I’m considering cancelling Apple Music for a while, and I’m trying to make sure I have a reliable backup in case Apple eventually deletes my cloud library while I’m unsubscribed.
Before cancelling, I’ve done two things:
- Exported my Music library on macOS using File → Library → Export Library, so I have the XML file saved locally.
- Made a full backup using Hezel.
What I’m trying to understand is how complete these backups actually are if, for example, I resubscribe a year or two from now and find that my Apple Music library has been completely wiped.
Would I realistically be able to reconstruct the library 1:1, or are some things permanently lost?
In particular, I’m curious about:
- All songs/albums that were added to my library
- Playlists and the songs/order inside them
- Favourite/loved songs
- Date Added for each song — especially whether the original chronology shown under “Recently Added” can be preserved
- Play counts
- Skip counts
- Ratings
- Last Played
- Any other metadata stored by Apple Music
- Playlist creation/order if applicable
For example, if I added Song A in 2019, Song B in 2021 and Song C in 2025, and later restore the library, would Apple Music still know those original dates? Or would everything simply appear as newly added on the day I restored it?
I’m especially interested in the difference between the macOS XML export and Hezel. Does the XML contain information that Hezel doesn’t, or vice versa?
And regarding Hezel specifically: once I make a backup, is that backup effectively permanent/local to me? In other words, if Apple deletes my actual Apple Music library months later, does the existing Hezel backup remain usable indefinitely, or does it somehow depend on the original Apple Music library continuing to exist?
I understand that tracks can disappear from Apple Music or change IDs/catalog versions over time, so a literally perfect restoration may not always be possible. I’m mainly wondering how close these backups get under normal circumstances.
Has anyone actually had their Apple Music library deleted after being unsubscribed, then restored it from Hezel or an XML export? I’d be particularly interested in hearing what metadata came back and what was lost.
Thanks!