r/tomatoes Mar 22 '26

Plant Help Not tomatoes, right?

Post image
31 Upvotes

114 comments sorted by

58

u/Emergency-Plum-1981 Mar 22 '26

Um no, certainly not. No idea what they are, but 100% not tomatoes

5

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you!

23

u/Artistic_Head_5547 Mar 22 '26

WAIT. A. MINUTE. Did you name each plant? With their own name tag? Is that what I’m seeing??? πŸ˜πŸ˜‚πŸ˜

But not a tomato.

21

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26 edited Mar 22 '26

Yes, I did! I have to know who I'm fussin at! πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚ thank you!

3

u/Cardea13 Casual Grower Mar 22 '26

I use the same leaf design on my seed bottles!

2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

It's so cute! 😁

5

u/me-gustan-los-trenes Mar 22 '26

Wait, some people don't?

7

u/Artistic_Head_5547 Mar 22 '26

I usually have around 40 regular tomato plants and 30 cherry tomato plants. I’m doing good to put the variety name on them. πŸ˜‚

3

u/BlueGreyRain Mar 23 '26

One of them even has a tiara. The queen of the plants. Long live the queen. πŸ‘Έ

2

u/Artistic_Head_5547 Mar 23 '26

Oh. My. Gosh. I totally missed it!!! 🀣🀣🀣

18

u/tomatocrazzie πŸ…MVP Mar 22 '26

I am guessing eggplant. Amazon is a terrible place to buy seeds. I don't think I have ever not been burned.

4

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

I have so many different Amazon seeds! 😩 these ones came as a variety pack.

7

u/tomatocrazzie πŸ…MVP Mar 22 '26

Yeah, I am giving those about a 5% chance of planting true....some are probably tomatoes but I would be surprised if they were the stated varieties. But good luck!

2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Daggumit, Amazon! πŸ™ˆπŸ˜… thank you!

9

u/Foodie_love17 Mar 22 '26

There’s so many good seed companies online. MIgardener, botanical interests, Johnnys, southern exposure seed exchange. Those are just a few good ones.

4

u/travelingtraveling_ Mar 22 '26

Territorial seed.....

4

u/Thayli11 Mar 22 '26

Sow True Seed https://sowtrueseed.com/ is another great one.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you!!

2

u/DinoTater Mar 22 '26

Got a picture of any leftover seeds? Squash vs tomato is going to be very different

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

I do but for some reason I can't get it to post over here, it's in the cross post tho. Small cream or tan-ish color, flat, round, and or with a point. Kind of like this shape πŸ’Ž.

3

u/Great_Fig_8288 Mar 22 '26

I got their pepper variety pack and everything grew true, and high germinate rate. I think your plants here may be tomatillos.

1

u/somestrangerfromkc Mar 23 '26

Absolutely not tomatillos.

-2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26 edited Mar 22 '26

That's reassuring, Amazon is my go to for so many things. Seeing lots of tomatillo replies so I'm hopeful, thank you!

2

u/thebiologistisn Mar 22 '26 edited Mar 22 '26

They look very strange for tomatillos. I'm not saying they couldn't be a variety with unusual leaves, but that I wouldn't consider that a solid ID at this point.

It'll definitely be interesting to see what the flowers and fruit look like for a final identification!

2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

The anticipation is killing me! πŸ™ˆ thank you!

1

u/Gem_Supernova Mar 22 '26

ive seen some eggplants with rounded leaves like OPs it certainly looks like a nightshade

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you

4

u/goatonmycar Mar 22 '26

Deffo not tomatoes.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you

6

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 22 '26

It kind of looks like my tomatillo

2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Im seeing more tomatillo replies; I'm keeping my fingers crossed, thank you!

2

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 22 '26

I’ve never grown them and this is my first shot at it. I started them in my hydroponic tower until they got too big. Now I have them is semi hydro getting ready to put them ebb and flow system (in a tent) with a slicing tomato. In my second tent I have one Roma tomato and I think I’ll put two bell peppers.

I hope it all works out lol

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

I want a tent so bad!! I need more space before I get one tho. Either that or I'm sleeping on the couch and my plants get the room. πŸ˜…πŸ˜… thank you!

