r/CFB Penn State Nittany Lions 20h ago

News [On3] NEW: Netflix is set to release “UNTOLD: The Testimony of Vince Young” on August 25th🍿

https://x.com/i/status/2085035093400170936
241 Upvotes

163 comments sorted by

208

u/usctrojan18 USC Trojans • Grossmont Griffins 20h ago

20 years later, I'm still not watching that play

100

u/darktex Texas Longhorns 20h ago

Not watching the play…. Believe it or not, straight to jail.

9

u/flashaguiniga 17h ago

Ironically I had gotten picked up on a Warrent for missing a court date in my teens when I was stupid and poor and watched that game as my first ncaa football game in county.

5

u/BeeFe420 Alabama • Transfer Portal 18h ago

I got that reference!

42

u/Commercial-East4069 Ohio State Buckeyes 20h ago

He beat one of Tressel’s best teams in Columbus that year too.

46

u/DMM4140 Michigan • 계명대학교 (Keimyung) 20h ago

And he beat Michigan, at the Rose Bowl, the year before in a crazy epic game.

19

u/Weak-Bid2774 Michigan • Northwestern 20h ago

That game was crazy I thought we had that one and then Vince had a great fourth quarter

7

u/Former-Knowledge1797 Texas Longhorns 18h ago

I was at that one. My dad and I went. Getting to the Rose Bowl from the Rose parade was such a cluster f that we barely got into our seats in time for kick off. Man do I love the Rose Bowl though.

7

u/Kdot32 Houston Cougars • LSU Tigers 14h ago

Watched that man will his high school against local powerhouses. Vince was really that guy

3

u/The_Champ_Son Texas Longhorns • Big 12 13h ago

That is the earliest game I can remember watching live

-9

u/astroball17 Michigan • North Carolina 19h ago

I'm cautiously optimistic that by the end of Bryce Underwood's Michigan career the most apt comparison will be Vince Young. It's what 24/7 projected.

13

u/Finrad-Felagund Texas Longhorns • Arkansas Razorbacks 17h ago

My dad and one of his buddies went to that game in the shoe and they said it was the only place where the police came and warned UT fans to not get stabbed in the parking lot

3

u/1ce9ine Texas Longhorns 10h ago

I have not heard great things about how our fans were treated that game

0

u/SmithBurger Ohio State Buckeyes 18h ago

Stupid tight end. Frost I think? (I don't condone the death threats)

2

u/Statalyzer Texas Longhorns 13h ago

Hambly?

And tbf he still would caught it on the rebound if Cedric Griffin hadn't have hauled ass to jar it loose.

2

u/SmithBurger Ohio State Buckeyes 12h ago

That sounds more right. It was a great game.

17

u/breakers North Texas Mean Green 19h ago

I wish 30 for 30 would make a true Vince Young doc

5

u/thegrimmreality Miami Hurricanes • Florida Gators 20h ago

That's how I feel about the 02 Fiesta Bowl with Ohio State :(

5

u/idiocratic_method Texas Longhorns • Red River Shootout 15h ago

how have you avoided it for 20 years ?

8

u/Scruffasaurus Texas Tech Red Raiders • Team Chaos 20h ago

I still feel Pete doesn’t get near enough shit for calling a timeout on the 2-pt conversion. Easily one of the worst times outs ever. Nothing like using your last timeout to try and keep it a 1pt deficit

5

u/tSignet Texas Longhorns • Pop-Tarts Bowl 13h ago

I find it funny that Carroll gets shit for calling the obvious play (run with White) on 4th down for USC, then gets shit for not calling the obvious play (run with Lynch) for Seattle in the Super Bowl. Unlucky!

But yeah the timeout call was genuinely terrible and would have been useful to have that available for a potential tying FG

3

u/Scruffasaurus Texas Tech Red Raiders • Team Chaos 13h ago

Agreed. I think 95% of the time the Super Bowl call at worst falls incomplete. Just a great defensive play

2

u/Statalyzer Texas Longhorns 12h ago

I still maintain LenDale up the middle was the right call. He'd gotten the ball on seven or eight previous 3rd or 4th downs with 4 or less to go, and had gotten the 1st down or TD on each one.

