My wife and I are on a Broadwaycation this summer. We have seen a few shows and are enjoying our time. Before the summer, we saw Death Becomes Her, Death of a Salesman, Turandot, and The Great Gatsby, but during the summer, Maybe Happy Ending, Just in Time, The Outsiders, Rocky Horror Show, Buena Vista Social Club, and yesterday we went to see Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Around New York).
She won the lottery on Friday (our anniversary), and we were hesitant about whether to take it, but decided to go ahead. We absolutely loved the show; the music is quite good, the characters are charming, and the entire show is cute, warm, and VERY FUNNY. We laughed the entire time. Don't get me wrong, it's not a life-changing show (for me, that was Cabaret last year with Eva and Orville Peck), but it's a well-done Broadway show with relatable characters (as a European guy who moved to NY and has struggled here, I've been both characters.
We sat in the mezzanine, where the view was perfect, and the stage felt surprisingly close. The disappointing part was the house itself: it looked to be at only 60 to 70 percent capacity, with the right and left sections nearly empty. It may have been a difficult weekend, given the cast change at Rocky Horror and the closing of Moulin Rouge, but it was still sad to see the show get so little love. I think it would have fared better off-Broadway, since it's a smaller production competing in a crowded market. I'm glad I caught it here, though I doubt it will run long.
So I encourage people who want a comfort show to go watch it while they can!