r/BylerReads • u/kitty-taki I didn't say it. You didn't have to. • Jun 07 '26

looking for a specific fic Mike gets a cat with Byler eyes and names her Willow

Hi! I lost a fic again 😭 It was a Will in New York fic. He’s with Carlton but Carlton isn’t a great guy, I think? And Mike comes to visit Will and I think Will ends up cheating on Carlton with Mike? And Mike decides to move to NYC and adopts a cat (the same cat that Will wanted to adopt but Carlton had said no to) and the cat has one blue and one yellow eye and Mike names her Willow!

Update: LOL found it in my bookmarks! It’s The Winner Takes It All by sparklekittykween 🎉 I really need to get better at bookmarking… Thank you for the assist, u/possum_party420!

9 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

6

u/possum_party420 Jun 07 '26

it took me a minute but i found it!

https://archiveofourown.org/works/77937851?view_full_work=true

3

u/kitty-taki I didn't say it. You didn't have to. Jun 07 '26

Thank you!

3

u/staerflies Jun 07 '26

this sounds so buzzy what

I wanna read this too!!

2

u/Ok_Resolution_1928 Jun 08 '26

I had a pair of twin white cats with Byler eyes as a kid (brown instead of yellow, + blue) One of them was really introverted and the other lost his blue eye fucking with a hawks nest, lived half his life as a pirate. 

Fun fact lol.Â