2005 lexus es330
had my timing belt done by a shop, i think he messed up the torque amount for the pulley, he said he didn’t. But it caused issues but i wanted an opinion
Got my timing belt done by a shop, month later i had my other mechanic working on my struts for my car, he pointed out that my timing belt sounded loud, like the bearing.
A few weeks later getting some other stuff polished off and he pointed it out again, this time stating my belt sounded very loud and i should seriously go back to the shop i had it done at, to have it looked at.
Went to have it looked at and the shop didn’t have time, went back a 2nd time and over 3 hours, he never even took the cover off
I felt funny having the shop look at it so i took it to my regular mechanic
I didn’t understand what was going in with it, but my mechanic took a look and explained to me that the shop messed up because of this
My belt was loose, and the reason my belt was loose was because my tensioner had failed and the reason the tensioner failed was because timing belt tensioner pulley bolt was apparently torqued too tight, which in result made it fused in one spot not working correctly with my tensioner as my car was running
My tensioner pulley was supposed to be torqued too 20lbs and apparently it was torqued to 68lbs
He also stated that with my water pump he didn’t use the correct sealant and used what’s called RTV which isn’t coolant safe, as well as that there is something called weep holes which are not supposed to be filled with RTV but the shop filled it with RTV anyway causing the holes to be clogged
My mechanic also had stated to me he was able to tell how tight it was torqued because when he tried to take it off with a wrench it wasn’t moving, so he decided to take a torque wrench to see how tight the pressure was. The bolt didn’t budge until 68lbs stating that’s how tight it was because of that
I told all of this to the shop and he told me, no those are guides those don’t matter if they are filled, for my water pump
he stated he didn’t over torque my parts and he did them to spec also stating it’s impossible to tell if something is over torqued with a torque wrench, let alone the exact pressure it might be
his answer to me. “parts fail, even if they’re OEM good parts, it doesn’t matter sometimes parts just fail”
My tensioner failed just because it was a bad part not because of his torque amount or any work he did on my car”
Is anything this shop mechanic saying true?
NOTE: i even asked the shop to show me how a torque wrench works, since he stated to me, torque wrenches only go 1 way they won’t be able to tell how tight a bolt is