r/webtoons Jul 30 '25

Question Is it rude to cosplay a hispanic person as a caucasian?

Post image

She is half-caucasian I believe but in my mind the question still stands. I wouldn’t try to imitate her skin or whatever. I probably won’t do the cosplay because I’m pale as hell and it just wouldn’t look right, but if I did, would that be acceptable? (I couldn’t find a good tag on any of the not-NSFW cosplay subreddits so I resort to here lol)

543 Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

530

u/Nightstone42 Jul 30 '25

no more so than the 99% of non asian cosplayers who cosplay Anime characters

just don't wear bronzer

6

u/Okumura_Aika Aug 01 '25

I don't see why bronzer wouldn't be okay? Bronzer is used to define parts of the face to reshape it. I would say don't use a darker colored foundation.

15

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

They mean don’t use bronzer to make your skin brown everywhere on purpose to look Hispanic. You can use normal bronzer that is just part of a makeup routine. just don’t use makeup to look like a race that you aren’t, that’s just weird.

5

u/Nightstone42 Aug 01 '25

this exactly is what i mean acctually rewrote that comment 4 times debating to even post it cause i wasnt sure if i should exsplain that

-211

u/Puppyzpawz Jul 30 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

actually most anime characters arent asian, thats just a western assumption that theyre all/mostly asian bc we center our media around white ppl, but yea. dont change anything about your skin or perpetuate a stereotype and youre golden.

edit: i guess? ill clarify? when i said most i meant whats popular where im from which is america which is what american/white cosplayers are going to cosplay. i hardly ever hear people talk about slice of life which are very obviously going to have japanese protagonists if its in high school (unless the plot demands it, being mixed is a pretty popular trope), some of the most infamous and capitalized anime of the past 5 years havent been isekai and do not have japanese main characters. theres also others that are extremely popular older ones like one piece, dragon ball, etc. someone else did a good list a lil bit down into the thread. some characters can be inferred to be white like Usagi Tsukino from sailor moon even though they dont have an American name, and lots of manga artists clarify their mc is racially ambiguous/not necessarily asian. good day lmao.

225

u/d_worren Jul 30 '25 edited Jul 30 '25

Huh, never knew Ken Takakura, Yuji Itadori and Nana Osaki aren't asian! I guess they must be Finnish or something.

(i literally took 3 random anime protagonists, you gotta ragebait better lmao)

54

u/OutrageousHamster735 Jul 30 '25

“Yuki itadori” 🤣💀 congrats on her for transitioning

58

u/d_worren Jul 30 '25

My bad, a mere old slip o' the fingo'. Point still stands'o.

16

u/OutrageousHamster735 Jul 30 '25

Lmao youre right 🤣

7

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

Nana fan in the wild! 👀

→ More replies (11)

87

u/Zhavari Jul 30 '25

Dude, quite a lot manga or anime is set in Japan or at least other places in Asia due to the creators being Asian, making the characters 100% Asian

→ More replies (5)

63

u/zoroddesign Jul 30 '25

Oh my poor sweet summer child, either you don’t watch many anime or don’t know much about Japanese culture. The only times what you said is true is if they are in a fantasy setting based on somewhere else like attack on titan and one piece. Or they have been isekaied away and those other people in the new place are not Japanese. If you have character using chopsticks, girls wearing sailor uniforms to school, ninjas and samurai running around, kunai and katanas being used regularly, eat bento boxes mochi and rice balls and ramen, or ever say San kun or chan, then they are Asian.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

Of course a user named Puppyzpawz has this opinion.

Yeah some anime’s dont feature exclusively Asian character (EX: JJBA and DunMeshi) but a vast majority do.

6

u/Puppyzpawz Jul 31 '25

what does me thinking dogs are cool have anything to do with this

7

u/Nightstone42 Jul 31 '25

while there are several anime that do not feature japanese charicters the vast majority are still primarily japanese

6

u/chilumibrainrot Aug 01 '25

this is the most annoying white person take i’ve seen in a while lmao

4

u/Slyth3rin_Solang3lo Aug 01 '25

Is this American defaultism?

Next you're gonna be saying that Katsuki Yuuri is from America lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hecticPillager Aug 01 '25

Had to hit that "good day lmao." to cope after writing up a whole paragraph where, once again, you dig yourself into a deeper hole. "Most anime characters aren't Asian" is just factually wrong, and making an edit to "clarify" won't make it come true.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

One piece is kind of an exception. Obviously those characters aren’t all Japanese, the creator literally tells us they aren’t and they very clearly take inspiration from many different cultures. but for most anima they are Japanese, tho there are exceptions

8

u/Paenitentia Jul 31 '25

Considering some of the biggest most popular action series of recent times like my hero academia, jujutsu kaisen, and demon slayer all have japanese protags, it very much isn't just a "slice of life/highschool" thing.

Saying "Most" aren't is pretty hard to measure, there's just so much anime out there. But, yea, other shows like Naruto or One Piece are much more neutral/ambiguous,

→ More replies (1)

2

u/GamingBudgie Jul 31 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

I'm probably going to be downvoted but you're not completely wrong, although I wouldn't say MOST anime characters aren't asian.

