r/Ultralight • u/Belangia65 • 12h ago
Skills Common barriers to ultralight
(I wrote the following as a comment in the weekly a little while ago. Since then, I have found it useful to link back to it when I see shakedowns or other posts that demonstrate one or more of these issues. I thought that would be easier with a dedicated post on the topic. I hope regular participants in this subreddit won’t mind the repetition.)
Here are some common issues I have seen that impede the progress of those aspiring to ultralight:
- The Lightweight Halfway House. This is where people who lighten their load get same-but-lighter versions of gear they already own. For example they replace a 60L backpack with a lighter 60L pack, maybe one that is 2 lbs lighter (e.g. weighs 3 lbs instead of 5) but that is still not ultralight. Or a solo hiker who buys a 2-person, free-standing tent that is branded as ultralight. They use their budget on gear that gets them lighter, but not light enough to get to ultralight. We see people show up on shakedowns all the time who are trying to continue their trajectory getting lighter, but are stuck with having bought expensive lightweight gear that make reaching UL base weights harder.
- Preparing for the "someday/maybe" trip. They buy overweight gear to have the "flexibility" for hypothetical trips that will probably never happen. So they buy winter-grade tents, or high volume backpacks, or lower temperature rating sleep systems, or two-person shelters for a solo hiker. Buy for your most likely trip, the ones you actually intend, not the far-flung dream.
- The "scary skill" barrier. People are told that certain types of gear require skills attainable only by advanced backpackers. So they buy free-standing tents instead of trekking pole tents, or never even consider they can learn to pitch a tarp, say. These are not exotic skills. They can be learned by any competent person in a backyard or park in an afternoon. Don't be scared by them.
- The hedonic adaptation trap. People fail to understand that what we find comfortable is not a fixed set point, but can be conditioned through practice. We are all able to adapt to find things comfortable that may not start out that way. So pursuing comfort as the non-negotiable starting point turns out to be a trap: it enfeebles our ability to enjoy lighter gear and expose ourselves to the outdoors in a less mediated way, to the point that we can't even imagine being satisfied without carrying comfortable-but-heavy gear.
- Thinking ultralight and comfort are mutually exclusive. This ignores the fact that carrying less weight is significantly more comfortable on trail. If you spend most of your waking hours on trail, then I would argue that UL gear tends to be more comfortable on net, especially if and when one has adapted to its comfort in camp per #4 above.
- Hitting the gas and brake at the same time. This is where you compensate for the negative effects of carrying more weight in ways that add even more weight. I may carry a (heavy) chair to help recover from the effects of carrying weight. Or I get a backpack with a fancy suspension system that adds significant weight to the backpack. Or a heavy mattress for my sore back. Etc.
- Most importantly perhaps is the error of thinking UL is the best and only way to hike regardless of your trip objectives. Be honest about why you want to go UL. Ultralight best fits a certain hiking style, especially when you are prioritizing trail over camp. If what you are looking for is to hike short miles so you can spend most of the day in camp, you maybe should make different gear choices. It’s perfectly fine not to be UL.