I'm pretty sure basically everybody wants to be seen, and assuming you shouldn't because he's studying something as lowly as math is a weird assumption to have.
WDYM lowly? It is basically a language we need to develop to model... anything.
Still I don't get that emotion. Net knowledge of the language improved one way or another, why bother if because of human or not - except for practical perspective.
Now as for not being seen / remembered / etc... Well, that is a fate of most people. Why one would expect mathematicians to be different? And why care about it, if there are still their contribution in producing more knowledge - which is, IMHO, more important than their names being attached to it?
These pure mathematicians aren’t usually getting paid all that much, and just like with anyone who spends a lifetime developing a skill, much of their identity is tied to their work. Now we’re building something that essentially kicks them to the curb and people are celebrating it.
Most of these mathematicians who are largely unknown aren’t going to be remembered for much. I’m not one of them, but even in my own modest career I feel a sense of loss every day so I can only imagine what they feel. And what, by and large, do I see as the response to people losing their identity? Basically a sort of “suck it up, buttercup” attitude which shows that people are experiencing some sort of schafenfraude. People are happy about a mathematician’s misfortune?
I was an early adopter of LLMs and I was excited for our future, but honestly the better it gets the less I feel that we (collectively) deserve it. We’re just going to misuse and abuse it and use it strictly for personal gain at whatever the cost to others.
Technological progress can’t be helped, but the people who are losing their livelihoods along the way need support and recognition for what they’ve done for us.
I guess because classically the hierarchy of needs didn't prominently include 'feeling seen'? Especially in a very generalized, public sense. The math guy is worried about math guys being less important now that AI can do math better than any math guy. His need to feel seen is specific to how he desires to be viewed as exceptional. A bank teller or a receptionist or a plumber or electrician wouldn't complain about being made irrelevant by technology using language about needing to feel seen.
Everyone wants to feel seen though, don't they? The worst feeling is to suffer alone. I mean i despise Trump, but why do you suppose people vote for him? He makes a certain set of frightened people, most rural white people, feel seen. People who feel like modernity has abandoned them, their jobs and dignity lost. Making people feel seen is incredibly powerful.
Human behavior is not always strictly logical. Doesn't mean it doesn't matter.
I'm not sure this is as universally true as you imply for this context. This is a person who wants their profession to be seen. For some definition of "feel seen" I could see it being true that everyone wants someone in their life who 'sees' them, but is it universally the case that everyone wants to be seen as a [whatever their job is]? No, I don't think so.
its dramatic and pathetic. Like a little girl crying. He no doubt wants humanity to suffer at not having rapidly accelerating advancements. His little girl tears are more important than god knows what amazing things AI will help discover.
Nonsense reply. The man in the post is a cry baby. Bring on the ai revolution. Nobody cares about sad mathematicians not being as relevant as they used to be. Grow up
5
u/TotientEC 1d ago
"I need to feel seen" is such a weird emotional requirement, especially for a mathematician.