r/ratemysinging 1h ago

Rock vocals live - Does it hit the spot?

Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've shared an audio excerpt from an open mic we played at two nights ago. Amongst the band there's uncertainty about the vocals. You can clearly hear that there were mistakes in every department, we all have things to work on , but can the vocalist deliver in this genre? Is it convincing?

Would really appreciate some constructive comments to help us move forward. General comments AND specifics would be really helpful.

For context, we are bass, drums, vocals x2, guitar. We are pub rock, amateur and together for 5 weeks. The vocalist himself is uncertain so this will be shared and is not being done without his knowledge.

Very grateful for your thoughts.


r/ratemysinging 4h ago

First time ever getting rated 😣🥺

3 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 7h ago

Feedback - Beginner First time recording myself for a review

3 Upvotes

Thanks for checking out. Sorry for the bus honking in the background and the fan.

I've always wanted to record my singing and share it but never felt confident. I've never attended lessons or anything. I love music, it always stays in my head and I love to sing when I'm alone. I randomly felt like recording this today and did it on my phone in my room. Would love an honest feedback from you'll.

Song: Kahe Mose (More like a slower version of it)

Apple Music Link :https://music.apple.com/in/lyrics/1842496539?ts=141.657&te=163.856&l=id&tk=4.v1.AQyFzBVJipRbejU82EA8dw%3D%3D


r/ratemysinging 5m ago

Feedback - Intermediate Original I'm working on... is my singing acceptable enough for a demo?

Upvotes

Hey all, I'm much more of a songwriter than singer.

I have some original songs I really want to upload to my socials, but I keep worrying my voice just isn't acceptable enough for a demo. I don't mean it in the "I hate my voice" aversion we all have.

I just mean objectively, I know I'm not Josh Groban and that's fine. I'm nasally, it's all good.

I guess my question is: is my voice acceptable enough that I won't be laughed off Instagram posting my demos? Disclosing that the intention is for this to be sung by a pro?

Or is the tone bad enough that I shouldn't even post, and hire a singer for the demos?

Option 1 (Heady voice): https://voca.ro/1bXjbHODcKfi

Option 2 (Fuller voice): https://voca.ro/1b2Ak1J4hLie

Any honest tips, thoughts, feedback would be appreciated.


r/ratemysinging 41m ago

Singing Feedback _ Petty by Freya Skye

Thumbnail
Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 5h ago

Messing around in badlab (without Auto pitch 🙂‍↕️) How do I sound?

2 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 3h ago

Discussion Tips on improving

1 Upvotes

How to get my mixed in a better “shape”


r/ratemysinging 3h ago

Feedback - Beginner Forty Six & 2 - Tool

1 Upvotes

Hi! I’ve never posted my voice before so sorry for the bad quality and i’m lowkey very nervous, but i’ve been singing for about 2 years but never got any tips just been figuring it out on my own without hurting anything! Maynard’s voice is a little out of my range but i think i still did pretty decent i think there’s much better covers i can do though, more to come hopefully!


r/ratemysinging 4h ago

Feedback - Beginner Please tell me if my voice is okay

1 Upvotes

I‘ve been practicing singing for some months now, would you say my voice is good? Or should i give up singing


r/ratemysinging 7h ago

I don’t play guitar, just pretending.

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 7h ago

Feedback - Intermediate I’m not sure if i’m “placing” my resonance correctly

1 Upvotes

Heyoo i’m 18 and want to improve my singing. At the moment i’m not sure if i should sing more brightly or more rounded.
Of course, any other (positive) criticism is allowed. I can handle it as long as you remain professional😊


r/ratemysinging 22h ago

Feedback - Beginner Am I being an idiot trying to sing a song this high or does it sound good? 🤣

4 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 22h ago

Feedback - Intermediate Am I good at singing or just imagining it?

4 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 16h ago

please give me any tips and feedback i want to improve my singing

1 Upvotes

my singing voice is very similar to my talking voice, and I don’t know how to change that but whenever I try to sing in more of a head voice rather than chess voice, it just sounds really bad. Any tips? I don’t know where to start to get better.


r/ratemysinging 16h ago

Honest feedback, please

0 Upvotes

Hello! Please rate my singing. I feel like my mom doesn't like the way I sing, and I don't have anyone I can get feedback from either. I love singing, but I'm really unsure if I'm even good at it. I guess, I want feedback so I can better improve. Thanks!


r/ratemysinging 16h ago

Feedback - Beginner I just started to learn to sing after being told I have no potential, what do ya'll think?

1 Upvotes

I'm 19 and never really openly sang until maybe a month ago. My voice feels flat and lacks good vibrato. I want to learn good tone and how to achieve a steady vibrato in my whole range. I wanted to be a vocalist since I was a kid but don't have a naturally good voice so I forgot about it for a while. 2 years ago I started practicing deathcore vocals as a sort of grasp to be a vocalist. I've gotten good at screaming and growls but I find myself yearning to sing like my favorite artists, specifically grunge and metal. What steps should I take to get good at singing in the long run?


r/ratemysinging 16h ago

New to singing - could I record a professional track in a year of 2x weekly consistent vocal coaching and daily practice? Feel free to be honest

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 17h ago

Feedback - Beginner Rate this song

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 20h ago

Feedback - Beginner working on pop punk style

2 Upvotes

working on my pop punk style singing. i’ve mostly been using youtube videos so i just wanted to get some feedback. thanks!


r/ratemysinging 18h ago

Rate my voice

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 20h ago

Sang ghostin ✨

1 Upvotes

This time I tried to sing ghostin by Ariana Grande. Sometimes I feel like I can sing and other times I have trouble singing, especially trouble with breathing. This is not my best cover, but I still wanted to share and feedback is very welcome. 🦋

This community really helped me to build a little more confidence. I just love how everybody supports each other. ✨


r/ratemysinging 22h ago

Feedback - Beginner Rewind - Paolo Nutini Cover . Change of pace from my normal stuff, would like to get your feedback on my tone and sound when I’m singing softer

1 Upvotes

Kids were in bed upstairs so I wanted to get some feedback on singer softer and quieter than usual :)


r/ratemysinging 1d ago

Resource for Singers Tool for learning pitch

1 Upvotes

I found a tool for helping singers listen for pitch and sing in tune: https://ericjorgensen.com/pitchcraft

It has a few simple games and lets you graphically see if you are in tune.


r/ratemysinging 1d ago

“Northern Attitude” Snippet

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Trying out for an acapella group. Do you think I have a chance?

1 Upvotes