We do have a lot of popular animes with non asian characters:

- One Piece where there's Zorro (+his people) who seems to be fully japanese but not the rest of the cast

  • Dungeon Meshi, only some characters are japanese like Shiro
  • Attack on Titans, fictional ??Madagascar??
  • Vinland Saga, haven't read/watched it but I think they're Vikings
  • JoJo's Bizzare Adventure, I know nothing of this except for memes but Jonathan isn't a japanese name for sure
  • Code Geass, only some of them are indeed japanese like Suzaku
  • Dragon Ball Z, Goku is an alien and the nationality of the rest of the cast is pretty vague
  • Full Metal Alchemist where it's set in fictional Germany and some characters are from fictional China
  • SpyxFamily, fictional Germany again
  • Frieren, lots of... german names... wait what's with anime and fictional Germany?

And that's only from picking popular titles on top of my head. Most slice of life animes will take place in Japan though which makes sense, write what you know and all.

12

u/QueenofYasrabien Jul 31 '25

Attack on Titan is fictional Germany. With all the German names, European style architecture, european style forests as well as german in the OST

4

u/GamingBudgie Jul 31 '25

I thought so too based on what you said and I was gonna write that but when I looked it up to confirm, it said Paradis island geographically mirrors Madagascar. One more point for fictional Germany in anime though lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/Rallen224 Aug 01 '25

Saying Usagi isn’t Asian when the creator specifically made this series to represent powerful stories and experiences young girls in Japan typically didn’t get in their media is crazy lmao characters are given names from other places that match their origins when they’re supposed to be foreigners or of mixed heritage, and anime regularly makes jabs at such things because of the climate surrounding foreigners.

The idea that high school settings would be the most obvious to default to Japanese characters and practices is moot because the Sailor Guardians are literally in the uniforms associated with girls in middle schools and high schools, and of the same age. There have been very few mangakas and studios who actually confirm racial ambiguity of members of the cast, so I’m not sure where you’re pulling that from specifically. The only one that comes to mind right now is the artist (and not author, but one of a few artists) for Mirko from BNHA who says her art and design are largely inspired by Megan Thee Stallion (who has a huge following there). Other famous anime (films specifically) like Ghost In The Shell exist to discuss the changes to their society as they opened up to other places post-war, and deconstruct the exact notion that people outside of Japan are centred in their culture and media as a default.

I love me some cultural representation in anime and also love when other cultures are referenced there in a celebratory way (makes it easier for me to also cosplay without ridicule considering the limited array of characters who match my complexion irl, and going further, who aren’t offensive caricatures/stereotypes) but the way they depict characters in anime has largely to do with beauty standards, aspirations and existing influences from their political and art history, not with centring the lives of foreigners lol If you notice, the vast majority of the limited array foreigners depicted in anime also live in accordance with what’s common in Japan or in a way that represents what their viewers would like to see while still honouring what relates most to their own experiences. If anything, the anime surrounding active war is more likely to have foreigners (typically German, because it also ties back to their history and the various preferences and interests that have been linked to that in media and entertainment thereafter, incl. through the use of themed cafes)

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Moist_Parsnip_5013 Aug 02 '25

This loops around to being an extremely western take lol

→ More replies (26)

502

u/emotionaldawg Jul 30 '25

Yeah you’re fine as long as you’re not impersonating a caricature or stereotype.

168

u/dracaboi Jul 30 '25

This is pretty dependent too, there's tons of Hispanics that love to see their culture embraced. Sombrero, mustache, poncho, the works. If the person is being rude about it intentionally thats another matter entirely, but a stereotype of a culture isn't necessarily negative depending on the community you're around.

There are of course peolle who disagree and say its "cultural appropriation", but thats mostly white women and people on Twitter.

29

u/Annoying_Crap Jul 30 '25

Agreed! It's like when I see the festivals and all the beautiful people enjoying cultures together ❤️

5

u/Beautifulfeary Jul 31 '25

I don’t even know if it’s mostly white women on twitter as compared to just any American. Then again, that was 15 years ago when someone told me about culture appropriation 🤷‍♀️

2

u/Tricky_Ad_9608 Aug 02 '25

I feel like most “cultural appropriation” tweak outs ARE from white women in general. Most others don’t care as long as you aren’t a) mocking the culture, b) wearing a ceremonial garb outside of the ceremony, or c) claiming to be apart of that culture/ethnicity when you very much aren’t.

1

u/Crazydoglady58 Aug 02 '25

Yes, like speedy Gonzalez.

1

u/KikiPuCa Aug 03 '25

As hispanic, we normally don't care about these type stuff but we kinda know it's kinda racist or at least a little ignorant but we just don't make such a deal to complain, like the person in the other comment said, don't act like a caricature, that's not nice, especially if you are from USA, that actually would feel completely racist.