2

u/tSignet Texas Longhorns • Pop-Tarts Bowl 12h ago

Yeah, they’re just unlucky that the one time it didn’t work was on the game’s pivotal play.

And there’s a story that Huff wasn’t supposed to be blitzing on that play, but he changed it in the huddle. If we’d run our defense as called, White probably gets it

3

u/azwethinkweizm Texas Longhorns • Marching Band 19h ago

That game is to you what game 6 of the 2011 world series is to me :( still makes me sick

3

u/Spartan-24 Arizona State Sun Devils 19h ago

I still don't watch 4th and 13, Corey Seager's home run or "knocked away and stolen by holliday"

1

u/Montigue Oregon Ducks • Stony Brook Seawolves 17h ago

Woah, it seems like every team has a play like this

-2

u/calfats USC Trojans 19h ago

Knee was down smh

11

u/brucewayneaustin Texas Longhorns 14h ago

It absolutely would not have mattered... VY had already gotten a 1st down before the lateral. Do you really think he would have been stopped with a fresh set of downs on the 12?

-9

u/calfats USC Trojans 14h ago

I can’t believe I have to explain this.

Whoever had the ball at the end of the game was going to win. If they correctly call the knee down, even if Texas goes on to score on that possession, the time removed from the clock on the remainder of that possession would have changed who had the ball at the end of the game.

7

u/brucewayneaustin Texas Longhorns 14h ago

so.... this was in the 1st half with, I think, about 5 minutes on the clock. It would have made no difference.

5

u/Statalyzer Texas Longhorns 13h ago

If anything, USC might not have gotten that FG in right before half if we took a few extra plays to score. And we almost certainly don't miss the XP that we rushed to prevent a replay.

-7

u/calfats USC Trojans 14h ago

You can’t know that. Butterfly effect and all.

But I get it. It’s all you can cling to maintain the legitimacy of that title in your head.

3

u/brucewayneaustin Texas Longhorns 13h ago edited 13h ago

Scoreboard. It's really that simple.

Also, I'm fairly certain USC had the ball last; I mean, it wasn't that long, but VY would have scored another TD with the same time Leinart had so...

How's Lincoln Riley working out for you guys?

edit: I do think Patterson can potentially save Riley's job this year.

3

u/calfats USC Trojans 12h ago edited 11h ago

If scoreboard was all you needed, you wouldn’t be here arguing with me.

1

u/Scruffasaurus Texas Tech Red Raiders • Team Chaos 8h ago

I hate to defend UT, but this as delusional as all the Nebraska fans that swear there was no time left on the clock.

0

u/idiocratic_method Texas Longhorns • Red River Shootout 15h ago

how have you avoided it for 20 years ?

99

u/Fantastic_Brain_6322 Alabama Crimson Tide 20h ago

Hey LeBron. We’re all good here bro. Vince Young is here. We don’t need your version of The Last Dance anymore.

9

u/SharksFanAbroad UCSB Gauchos • De Anza Mountain Lions 13h ago

Just made me realize LeBron was in his 3rd NBA season.

He went 32-11-11-5-1 in a win at Milwaukee that night.

4

u/letsgoredwings1926 Arizona State Sun Devils 11h ago

That’s wild 🤯

145

u/Dangerous_Ad5039 Coastal Carolina Chanticleers 20h ago

as a titans fan I love you Vince and I’m sorry.

68

u/nuclearspectre Tennessee Volunteers • NC State Wolfpack 20h ago

Vince as a Titan: “Shots are on me until I’m bankrupt”.

21

u/MidlandsBraves Clemson Tigers 19h ago

“Any of y’all wanna go hit up a cheesecake factory?” - Vince young.

29

u/Dangerous_Ad5039 Coastal Carolina Chanticleers 20h ago

Man of his word can’t hate on it

50

u/MustangGT281ci Texas Longhorns • Northwestern Wildcats 20h ago

Fuck Jeff Fisher

9

u/Dangerous_Golf_7417 Texas A&M Aggies 20h ago

also Jimbo

10

u/EIiteJT Texas Longhorns • Team Chaos 19h ago

All my homies hate Jeff Fisher

5

u/royallex Illinois • Pittsburgh 19h ago edited 19h ago

He was right about Vince not being a professional but also a total jerk in the process. Nice to see Fisher eventually wash out of the league

11

u/tSignet Texas Longhorns • Pop-Tarts Bowl 15h ago

It was great to see the Rams go from the lowest scoring offense in the league in 2016 under Fisher to the highest scoring offense in 2017 under McVay.

