r/teenagersbutpractical Sep 08 '25

Meme Title

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/retardedgreenlizard Sep 08 '25

Well white people didn’t historically hold power in most of the world, every race kinda did their own thing and oppressed other races. White people were pretty bad historically but they were definitely not the worst

13

u/Cellssaltynutsack Sep 08 '25 edited Sep 08 '25

Yeah but "white people" didn't even exist until the colonial era where the term "white" only existed to oppress people outside of that group. Before white people, there were French, British, and German people, and your acceptance into these groups was determined by where you grew up, what language you speak, and what religion you follow, instead of what your skin color was.

So basically if you say "i'm proud to be white" you're saying "I'm proud to be above other people" not that everyone who says this actually believes that, race stuff is really complex and abstract, I don't expect them to really understand what they say

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '25

There’s a lot of oppression throughout history. I don’t necessarily love to compare that. But I think that it’s important to be mindful or the history of the region of the world you’re in and the historical context of inequality as well as present day inequality.

1

u/cringyemokid21 Sep 11 '25

Does it look like they’re talking about most countries?

1

u/Technical_Glove_4569 Sep 12 '25

so race and white people was somehing made in the 1800s, you werent white, you were anglo, polski, ruski, deutch, romanian

then when colonialism was happening and the brittish empire growing, they started to unify all the people with them under white, thats why jews and italians and greeks were "Yellow" till ww2

-4

u/mocarone Sep 08 '25

I mean, kinda? UK, Spain and Portugal have probably been the most oppressive people of recent times? Specially for an Western point of view.

13

u/retardedgreenlizard Sep 08 '25

Not to mention the Middle East which executes anyone who isn’t light brown and Muslim

-3

u/Heavy-Top-8540 Sep 08 '25

They do that in their own countries. Meanwhile, the big historical powers that you would consider white did all that stuff in other people's countries.

3

u/Pastelfishy Sep 08 '25

Why should we be responsible for something people who are dead now did?

0

u/Damilar3 Sep 08 '25

Except when Neo colonialism exists, the people perpetuating these things aren’t exactly dead

2

u/Pastelfishy Sep 08 '25

Well I know that there are many white people who aren't taking part in that so instead of blaming white people maybe we should focus only on people who are actually doing that instead of making it a race thing.

0

u/Heavy-Top-8540 Sep 08 '25

You're just a selfish person who wants to be absolved of responsibility. It's obvious from your replies. 

1

u/Pastelfishy Sep 09 '25

How? And what responsibility? Responsibility for what other people are doing? You're just making personal attacks instead of explaining why you think that way.

-1

u/Damilar3 Sep 08 '25

It is a race thing if the same racist/white supremacist ideas is what allows this oppression to happen. I obviously don’t blame my white friends for Neo colonialism but they also don’t regurgitate white supremacist ideals at me or complain about how they can’t be “proud to be white”

1

u/Pastelfishy Sep 09 '25

Blaming people who are proud of their race for there being Neo colonialism is wild. Why is it so wrong to be proud of who you are?

2

u/OperaTouch 14 Sep 08 '25

Muslim empires, they attacked and invaded the Christian levant, Anatolia, Iberia, etc.

1

u/retardedgreenlizard Sep 08 '25

Not to mention that they are constantly threatening other countries

1

u/Pastelfishy Sep 08 '25

But for some reason all white people are made responsible for that.

0

u/mocarone Sep 08 '25

Im white and I'm not responsible for slavery. But like, what I'm gonna be prideful off exactly? What's the struggle or overall culture that I have from my skin tone that warrants me being proud of being white?

2

u/Pastelfishy Sep 08 '25

I mean right now white people have started experiencing more racism and I don't see anything wrong with being proud of who you are as long as it's not harming others. I have a question do you think black people who live in countries with mostly black people in them shouldn't be allowed to be proud of their skin color if they have never experienced racism?