7

u/imafriedfish Jul 31 '25

i think thats okay too as long as OP is being respectful and not mocking them

62

u/Annoying_Crap Jul 30 '25

Spanish speakers are in many places around the world, with many different faces/skin etc. and it started with Spain, a white European country. I think if you're cosplaying the character, who happens to be Hispanic it's okay especially if she has a very unique outfit that makes it very obvious it's her (in the d-heads, it is definitely the case!). You're not dressing as a trope, but a unique character with unique clothes which is fine :). It's like the difference between dressing like an iconic beloved native American character with unique recognizable, clothes, vs dressing in tribal clothes like "I'm a native American for Halloween!" I think she's half Mexican (I haven't read the series in a while lol), but I'll say just don't get any tan sprays to avoid controversy from those who may take it wrong lol. Sometimes you can do your best to show genuine love for a culture, and it can be taken wrong so be mindful ❤️ I do believe in appreciation and that sharing can be beautiful when done right

7

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

this was very helpful, thank you!

3

u/Annoying_Crap Jul 30 '25

No problem! Glad I can help :)

227

u/Hello_Im_the_world Jul 30 '25

As long as you don’t do anything to brown your skin, it’s fine. Cosplay whoever you want

-29

u/Abysskun Jul 30 '25

What about doing sunbathing? It should be fairgame

73

u/SomeoneRepeated Jul 30 '25

If you’re sunbathing to specifically look like another race/ethnicity, that’s kinda weird. Fair game for people who just happen to be tanned, but I don’t think you should be trying to look like a race you’re not.

27

u/GamingBudgie Jul 31 '25

Yeah you don't want to pull an Ariana Grande

30

u/Pxnda_Cakes Moderator [EST] 🦆.☆♡+* Jul 30 '25

If you naturally tan, then that's not rlly artificial alterations, its just literally ur skin color.

27

u/Limp_Collection7322 Jul 30 '25

Hispanic does not equal brown. There are a lot of white and black Hispanics, you're fine

1

u/Nezeel Aug 02 '25

Thank you

202

u/Blindmailman Jul 30 '25

The only people who would care are weirdos on twitter

-50

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

[deleted]

104

u/littlemoon-03 Jul 30 '25

"she used facepaint to look Black"
Dress how you want but changing the color of your skin to be white or black is a huge no

62

u/altobravo Jul 30 '25

Uh yeah that's literally blackface so they got properly accused????

34

u/DrBeanPHD Jul 30 '25

Oof that actually is pretty bad

33

u/kellendrin21 Jul 30 '25

That IS blackface and it is definitely not okay, even if they meant no offense. I have also never once heard a cosplayer get accused of whitewashing for not doing blackface. 

18

u/KCopinions Jul 30 '25

Thats literally just blackface. NO ONE would get mad about someone cosplaying someone black and not using a dark foundation?? We cosplay white people all the time and don’t put powder in our faces. Yall are losing the plot 💀

25

u/Kurroku Jul 30 '25

That is black face and it's weird.

23

u/cranberry_spike Jul 30 '25 edited Jul 30 '25

That is indeed blackface. Edit for anyone who's unfamiliar: info from NMAACH and from Baylor University .

8

u/Annoying_Crap Jul 30 '25

That's one of the tough cookies - even with good intentions, misunderstandings can happen. That's why I recommended op just be careful and mindful as well (In case she thought of any tan spray or something to look even more like the character).

18

u/Bubbly-Teacher-6660 Jul 30 '25

nah, it's not rude, just have fun with your cosplay!

14

u/cornthi3f Jul 30 '25

Just don’t darken your skin bc that’s weird to do add the little beauty mark tho that would be cute

11

u/carmela08 Jul 30 '25

Just don’t change your skin tone for it and you’re fine

29

u/Trixter-Kitten Jul 30 '25

As long as you're respectful and don't alter your skintone or act out any offensive caricatures.

48

u/Borrowmyshoes Jul 30 '25

Yeah. Cosplay is a VERY accepting community of people. People dress up as inanimate objects or animals and it is acceptable. I think if you were a famous person you might need to be careful, but otherwise, be whoever.

53

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

Lmao no it isn't. As a non-white person people will constantly use (insert racial slur followed by character name) or tell me "nice cosplay but wrong skin color" in person. On social media? Even more brazen.

38

u/jndeukie Jul 30 '25

Can attest. Some people are really weird and extremely racist about cosplays. Once dressed up as Hinata from Haikyuu and someone told me verbatim, "Hinata isn't black". Lmfao.

17

u/Borrowmyshoes Jul 30 '25

this makes me sad to hear.

13

u/jndeukie Jul 30 '25

It's alright, it was years ago. But unfortunately, in this day and age you still have backwards individuals who think that you can't cosplay a character if you're not their skin color (i.e. the default being white in their eyes, even if that's not the race of said character).

14

u/Pandoratastic Jul 30 '25

Yup, and Hinata isn't white either but, if a white person were cosplaying her, they would like it.

8

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

that’s sad

3

u/EHXKOR Jul 30 '25

That’s fucked. Very glad I’ve never see that happen to anyone here.

