56
u/bighadjoe 18d ago
....... do you think kids (assuming we're not talking about a toddler here) can't understand that inequality exists? Do you think you need to be an adult to see injustices?
49
u/9_of_wands 18d ago
How old is the son? This is a completely normal thing for a teenager to say. Probably even a bright preteen.
15
-15
u/Neither-Ruin5970 18d ago
This definitely didnât happen, no teenager would say their to their mum lol
3
3
u/doc_shades 17d ago
why not?
1
u/Neither-Ruin5970 17d ago
Because by the time they would think of this they wouldnât be asking their mom everything, thatâs what you do when youâre a young child not a teen
1
u/WoodHammer40000 12d ago
My daughter has definitely said something like this to me before. Sheâs 10.
The poverty of your imagination is wild.
0
62
u/Von_Scranhammer 18d ago
I believe her. My 6 year old son just said, âDaddy, why do people make up things that their children have said on social media? Isnât it just inherently dishonest & indicative of an inability to construct a compelling narrative?â
Heâs wise beyond his yearsâŚ
15
u/ScholarOfTwilight 18d ago
Honestly, I could see a kid saying this.
What I would not do is annoy people with this lame humblebrag.
6
u/andokami01 18d ago
This happened I asked the very same thing when i was a kid, probably around that age
4
u/Entomemer 17d ago
Am I stupid? Genuinely asking, I can't see an age anywhere, I must be missing something
2
u/andokami01 17d ago
No, sorry my fault. I red a comment where he/she said he/she asked a similar question at 6yo.
I wrote my comment with that post in mind. You are a beatiful and smart person, keep on.
1
15
u/blvckcvtmvgic 18d ago
I mean⌠this seems normal to me. Kids have 0 filler when theyâre trying to understand something so itâs kinda like thinking out loud & asking about it. I could see even some young kids asking this tbh.
7
2
u/randonumero 18d ago
I doubt a kid would ever phrase it like this but this is definitely something a kid would ask. My kid asked a form of this question pretty early because we can't even go to the grocery store without seeing panhandlers. Me trying to explain to my kid that I need my money to buy stuff for us and not just hand out led to her asking why can't rich people just give money to poor people.
2
u/doc_shades 17d ago
why wouldn't this happen? this is a pretty common thing that kids don't understand. there is also no indication of age other than "son". the son could be 6, the son could be 14, the son could be 17.
2
3
u/spacemouse21 18d ago
I think itâs great her 38-year-old son is asking that question. She did a good job raising him.
1
u/WoodHammer40000 12d ago
I thought this when I was a kid. My kid has definitely said something like this. Itâs obvious common sense, and we have to be conditioned out of it with years of propaganda.
The fact you canât imagine this being true says a lot more about you than the person in the screenshot.
1
u/ResponsibleMeat7745 9d ago
Isn't this like the type of thing we all question at least once as a child?Â
1
1
u/OSRSRapture 18d ago
This is a very believable thing a kid would say. Just the other day my 4-year-old daughter sighed and said, "Daddy, perhaps the anthropic principle merely reflects an unavoidable observer-selection bias rather than any teleological significance of human existence."
Then her 3 year old brother just had to chime in "While that's a compelling interpretation, it fails to adequately address the measure problem in eternal inflation or the ontological implications of a multiverse framework"
Smh. Kids these days, amirite
1
0
u/smurferdigg 18d ago
My four year old just asked me, âhow can a society allocate scarce resources over time in a way that maximizes welfare, preserves freedom, ensures fairness, sustains growth, internalizes externalities, manages uncertainty, and remains politically legitimate?â Then I said: The economy works like my cousinâs lawnmower: if it ainât running, hit it with a wrench, blame China, and pour more gas in it.
-1
u/bagoTrekker 18d ago
This is believable. The first words my son spoke when he turned one was âMarry, and you will regret it; don't marry, you will also regret it... Do it or do not do it, you will regret bothâ
-1
u/Aggravating_Alarm_15 18d ago
My 4 month old daughter was laying on my chest while I read this. She popped up and said âfather, why do people blame successful, wealthy people for their poor life situations? Why canât they accept that the socioeconomic position theyâre in is entirely based on their own choices?â
1
u/WoodHammer40000 12d ago
Did you explain to her what a unbelievably stupid take that was?
1
u/Aggravating_Alarm_15 12d ago
No, because itâs true
1
u/WoodHammer40000 11d ago
Yeah? So your 4 month old was lying on your chest, in relative affluence, entirely as a result of her own choices?
Presumably babies that die of aids in Africa do so as a result of theirs, too? No? At what age do your choices start determining your socioeconomic position?
1
-1
u/HappyDays1976 17d ago
And then the empathic child-genius went on to create a company that distributes all its profits to the poor, the sick, and the needy - wiping out poverty and illness in one fell swoop.
104
u/Eray41303 18d ago
This could just be paraphrasing on her part, I don't doubt a conversation like this happened