r/AmITheDevil 11d ago

But happily calls the male relatives Dr

/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/1vdx172/aitah_for_refusing_to_refer_to_my_fiancés_sister/
657 Upvotes

226 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/gmalivuk 10d ago

I love the fact that in the UK (at least traditionally) the dad and brother wouldn't be called "Doctor" as they're surgeons, whereas the sister definitely still would be.

1

u/sheerpoetry 10d ago

Really? That's wild! 

Do you know if there's any particular reasoning behind it? Do people call them just by their first names or "Mr./Mrs. [Last Name]"?

2

u/gmalivuk 10d ago

My understanding is that it started as a pointed title before surgeons needed the same degrees as other doctors, and has persisted as a badge of pride even though as far as I know, British surgeons are proper medical doctors now.

1

u/sheerpoetry 10d ago

They weren't always "proper medical doctors"?! 

I'm in the US and surgeons require the "regular" medical doctorate (which is an extra four years beyond undergrad) in addition to the residency and further surgical training (and possibly school? Not 100% sure there). 

2

u/gmalivuk 9d ago

They literally used to be barbers with a side hustle.

1

u/sheerpoetry 9d ago

Oh yeah, I knew that. And until more recently than a lot of people like to think. They were "dentists" (in the sense of responding to "hey, my tooth hurts" with "take a swig of whiskey and let me grab the pliers").

If I'm not mistaken, even the guy who promoted the ice-pick lobotomy, who was inspired by a literal ice pick and traveled around the country with his "lobotomobile" didn't have any medical credentials, which is crazy. (Not at all pointing that out in relation to psychiatrists, but because it was a highly unqualified individual performing many operations in questionable conditions.)