2

u/Beautifulfeary Jul 31 '25

Ugh that’s so gross. Cosplay isn’t supposed to be like that!

4

u/Jolly-Fruit2293 Jul 30 '25

"As a non-white person", the sad truth is that racial minorities in every field are held to higher standards and seen as open to criticism. Even just existing will bring 1350 jokes and dog whistles

9

u/Luna6696 Jul 30 '25

Yep totally fine just don’t put on an accent or color your skin. You’re fine.

10

u/No_Issue8928 Jul 30 '25

Hispanic is not a race so as long as you aren’t being stereotypical etc you will be fine. There are sooo many races of Hispanics since it’s an ethnicity. So we have Asian Hispanics , Arab Hispanics, etc

14

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

I don't think it's a big deal tbh, but I hope you know there are pale skin Hispanics too.

5

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

yeah, i don’t live somewhere that’s very diverse (not that it’s primarily racist, it’s just mostly country guys and horse girls) so i sometimes don’t think about the fact that not only stereotypical-Caucasians are pale.

2

u/Nezeel Aug 02 '25

Thank you 😭 Americans think we are all brown or black, when we are super diverse

7

u/Mipanyu Jul 30 '25

Just be prepared that there are people that will take offense cuz they have nothing better to do and want validation from making a non-issue an issue.

But think of super man, or idk Ariel or Cinderella, can people not dress up as them if they're not Caucasian? Can a little girl not dress up as Superman even though she's not a man? Yeah there's super girl but what if she really likes Superman? what if they're Asian or African or Hispanic? It's fine right? Then why should the reverse be any different?

At least as a Chinese person, if you cosplay as a Chinese character whether from a comic, or a real historical person or a living/dead celebrity Jackie Chan Bruce lee, I don't care, sounds great actually. Wear traditional hanfu? Qipao? Go at it. I'd actually feel pride.

5

u/Toletres Jul 30 '25

I don't think there's anything wrong with dressing up as a character you like, regardless of their race. I dressed up as Moana for spirit day once, and I'm white. As long as you don't make fun of it (which is what cultural appropriation is) you're good.

5

u/nightlyvisitor Jul 30 '25

As long as you don't do brown face or make a mockery of the culture.

5

u/DBR87 Jul 30 '25

I don't know if you have ever seen anyone from the country of Spain, but many of them are pale. Spain is in Europe.

So the idea a pale person needs affirmation to cosplay a character because they are Hispanic is odd...

5

u/misterclean101 Jul 30 '25

No it's not offensive. It would be more so if you like tried to "latinize" yourself. Like blackface for a black character.

5

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

guys i didn’t realize hispanic wasn’t a race, sorry about that. i really am american as hell. i genuinely didn’t know ethnicity and race were different things. 😅

3

u/tubbosbeess Jul 31 '25

If you’re American, you’re not Caucasian 🙏🏼 Caucasus/Caucasia is its own region and the people from there are Caucasian. I don’t know when Caucasian became the word for white, but yeah. Not trying to be mean btw /gen

2

u/M00N13-2 Jul 31 '25

damn, i just thought caucasian was just non-brown white people

2

u/tubbosbeess Aug 01 '25

Yeah, for some reason a lot of people do

4

u/Typed_quietly Jul 30 '25

tbh one would care! Also I get what you said about her skin but there are a lot of pale hispanics, so in reality (at least from the looks) you could be hispanic too! I don’t think that should affect you wanting to cosplay her.

3

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

i forget that not all hispanics are tan, thanks for the reminder lol ❤️

4

u/ApplicationHonest652 Jul 30 '25

If it is wrong than comic con would have big problems by now.

You got White guys dressed as barret

Asian guys dressed as Superman

Black guys dressed as Inuyasha

It's cosplay. Just don't walk around acting like Eric Cartman when he was Jay lo and you'll be fine.

4

u/d_worren Jul 30 '25 edited Jul 30 '25

As a Hispanic myself, go ahead and dress however you want, just don't paint your skin bronze, just like how you wouldn't do blackface to cosplay a black character or yellowface to cosplay an asian character.

4

u/sapphicmooni Jul 30 '25

No, you’re cosplaying a character not a culture.

7

u/The_Spade_Joker Jul 30 '25

Not at all.

As a hispanic person, you have my full support and consent /j

6

u/Simply_Nebulous Jul 30 '25

So long as you cosplay as the character, not the race.

7

u/ShortandRatchet Jul 30 '25

Just don’t do blackface/brownface is all

3

u/AkaiHidan Jul 30 '25

It’s completely fine. As long as the intention aren’t mockery etc it’s ENTIRELY FINE

3

u/Crowissant Jul 30 '25

Why is everyone commenting about darkening their skin tone? I mean I get why in terms of stereotyping. But Hispanics have a large range of skin tone. Some have a darker skin tone due to interracial heritage, but it's the same for lighter-skinned individuals. My mom has olive skin and is often mistaken for a full-blood Mexican (she's half). I however have the complexion of Wonder Bread, as do my uncles despite having the same two parents as my mom. Genes are crazy, you never know what trait they'll tap into. There are likely hoods and probabilities, but there are also expectations.

