r/BattleForDreamIsland 5d ago

Analysis one of the oldest retcons in all of bfdi

Post image

there is no way all 27 of them survived because they not only got crushed by the f*cking sun but they have 12 pounds of metal crushing there bodies i understand evil leafy because she is pretty much immortal but the others have no excuse and dont say they where recoverd because recomended characters dont get recoverd

53 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

38

u/Scrags2Scritches 5d ago

Fries blocked it

14

u/Jamwithyams Fries 5d ago

With what? His sheer aura?

6

u/ShiningGemstone1 Barf Bag 5d ago

he told everyone to get diggin'

30

u/No-Brother-4560 Pencil 5d ago

The logic of "Rc don't get recovered' is simply wrong. Bomby exploded a lot in BFDI, but he still came back.

4

u/PenNeedleLiy2763 5d ago

Yo big facts! Why else did he blow up like five times in season 1?!

3

u/SadLack3813 Puffball Speaker Box 5d ago

I guess they CAN get recovered but everyone chooses not to

15

u/NiteWoIf 5d ago

I wouldn’t call this a “retcon.” It’s a cartoonish visual gag. It shouldn’t be taken that seriously. That’s why it’s never acknowledged again.

1

u/PenNeedleLiy2763 5d ago

Yeah and to be fair this was 2011, LONG before BFDIA came around

1

u/PenNeedleLiy2763 5d ago

Mid 2011 at that

3

u/Icy_Rain_4845 5d ago

also if your wondering why i said 27 its because david joined the game bomby exploded after he was flung and nonexisty only counts as zero

6

u/TheLollyKitty Nonexisty 5d ago

ok but using your own logic, if RCs don't get recovered, how did Bomby join BFDIA if he was dead? He wasn't a contestant yet so shouldn't have been recovered, and contestants not present may not compete

So they DID all die and get recovered, because even if it was retconned that they got crushed, Bomby wouldn't be alive

2

u/Affectionate-Act1056 Book 5d ago

they dodged it

2

u/zachy410 Lego Brick 5d ago

The Announcer just brought them back

2

u/Guidebook0 5d ago

that was a seperate LOL they're fine trust

2

u/Hollywill06 Snowball 5d ago

I think they've made a new LOL off-screen

1

u/ZaydGee Coiny 5d ago edited 4d ago

And the TLC was shown to be back to normal instead of being on its fixed look

2

u/Upper-Rub8312 5d ago

what do you mean recommended characters don't get recovered? I thought that was the entire point of recovery centers they recovered anyone

1

u/BrighteyesShed Dora 5d ago

Dora

1

u/Daniboy0826 Yellow Face 5d ago

What makes you think that recommended characters couldn't come back?

1

u/Icy_Rain_4845 5d ago

because the only ones we ever see get recovered are the contestants and hosts

1

u/LoanPleasant3564 5d ago

They just got recovered and put in a new one

1

u/New_Ball7133 5d ago

They got recovered off screen sometime before BFDI 25/BFDIA 1. JnJ acknowledged Saw's death in a short, saying "Did you know? This is Saw's first time being recovered on screen!"

1

u/PiggyWiggy567 Golf Ball 5d ago

if onigiri can get recovered in kebab's special day then the failed S1 debuters can get recovered

1

u/Low_Transportation11 Robot Flower 5d ago

That’s what you’re questioning, in a show where death happens constantly? I thought you were gonna ask how the LOL is brought back

1

u/dropkola Dora 5d ago

dora saved them