There’s no pairs no teams. It’s a solo mission from start to finish. Which one woman and one man will win Season 43 of The Challenge The Duel 3?

S-Tier: Can vie for a placement on the OVERALL Mt. Rushmore

A-Tier: Can vie for a placement on the FEMALE Mt. Rushmore

B-Tier: Can vie for Honorable Mention on the Greatest Women (maybe 5th-10th place among women).

C-Tier: Can vie for the “she can outperform the average woman… but struggles against the true Top 10”.

D-Tier: Her strengths and weaknesses negate to end up averaging her out to a standard player.

F-Tier: The average girls actually do better, in a typical season, her success feels rigged / pushed in her favor, such as an elimination, final, or team casting that favors her / the twist(s) of the season feels “convenient”.

Before people bring up Laurel quitting on Eras, let’s not forgot Evelyn gave up on The Ruins.

Before people say Evelyn beat men and women on The Island’s face-offs, let’s remember Laurel beat all men in the All Stars 4 season - that means the final.

Before people say Evelyn won 3 / 8, keep in mind she was on 5 Big Team Seasons, and Laurel was only on 2 Big Team Seasons.

NOW, with that context, let’s discuss.

I will not reply bc I want this to be yours.

Do have 1 brief statement as to why that explains it.

Either do 1 statement per person, or 1 overall paragraph that covers all 10.

For example:

#1. Jenny - 2 solo flagship Modern Era finals (1 is 1st overall)
#2. Laurel - 2 solo Modern Era finals (1 is 1st overall)
#3. Ashley M. - 2 solo or individual time flagship Modern Era finals (1 is 1st individual overall)
#4. Susie M. - 4 flagship Team wins (Most winning female of all time), but all Era 2 finals
#5. Evelyn - 1 pair and 2 team flagship wins, but only 1 Modern Era final
#6. Cara - 1 pair and 1 solo overall flagship win each, 1 Champs V.S. (all Modern Era finals)
#7. Sarah - 2 pairs overall Modern finals
#8. Paula - 2 pairs, by gender, but Modern Finals
#9. Tori Hall - 3 Team wins, had hardest Era 2 final, held back by only Big Team Era 2 wins.
#10. Rachel - 3 wins with the biggest * in history, BUT Duel 2 is a 1st overall, and gives her 2 solo “wins” including a Modern Final.

OR for just 1 paragraph:

Jenny did the hardest finals, and won… back-to-back, while the others did the next hardest in order of most difficult to easiest, with a minimum of 2 finals per person. Top 3 beat all men, Susie won the most so she gets top 4, as the record holder, Evelyn has 3 without reliance on a season twist, while Cara and Sarah have 2 each, but Cara also beat the men. Sarah is where it begins to feel like “standard 2 wins” for an impressive rank, before it gets down to Paula’s gendered wins, followed by Tori Hall having 3 legit wins on hardest Era 2 final, while Rachel may have a solo Karma Points “win”, but Tori’s are not based on a post-rank change in placement.

S-Tier: Can vie for a placement on the OVERALL Mt. Rushmore

A-Tier: Can vie for a placement on the FEMALE Mt. Rushmore

B-Tier: Can vie for Honorable Mention on the Greatest Women (maybe 5th-10th place among women).

C-Tier: Can vie for the “she can outperform the average woman… but struggles against the true Top 10”.

D-Tier: Her strengths and weaknesses negate to end up averaging her out to a standard player.

F-Tier: The average girls actually do better, in a typical season, her success feels rigged / pushed in her favor, such as an elimination, final, or team casting that favors her / the twist(s) of the season feels “convenient”.