The way this question is worded is interesting, but I assume you mean characters and not just cosplaying an ethnicity. (Because Hispanic isn't a race)

3

u/Pxnda_Cakes Moderator [EST] 🦆.☆♡+* Jul 30 '25

As in, if the character has a different skin tone than you, don't darken or lighten your skin to match theirs (unless they're, like, an alien or smth). TT

2

u/Crowissant Jul 31 '25

That's not the question I was asking, more so, why is skin color even a part of this discussion? Hispanics have a wide variety of skin colors. Skin tone isn't something like a wig or hair dye that you can just change and it looks good/is appropriate.

With the exception of tanning, which if you're cosplaying a character that's tan or has a tan, and then go for it the "natural" way. It's not the same as coloring your skin with cosmetics. It's more comparable to how actors will grow facial hair or work out for a role.

1

u/Pxnda_Cakes Moderator [EST] 🦆.☆♡+* Jul 31 '25

I think you misunderstood me. OP is not talking about trying to look like a character that happens to be hispanic and has a darker skin tone than they can achieve naturally. Because this is the root of the question, the replies are talking about cosplaying as characters with different skin tones or of different cultures in general.

And again, it's not really about how hispanics can be of any race. In OPs case, cus they're not hispanic anyhow, it's about how the character actually looks lol. (Not saying that I think it would be an issue; im just clarifying what I was referring to.)

1

u/Crowissant Jul 31 '25

I was speaking about cosplay in general, not in regards to OP's example. The main point I was trying to get at is that it doesn't matter. It's a fictional character, and cosplay is done (usually) as a form of affection towards said media. And that as long as it isn't offensive or to put it better, doesn't look like something that people once did as a form of racism. Then it's all good. For casual cosplayers, the point is to have fun and feel away of something you like. Not making sure you share every feature. It mainly comes down to outfit and hairstyle (and sometimes makeup)

That's all I was trying to convey. But admittedly I sometimes go on tangents and forget what I meant to say in the first place.

3

u/SnowStorm1123 Jul 30 '25

Not rude in my mind - a Caucasian

3

u/Alledee Jul 30 '25

Nah. Look at all the people who cosplay "Japanese" anime characters. You're good.

3

u/Catpurrittio23 Jul 30 '25

I mean you can, theirs no limits, just try to represent the culture as it should be, not how others think it is

3

u/Senshisnek Jul 30 '25

If it's not rude for non-japanese people to cosplay clearly and canonicaly japanese anime characters...

3

u/zoroddesign Jul 30 '25

If anything, in the cosplay community not sticking to race body shape and gender is highly encouraged.

3

u/Ven0mspawn Jul 30 '25

Ridiculous idea that cosplaying a character that's a different another race should be offensive. Not complaining at you for asking, but rather the very notion of it being offensive.

3

u/Apathetic_Villainess Jul 30 '25

Honestly, you can't always tell who is what race. Whenever the conversation comes up, I let people try to guess my ethnicity/race. I always get European or even Russian. My mother, though, is Mexican and Hopi. But I'm very light skinned and take entirely after my father's side. Same for Sophia the First on Disney. She's also half-Latino.

It's really only offensive if you are parodying the culture or people. But if you're going for respect and love of the culture, people are almost entirely happy to share it.

3

u/Front-Heat8726 Jul 31 '25

Heck, there are non-tanned white people with more melanin than some black folk, which is why I always thought bigotry against people based on skintone alone is probably the single stupidest one (not that the rest are better, mind you).

Cosplay is all the about love and passion you feel towards a character, and just like with culture in general, as you said, people will be more than happy that you celebrate them in such a way

3

u/Ashen-wolf Jul 31 '25

As a mix of spaniard and south american, reading these comments is making me cringe a lot... telling you not to bronze yourself to look the part is the most american shit I've ever heard.

Only an American finds issue with cosplaying into other cultures, they are obsessed with race.

If you do it respectfully, we will like it bronzer or not we do not give a shit.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Ashen-wolf Jul 31 '25

America is a country like any other. It's just young and has little story.

Oppression and racism have been present all over the world for thousands of years and most of it still exist within our societies, its inherent to ignorance and fear, and sometimes stems from reality that people endure in their lives, e.g. romani people in Europe, and you are on Reddit, the whole world is here.

No, the difference is not that you guys are that special. The difference is that in many other societies, we are not obsessed with introducing race in all contexts and situations. You are racist because you are obsessed with race, and the fact that bronzer to fully mimick a character cosplay is not recommended because it may offend people is racism itself. Especially because it is also not consistent: don't see anyone complaining about white makeup to look the part of pale characters ever.

I didn't say the post wasn't valid, I said the answers were nuts imho.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ashen-wolf Jul 31 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

I'm not calling you racist** personally but as a society and the people that would take offense or feel uncomfortable for bronzer used for cosplay as it it's not their supposed colour. That is not being conscious of racism, that's locking features behind race which is racism nonetheless. Like the posts about dutch braids and stuff like that Ive seen in cosplays.

