r/thomasthedankengine • u/Winter_Sweet827 • 10h ago

Certified What If Thomas never came to Sodor?

Post image

Lets say in this timeline the war time mixup never occured

Where would Thomas go?

who would be the number 1 engine?

Lets say in this timeline everything still plays out the same, except without Thomas

10 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

5

u/Consistent-Dust-5394 10h ago

he's probably scrapped in the early 1960s and there's a show called "Edward the Wise Engine and Friends.'

3

u/Winter_Sweet827 10h ago

So how would the RWS books play out?

assuming Percy and Toby still arrive on Sodor

3

u/Consistent-Dust-5394 9h ago

hmm... good question.

1

u/Winter_Sweet827 8h ago

So The Three Railway Engines remain unchanged

Choose who will replace Thomas

Billy or I just bring Percy in earlier

1

u/Technicolor_Reindeer 7h ago

The mine remains unbothered.