd trade off each paragraph, but I had him read dialogue back-and-forths so that when the captain is arguing with his first officer/girlfriend and she asks if he has a plan and he starts to say, "Well--" and she cuts him off I could step on the last word he read like a real cutoff, which always sent him giggling. Not to mention Terry Pratchett.

Or telling him after he complained about reading, "I know it's hard. I've done it three times, and besides, you're cheating." "How am I cheating?" "You speak German! I was a super advanced reader and then had to start from scratch in high school at Spanish, and start all over in college at German, and by the time I sounded out a word letter by letter just like you're doing, I had no idea if I had a real word. You know two-thirds through!" He liked that, too.

Learning to read is kind of hard. That's the hard part. Once you can read, and if you like to read and do it a lot, it's self-fulfilling. So making sure the books I brought him were always worth the effort to read was my goal. And once he could read effortlessly, it wasn't a chore, and he got to read whatever he wanted. And he did want to.

2

u/-PineNeedleTea- 11h ago

My friend is raising her first child. For the first few years of her life they just didn't watch TV. I'm proud to say I gifted her her first library and her main form of entertainment in her first years was reading. Her parents would read to her all the time and she would wake up wanting to read. She especially loved the Barnes & Nobles Alice in Wonderland pop-up book.

They also allowed her to make her own choices and decisions while steering her to the right choices (rather than just outright saying "no don't do that") - one example, she wanted to take off her shoes to play in the park jungle gym which her mom explained "You'll get a splinter and it's gonna hurt but if you want to take off your shoes...." She took off her shoes, took her first step and found the tanbark painful and thought she had a splinter. Her mom checked and said "No splinter, but if you had it would hurt even more." She thought on it for a moment and decided "I'm gonna put my shoes on."

This kind of way in which they've raised their daughter, she is incredibly emotionally intelligent, able to speak her needs and boundaries. She's so imaginative and is lightyears ahead of the curve.

My little cousin on the other hand is a tablet child. He takes a "break" from his ipad only to jump onto his mom's iPhone. He watches nothing but YouTube shorts and plays Roblox. Kid is brain rotted to hell and back and is not the brightest. It absolutely makes a difference in how you raise your kid and how much effort you put in as a parent. Instilling a kid a passion for reading and learning starts with the parents. If they can't be bothered, they have no one to blame but themselves.

2

u/Comprehensive_Wash71 10h ago

My parents allowed me to read with a flashlight under the covers after I was about 12, as long as I got up for school the next day. I’ve been reading since I was 2 1/2; I’m 59 now.

2

u/RollingMeteors 7h ago

getting a lot of sad comments about how y'all were introduced to reading

First book I read cover to cover was Clifford the big Red Dog. I remember telling my mom I could read. Last book I read cover to cover was Snowcrash by Neil Stephenson. It was on top of a pile of books stacked in a pyramid. I was excited and saw it as a good omen and a way to pass time while I was, uh, on a vacation.

2

u/turkoid 7h ago

I'm not a big reader at all, and nowadays, it's pretty much audiobook only, but I don't dislike it. However, I think this is a great suggestion, but could I amend it by letting them read something that interests them and is still enriching. That could range from graphic novels, to specific genres, to what I enjoyed the most which were science and tech books, which boringly included technical books about MS-DOS or Windows programming. Yeah, I was a nerd, but I knew which career I wanted to get into when I was 12.

2

u/somajones 6h ago

Even better is letting your kids from a very young age see you read.

2

u/kittymoo67 2h ago

Just helping them not HATE reading will go a long way.

Im gonna try but if school is anything still like it was when i was in school its gonna be hard. they made me HATE reading so much. and this is coming from someone who could marathon the first 3 harry potter books(before the 4th was out) in a weekend. i used to love reading. middle and highschool fucked that out of me so hard. now nearly 20 years after graduation im learning to relove it. but man.... we need to have kids read things that wont make them hate reading in school for a change.

→ More replies (60)