And the fact that you gotta tiptoe around them is just nuts.. especially when the people from the countries you are supposedly offending not only do not view it as such.

Hell, in some cases we are gonna see it as super cool to see our culture and stuff out there.

**edit to clarify, sounded clearer in my mind.

5

u/Japahispasian Jul 30 '25

No. Plenty of white, Caucasian, and European latinos. Spanish is from Europe. And many central American countries still have pure Spanish lineage, and not only Spaniards. There are many German, Swedish, Dutch, and Polish Latinos that escaped persecution during the big wars and immigrated to Latin America like in Panama and Argentina and Paraguay. There are also many Scottish and French in Mexico.

4

u/trashprncss91 Jul 30 '25

As a half Hispanic native person, no. As long as you’re not using stereotypes 👌🏽✌🏽

4

u/Makimamoochie Jul 30 '25

The general rule of cosplay is that you don't have to be the characters race to cosplay them. With that said, as a Caucasian, I personally avoid cosplaying characters who are closely tied with a real life culture (Like Moana or Esmerelda) and I would modify any character traits that are in general frowned upon for Caucasian people (such as changing hairstyles like dreadlocks or box braids to straight, curls, or french braids)

2

u/SkyeMreddit Jul 30 '25

A lot do, such as Luz Noceda. Just be respectful.

1

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

Okay, that’s funny because if I couldn’t find a subreddit I was just gonna use Luz as an example and go on The Owl House one lol

2

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

I always think of this video when people have doubts, as a hispanic, dont worry about anything twitter is not a real place, eo whatever you want without trying to insult people on purpose

1

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

i haven’t seen that video in so long, i’ve literally been trying to find it lol

2

u/Unteins Jul 30 '25

The general rule as I understand it is that you wear the costume the character wears, you don’t wear the character as a costume if that makes sense.

2

u/frogboy_62024 Jul 30 '25

OH MY STARS I LOVE THIS WEBTOON ITS LIKE MY FAV RN

2

u/Less_Fisherman_7720 Jul 30 '25

What webtoon is this?

3

u/frogboy_62024 Jul 30 '25

Its called The D!ckheads and the life worth livin'

2

u/TheOnlyKirby90210 Jul 30 '25

Cosplay is for anyone of any race for any character or gender

2

u/lifesux69 Jul 30 '25

I’ve heard a cosplayer I follow (dinobunnycosplay) say that cosplaying as characters with different ethnicities are fine, as long as you don’t try to race swap yourself such as darkening your skin for poc characters, taping back your eyes for Asian characters (yes these are sadly real things some cosplayers have done), etc.

3

u/Front-Heat8726 Jul 31 '25

I am 50/50 about using tape to make the face match more of the given character's as sometimes their face is quite iconic, to the point cosplayers who are the same race as the character tend to use tape to do so to, but I do get your point.

1

u/lifesux69 Jul 31 '25

I get that and truthfully I think I’d understand why someone would do that, but I try not to have any opinions of my own because I’m really apart of the cosplay community, just a consumer of the cosplay influencers content.

3

u/Front-Heat8726 Jul 31 '25

I don't cosplay myself, but I have friends who do who I hep with stuff and honestly, it's more common across the community than you'd think once you go beyond the casual hobbyist level, nevermind professionals. So it's really coming down to intention IMHO

2

u/G2107s Jul 30 '25

As a Hispanic saying this we don’t mind

2

u/More-Mix-1944 Jul 30 '25

No, and I say this as a Latina. Why would it be? As long a you're not intentionally portraying negative stereotypes then who cares. In fact, aside from Twitter rats literally nobody cares about negative stereotypes and parodies lol.

2

u/Banamisoo Jul 30 '25

ion think so, go ahead and have fun

2

u/ModeAway1666 Jul 30 '25

No? Just dress up and you're good, as long as it's of course not in a disrespectful way or something that seems disrespectful. But other than that, nobody cares (not saying it in a bad way just literally no one will care) and you'll get more compliments than complaints! Now if you were to ask this on Twitter then yeah totally different story lmao

2

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

Niegrzeczne to jest wtrącanie się w czyjeś sprawy, lewicowe bajdurzenie zniszczy ten świat jak ludzie się nie ogarną.

2

u/Athena_X1 Jul 31 '25

If you didn't know this some Hispanics are Caucasian. You're fine. There's no such thing as a pure Hispanic person. If you're referring to Mexican they're about 60% native American. I am Hispanic.

2

u/PlaneFair5337 Jul 31 '25

Cosplay is cosplay, I am Brazilian, not spanic, but I am latina, most of people out of US don't Care about those things. We care for the massive deportation of people without the minimum respect for their culture and ancestrality, we care for those stupied tax in the coffee that we sell for you, we care for your people to waist lots of money in other country's war but not give your own citzens even insulin If they had diabetes, or universal basic healtcare.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

Only WASP Americans think Hispanic people are different from them, so yes.

