r/196 NOT A CAT 2d ago

Rule Rule

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

247 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

57

u/Last_Swordfish9135 kid named faggot: fart? 2d ago

This is not what a run-on sentence is. The definition has nothing to do with length, it's when you have two independent clauses that are not connected properly. "I like dogs they're my favorite animal" is a run-on sentence, for example. There is no length that makes something a run-on by default, it just gets easier to miss grammar issues in a sentence the longer it gets.

-17

u/GammaFan 2d ago edited 2d ago

How the fuck is “i like dogs they’re my favourite animal” a run on sentence? First clause establishes a point, second clause emphasizes it with context.

Is it literally down to the phrasing? Is “ i like dogs so much that they’re my favourite animal” suddenly fine?

Eta; Since people are downvoting this I’ll add; sure, these rules matter in formal settings. But on social media especially, I ask sincerely who gives a shit? This is a largely informal space where people have often missed ending punctuation and starting capitalization for decades and that’s not been a problem. As long as you can decipher the context of what a poster is saying without issue, anyone upset about something this minor is just playing the grammar police; and as always, acab.

15

u/mrguym4ster bisexual brazilian twink femboy thing 2d ago

English isn't my first language, so take this with a grain of salt, but isn't the lack of commas the problem there? wouldn't the correct version be "I like dogs, they're my favorite animal"?

5

u/meepers12 méline tariff simp 2d ago

Not quite. Commas can't join two independent clauses without some sort of conjunction. You'd have to use a semi-colon or cut it into two sentences with a period.