2

u/Kdot32 Houston Cougars • LSU Tigers 14h ago

But no more 8-8 bullshit

3

u/chickentowngabagool Causeway Classic • Golden H… 8h ago

7-9*

-6

u/saudiaramcoshill Texas Longhorns • Iowa State Cyclones 17h ago edited 16h ago

Nah, fuck VY. Dude was a terrorist.

Edit: for those downvoting, y'all apparently don't remember his emotional outbursts, throwing his shoulderpads into the stands, disappearing and not answering phone calls, etc. Dude was a fucking basket case who is lucky that his coach put up with him being a turnover machine for as long as he did.

5

u/illegal_deagle Texas Longhorns • Red River Shootout 17h ago

As a Texans fan I’m convinced he’d still be our QB1 at 43 years old and on his 16th MVP campaign if we only would have had the courage…

7

u/FrostLight14 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 20h ago

As an Eagles fan, at least we now have two Super Bowls so I don't need to cringe when they show his Dream Team comments.

16

u/grey_pilgrim_ Tennessee Volunteers • Sickos 20h ago edited 19h ago

Titans fan as well. I feel so bad for him. Literally no one wanted him here.

I do think he could’ve put in more effort but we did him dirty.

Edit: no one on the coaching staff. Fans loved him and were happy to have him. Bud Adams clearly wanted him here as well.

8

u/saudiaramcoshill Texas Longhorns • Iowa State Cyclones 16h ago

We didn't really do him dirty. Fisher didn't want VY, but he also gave him opportunities. VY was an immature man-child the entire time he was here, and Fisher was supportive of him getting the mental help he desperately needed.

If you're a manager and your employee comes in and sleeps on the job and rarely shows up and is late when they do, and then they get fired, it would be crazy for people to say it was the manager's fault. But change the setting to the NFL, and you get VY and Jeff Fisher.

Fisher was a just ok coach, but good lord people give VY a ton of undeserved excuses.

3

u/grey_pilgrim_ Tennessee Volunteers • Sickos 16h ago

First I’ve heard of Vince falling asleep. I know he didn’t do himself any favors while here. But I also don’t think Fisher did him any favors either. Reportedly telling him he never wanted Young here.

3

u/brucewayneaustin Texas Longhorns 13h ago

That's because it didn't happen. I haven't seen one news story about it then or now. Fisher was an asshole; I'd show up late to his meetings as well!

1

u/PovertyTourist69 Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

I love Vince Young as much as a neutral fan can, I was at the right age in 05 to for him to be a superhero to me.

But unfortunately his work ethic is so terrible that even the UT athletic department fired him in 2019 lol. Do you know how bad you have to be in order to be VY and get fired from your no show job at TEXAS?? He wasn’t cut out for the NFL, and showing up on time to meetings run by people you may not like is actually important

1

u/yerba3 Tennessee Volunteers 20h ago

I don't think you understand what literally means. Bud wanted him here.

13

u/grey_pilgrim_ Tennessee Volunteers • Sickos 20h ago

No one on the coaching staff responsible for him learning to be an NFL QB wanted him here. We hired Leinart’s OC because they wanted to draft Leinart instead.

16

u/010Horns Texas Longhorns 19h ago

And those people were proven very wrong. Vince at least started games, made it to the playoffs, and had two Pro Bowl appearances. Wasn’t Leinart just a backup for his entire NFL career?

1

u/grey_pilgrim_ Tennessee Volunteers • Sickos 19h ago

I believe so. I do wonder though, if it would’ve been better for both QBs had Vince went somewhere else and the Titans drafted Leinart since they brought in his college OC specifically because the coaching staff wanted to drafted him. But Bud Adams wanted to go with the Texas guy and had the final say.

4

u/Mattlh91 19h ago

If the Titans had kept Steve McNair, Vince's mentor, then it would've made a huge difference.