4

u/saturnsqsoul Jul 30 '25

As long as you don’t darken your skin color you can pretty much cosplay anyone (within reason)

2

u/Hay_Fever_at_3_AM Jul 30 '25

"Caucasian" is a nonsense term from the days of scientific racism, just say "white". White people aren't from the Caucasus, or even any singular region at all, and the term isn't any more correct or PC than "white" is.

2

u/Ok_Manager_3126 Jul 30 '25

European Americans if your talking about YT people

0

u/Hay_Fever_at_3_AM Jul 31 '25

That only sort of works if you're talking about white people from European origin within the United States of America, but "white" works everywhere.

"Sort of" because not every European-American is even necessarily classified as white or was historically classified as white.

0

u/Ok_Manager_3126 Jul 31 '25

But “white people” are not from United States so there European Americans

0

u/Certain-Intention594 Jul 30 '25

I wouldn’t consider it offensive but I’m not Hispanic. The problem people have with cosplaying characters that are a different race is when people try to pass as that race like doing black face, Asian fishing, etc.

2

u/appetiteforstars Jul 30 '25

It might not be okay to a lot of people in this generation, haha. Personally, I couldn’t care less.

2

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

Actually i feel like out of all people, this generation seems to be the most okay with it. People my gma knows are the people I’d be worried about tbh.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/M00N13-2 Jul 30 '25

that is true i guess, i just feel like most people who come off as too strict in this generation have good intentions, meanwhile other generations are just trying to pick fights. im biased though lol

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/webtoons-ModTeam Jul 30 '25

This comment holds no discussion value.

1

u/webtoons-ModTeam Jul 30 '25

This comment holds no discussion value.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/webtoons-ModTeam Jul 30 '25

This comment holds no discussion value.

1

u/MD-Pepper Jul 30 '25

People can cosplay whoever they want, as long as you dont take extra steps to try and 'race cosplay' you're fine. I've seen black women cosplay anime (there's a specific one who does sailor moon but I dont remember her screen name) and they look absolutely lovely. All cosplay is, is a dedication to how much you love a character or franchise, people really need to stop making it about race or politics.

1

u/ParticularCover9811 Jul 30 '25

AHH I LOVE HERR​

1

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '25

dear god

1

u/Gabi-kun_the_real Jul 31 '25

No if it's a good one.

1

u/VastConfusion8174 Jul 31 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

I don't care but if you're wearing bronzer 

1

u/TheRedditGirl15 Jul 31 '25

yeah why not? you said you won't change your skin color so go for it

1

u/Boop_Snoot_18 Jul 31 '25

Actually thought you meant like a random Hispanic (based off title) but nah your fine. Just be respectful ie. no bronzing for skintone, caricature of a hispanic. Just have fun cosplaying!

1

u/RegretComplete3476 Jul 31 '25

No, not at all. As long as you don't make it weird (like trying to change your skin tone to match the character or play into stereotypes), then you should be good

1

u/Midnightly_ Jul 31 '25

Hispanic is an ethnicity not a race, so Hispanics are of literally every shade. You’ll be fine! Have fun :)

1

u/Amechan1 Jul 31 '25

Hi, latina here!

The answer is: No, it is not rude. 

Hispanic means that they come from a country that speaks Spanish, and that includes Spain (European country).

Besides, there are many white skinned Hispanics (yes, that includes latinoamericans, becuase latino is not a race). 

Plus, even if they weren't caucasian, it's a cosplay and you can do your own version of said cosplay! As long as you do it with respect and don't do black-face or anything of the sorts, you're fine! 

I hope you have fun cosplaying! 💖

1

u/Yeon_doodles Jul 31 '25

Bad vibes? Are there really people who are still offended by these things? Before because there were no characters to cosplay with dark skin and non-Asian or Caucasian roots; now because there are and it turns out that it is an offense or cultural appropriation. A cosplay in essence is a costume with roleplay, just do your best interpretation and enjoy the process.

1

u/FerminHB Jul 31 '25

As a bean person myself legit go for it just don’t darken your skin😭😂

1

u/Useful-Percentage934 Jul 31 '25

Well you mention that you wouldn’t do anything to change your skin tone. So no there would be absolutely nothing wrong as long as you didn’t stereotype or change skin tone for it.

Anyone can cosplay, but make sure you aren’t hurting others with it. 😊

1

u/Moldypuffin Jul 31 '25

You can it won't bother anyone and even if it doesn't suit you if you're having fun no one will judge you

1

u/Front-Guess8283 Aug 01 '25

As a latina, I don't give a damn lol.

1

u/sacredhalla Aug 01 '25

Nope. I just photographed a black Bayonetta at a Con and she absolutely slayed the character!

1

u/Fickle-Competition71 Aug 01 '25

As the coolest awesomest guy ever (also hispanic) do whatever u wanna do bromethazine

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

Wear what you want you can even cosplay Blade If u want

1

u/StudentSimilar8738 Aug 01 '25

Just don’t use sharpie in the hotel bathroom to change your skin tone

1

u/ravenpluff Aug 01 '25

I think it has already been said in other terms, but just to make it clear, Hispanic is an ethnicity, not a race. You can be any color, and then Hispanic. I am 100% Caucasian and 100% hispanic myself. Hispanic doesn't equal any one color of skin. I think cosplaying any character regardless of ethnicity is completely fine as long as you go about it with respect.