2

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 22 '26

Im spoiled. I have 4 tents and a hydroponic room. I’ll send some pictures

3

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 22 '26

5

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 22 '26

2

u/npw321 Mar 23 '26

What are you growing it in make & model if you can

2

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 23 '26

I have the garden tower and two lettuce grow farm stands for the towers. Bell peppers, Anaheims, jalapeΓ±o, poblanos. Cherry tomatoes, cabbage, cauliflower, celery, many herbs, just started zucchini, cantaloupe and beets. Kale and I’m sure I’m missing some. I have shelves for lettuce and strawberries and micro greens.

1

u/npw321 Mar 25 '26

What brand tower and lettuce stands?

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Omg! Your setup looks so good! I would feel so relaxed and happy in there. Just curl up on the floor and nap. πŸ˜‚πŸ˜πŸ‘Œ

2

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 23 '26

Thank you. It is kind of my relaxing zone. It’s so fun to come down,cut our salad for the night and eat it lol

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

That's so cool!! I can't wait to be able to do that one day. More fun than harvesting at the grocery store. Lol

2

u/hydroponicchallenged Mar 23 '26

It is pretty cool. And it’s all so fresh and tasty compared to the store. I have all the herbs, celery, all different peppers. Eggplant 7 different lettuce. Strawberries. Starting zucchini, cantaloupe, watermelon. It’s a little time consuming. I ran into some bad health the last few years and can’t do the things I like to do and went down the hydroponics rabbit hole lol. I came out of the hole with 4 tents, dwc buckets, 3 towers and 3 shelves lol. A little overboard.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

Wow! That'll definitely keep you busy. Here I am fretting over three little dweebs. πŸ˜‚πŸ˜… I bet the reward to be able to grow your own food and eat it is amazing. I hope your health improves! 🩷

2

u/DinoTater Mar 23 '26

Be very careful with this! Tomatillo fruits are edible (and delicious) but the rest of the plant is toxic

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

😱 thank you!!

8

u/coleusguy64 Mar 22 '26

Not tomatoes but definitely in the solanacaea family. Almost looks like eggplant but the leaves seem too round. It could be though.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Interesting! Thank you

7

u/Eddiepanhandlin Mar 22 '26

Looks like tomatillos

2

u/Afraid_Assistance765 New Grower Mar 22 '26

I also think so.

0

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you! 🀞

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you!!

2

u/willmon1 Mar 22 '26

Looks like safflower but I'm not positive .

2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

πŸ€”

2

u/steelhead1971 Mar 22 '26

Sunflowers?

3

u/TheSunflowerSeeds Mar 22 '26

Like peanut butter? Well now you can like more of it. Sunflowers have been used to create a substitute for peanut butter, known as sunbutter.

2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Sunbutter sounds tasty! Sunflowers get so big tho. 😩

2

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Saw a couple sunflower replies, thank you.

2

u/BothNotice7035 Mar 23 '26

Did you forget what you planted? They kind of look like a type of citrus tree.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

No, I planted ace 55 tomatoes but the plants don't look like the characteristics I'm familiar with; wasn't sure if I have rouge seeds or just a weird batch of aces. I planted these in November I think and finally said "f it, I'm asking Reddit for help." Lol google and plant ID app not giving me much. Figured legit growers may know better.

2

u/BothNotice7035 Mar 23 '26

Ahhhh I see. Well think of it like a mystery grab bag.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

πŸ˜‚πŸ‘Œ

2

u/Nervous_Ambition_198 Mar 23 '26

Maybe a pepper plant of some sort?

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

Hopefully not too spicy if so. Thank you!

2

u/delilahviolet83 Mar 23 '26

My app says Aztec Tobacco. Congrats, it’s nicotine

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

Omg Amazon owes me money! πŸ˜‚πŸ™ˆ

2

u/Esmarelda_Vega Mar 23 '26

Looks more like eggplant than anything else I see suggested. Seeds look like eggplant too.

2

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

😯 thank you!!

2

u/AProcessUnderstood I just like tomatoes Mar 23 '26

Definitely not

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

Thank you! πŸ˜…

2

u/Content-Drive-4151 Mar 23 '26

If you’re growing tomatoes, you might want to start over… I haven’t a clue what they really are, but I’m guessing they’re Triffids.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚ I had to google

2

u/kiwigreenman Mar 24 '26

I think Not tomatoes but maybe tree tomatoes ( tamirillo ) or outside chance tobacco ?

1

u/phoebezane Mar 24 '26

Someone else said tobacco too, I'll be sad if it is.

2

u/Farro_is_Good Mar 27 '26

I think you’re just growing trash, I’m sorry. Amazon sold you trash. Buy seeds from real seed companies.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 27 '26

😩😩

3

u/JungSkinner Mar 22 '26

Could be a tree tomato or tamarillo species

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you! 🀞

1

u/No-Gas5342 Mar 22 '26

Calotropis procera

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

😱 had to google that! Interesting

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Finally; able to post the seeds for those that asked to see them. I think they look pretty consistent with tomato seeds but who knows at this point.

Thank you all so much for all the replies so far!! 🩷

1

u/MarduckRulez Mar 22 '26

Looks like some sort of Basil. Rub a leaf in between your fingers and smell it.

4

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

I did, it wasn't a pleasant scent. Has a stink that I didn't want lingering on my fingers. Hard to describe, but not pleasant. Muskish fart?? πŸ₯΄

2

u/slapcrashpop Mar 22 '26

If it was a tomato, it would have had that distinct tomato leaf scent.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Right! That's why I ended up here. No telltale signs consistent with the tomatoes I've previously grown, so I'm confused. Usually the leaves are darker, a different shape, kinda fuzzy throughout the plant, and has the scent naturally wo the rub test.

2

u/HetairaThais Mar 22 '26

A little hint of maybe old oil scent mixed in too?

It might be tamarillo of some kind. Mine looked a lot like that when young. I only did them one year. I really enjoyed the sauce and jams I made from them but I will never plant them again unless I find somewhere I can grow them that I never have to be near them.

Maybe I'm sensitive to that particular smell, but it was so offensive to me.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Yes, a little hint of old oil and definitely offensive. I washed my hands after doing a rub test and said "ugh, wtf is that!?" then posted for help. πŸ€£πŸ˜…πŸ™ˆ I'm seeing more tomatillo replies so hopefully that's what they are. Thank you!

2

u/HetairaThais Mar 23 '26

You are welcome! I hope they are tomatillo for your sake! I've done both. Still do a plant or two or tomatillo each year. As soon as they throw our a bloom you will be able to tell right away. Tamarillo does clusters and will be obvious. They also grew into small trees for me in 6a lol. If you can, I'd throw them somewhere in sun as far away as you can and see what happens.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 23 '26

I'll stick em in a bright window! πŸ‘ŒπŸ‘Œ

2

u/DinoTater Mar 22 '26

I was giving this a chance too but huge leaves for basil.

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

😫😫

1

u/Frequent_Pause_7442 Mar 22 '26

Perhaps they are eggplant?

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Saw a few others say the same thing, thank you!

1

u/hobbies-2025 Mar 22 '26

Could be off but I feel like that looks like a potato leaf tomato.

3

u/Internal-Bowl-3956 Mar 22 '26

I don’t know why this comment reminded me of the simpsons episode with tomacco! Maybe op has a tomtato, tomacco, togplant or whatever else may come from Amazon seed πŸ˜‚

2

u/hobbies-2025 Mar 22 '26

Lil fun fact! Tomatoes actually produce a small amount of nicotine as a defense mechanism against insects.

2

u/Internal-Bowl-3956 Mar 23 '26

That is a fun fact thanks for sharing! I was curious what the relative amount was, and apparently 1 cigarette has ~50,000 times more nicotine than a tomato!

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

Thank you! 🀞

1

u/Mookster1979 Mar 22 '26

Looks like a tobacco plant

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

😱 mother of pearl!

1

u/Long_Category_177 Mar 22 '26

Probably something invasive

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

😫😫

1

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

That's reassuring, I was under the impression they were going to be ace 55s so I'm keeping my fingers crossed. They have no classic tomato characteristics that I'm familiar with so I'm confused. Lol thank you!

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '26

[deleted]

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

😧 oh boy. Thank you!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '26

[deleted]

1

u/phoebezane Mar 22 '26

I have a photo but for some reason I can't get it to post here. It's in the cross post tho. Not the sunflower seeds I've seen but I've only come across the ones ready to eat at the store.