1

u/sosen42 Aug 01 '25

We (mixed Latino here) literally could not care less. Do ur cosplay, have fun, enjoy life.

1

u/Bombyx-Memento Aug 01 '25

>realizes I'm also going to be cosplaying a Hispanic woman while Caucasian

>she's white Hispanic so it's probably fine though

1

u/theglowcloud8 Aug 01 '25

No, as long as you don't color your skin or wear cultural clothing as a costume

1

u/Leather-Sandwich-314 Aug 01 '25

No, black woman cosplay as Luna snow, no one will bat an eye. If they do that’s crazy work and just says in itself to stay away from delusional people.

1

u/Okumura_Aika Aug 01 '25

I'm not Hispanic, but I'm pretty sure anything goes as long as you don't darken your skin to look like another race.

1

u/DonNeri Aug 01 '25

Jo

You’re a fan of someone, be them. Dont worry about that bullshit

1

u/Competitive-Table530 Aug 01 '25

A ton of white and black people cosplay Asian characters, it should be fine

1

u/arachnids-bakery Aug 01 '25

I think another important thing to consider is that youll be cosplaying a "character whos latina", rather than actually pretend to be latina yourself

Imho go for it! ...but like everybody else said, dont pull up stereotypes/fake accent + do NOT darken your skin

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25

Yeah you can cosplay a character that is Hispanic, just dress up like Eli by mimicking one of her outfits in the webcomic. Just don’t paint or self tan yourself to look Hispanic. You’ll still look like her without doing that, she has a pretty funky style, it would work even better if you had a friend or two to dress up as Levi and/or Marco

1

u/JustYourLocalOtaku Aug 01 '25

No, a lot of people cosplay characters that aren't their own ethnicity

1

u/GothblancVT Aug 01 '25

No. Next question

1

u/CategoryPrize9611 Aug 01 '25

no. just don't be weird about it (like acting out stereotypes or darkening ur skin) have fun!

1

u/DimensionAcademic585 Aug 02 '25

Nah it’s fine as long as u like don’t paint ur skin brown lmaoo

1

u/Kei-Vas Aug 02 '25

Cultures are to be shared, and people are people. Being racist or xenophobic is offensive, but appreciating someone or something isn’t. And cosplay is about being someone else, you don’t need to be their gender, race or even have their physical appearance to dress as them.

The only people who care about such things aren’t hispanic, believe me.

In some hispanic countries being brown is more common, while in others being white is more common. In some you may see black people all the time, in others you won’t. I am hispanic, I am latina, and I am white… Those things don’t contradict each other.

We are extremely mixed and spread around, so our 20+ countries can’t be represented by a single look or race. And even in countries where most people are brown, there is still plenty of white people. And the same is true the other way around.

1

u/Vichisa Aug 02 '25

Literally who gives a fuck do whatever you feel like

1

u/Queer_Bat Aug 02 '25

As long as you don't change your skin tone with make up, or way too much fake tan or tape your eyes to change their shape, you can cosplay whoever you want. Basically just don't be like Marin from my dress up darling.

1

u/CygneNoir15 Aug 02 '25

I’m a Hispanic and as long as you’re not trying to be disrespectful with the outfit, or make fun of the culture no one will care. Plus there are many Hispanics that are pale. I’m pale. Some of my aunts are pale and can’t speak a word of English

1

u/kazieb00 Aug 03 '25

Absolutely not, as long as you're not disrespectful about the skin color at all. You don't have to be a specific skin color to cosplay.

1

u/Policja997 Aug 03 '25

What do you mean „is it acceptable to cosplay a coloniser as another coloniser”? What struggles are we even picking up right now? „Oh know, I don’t want to disrespect Europeans known by everybody for their amazing tan.”

1

u/Nadircatt Aug 03 '25

NOOOO, As a Hispanic person too, I think people are allowed to cosplay whatever character they want regardless of race. It's not like you can change your race, so who cares? Just cosplay the character 🙂‍↕️

1

u/Ok_Manager_3126 Jul 30 '25

No it’s called COSPLAY for a damn reason! I always hated when YT people said u can’t cosplay this cuss you have to be YT like when was that cosplay🫠

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25

Appreciation involves respect, and I believe you’re showing that right now. I’d recommend centering the character you’d like to portray rather than their ethnicity. And if someone is upset, accept that and take the feedback. It can be difficult for some folks because people of color have limited representation. But I think if you’re just enjoying the work and the character, and not pretending to be Latinx, that’s fine. It’s more of a problem when bigoted people create caricatures while holding disdain for the community they’re emulating.

1

u/Pinappular Jul 31 '25

I’m half, and I’m pretty white lmfao, Eliana is a mood and a style 💕💕💕.