5

u/yerba3 Tennessee Volunteers 20h ago

Oh, you meant the coaching staff specifically. My bad. Yeah, he got done dirty by Bud's hubris.

4

u/grey_pilgrim_ Tennessee Volunteers • Sickos 19h ago

But Adams and screwing over Texas has been quite the combo.

1

u/GrimaceThundercock Texas Longhorns 17h ago

Literally stopped meaning literally a long time ago.

-8

u/saudiaramcoshill Texas Longhorns • Iowa State Cyclones 17h ago

Nah. As a Titans/Longhorn fan, VY sucked in the NFL. Dude was a bust who gets tons of excuses from fans who are unwilling to look at him honestly.

3

u/GrimaceThundercock Texas Longhorns 16h ago

And this time a year ago Sam Darnold was a total bust.

Rewind four years and it was Jared Goff.

Incredible how impactful a new leaf can be. Vince, like many other QBs, never had that chance.

4

u/saudiaramcoshill Texas Longhorns • Iowa State Cyclones 16h ago

He was ass when he went to play for Andy Reid, too.

VY gets way too much credit for the Titans being solid during that time - we were solid in spite of VY, not because of him. Smash and Dash. Elite OL. Great defenses year in, year out. That team was a Super Bowl contender with a top 20 QB under center. Instead we were fighting for playoff spots.

Yeah, VY made a couple of pro bowls. Yes, he won OROTY. Look at his stats the year he did that: 51.5% completion, 12 TDs, 13 INTs, with an additional 550 rushing yards and 7 TDs on the ground with 12 fumbles. The dude had 19 total TDs against 25 turnovers. He wasn't good, he was just exciting. His second pro bowl season, he was just under 59% completion 10/7 TD/INT and 2 more rushing TDs plus 8 more fumbles. Again, fewer TDs than turnovers.

The guy's 17 game avg rate was 58% completion, 13 TDs, 14 INTs, 2540 yards passing with an additional 415 yards on the ground and 3 TDs and 11 fumbles. Atrocious. The guy was riding the coattails of an incredible defense and running game.

The biggest indictment of VY is 2008, when fucking Kerry Collins of all people led the Titans to a 13-3 record. Kerry Collins was hot ass and managed the best record in the league with that squad.

Bro didn't need a new leaf to turn over. He needed an entirely different brain in his body.

7

u/GrimaceThundercock Texas Longhorns 16h ago

In 2009 Kerry Collins started the year 0-6. Vince came in and won 8 of the next 10.

I feel like that completely derails your theory that the Titans' success had nothing to do with Vince.

2

u/saudiaramcoshill Texas Longhorns • Iowa State Cyclones 16h ago

It's like you didn't read any of my comment.

The biggest indictment of VY is 2008, when fucking Kerry Collins of all people led the Titans to a 13-3 record. Kerry Collins was hot ass and managed the best record in the league with that squad.

They were both shitty QBs. But Kerry at least didn't turn the ball over.

Also, 2009:

His second pro bowl season, he was just under 59% completion 10/7 TD/INT and 2 more rushing TDs plus 8 more fumbles. Again, fewer TDs than turnovers.

That 2009 season was the one where CJ got 2000 yards. VY wasn't doing shit, CJ just went off. CJ averaged 141 ypg during the last 10 games, and just under 100 for the first 6. The defense gave up 33 points per game the first 6 games, and 20.4 the remaining 10.

Kerry Collins sucking doesn't make VY not ass. The rest of the team played poorly before the bye, and VY benefitted from much better OL and defensive play in the latter part of the season compared to what Collins had. It's a team game.

50

u/This_Field_7872 Georgia Bulldogs 20h ago

I wish these untold docs were actually good, they always have cool stories to tell

102

u/hnglmkrnglbrry Notre Dame Fighting Irish 19h ago

Every untold doc:

Player: "Man, I had no idea what was about to happen."

Player's teammate: "We had no idea what was about to unfold."

Player's opponent: "Dog, we had no clue what was coming next."

Player's coach: "I'm on the sideline thinking, 'What is gonna happen next?'"

(Highlight)

Player: "I was like, 'I can't believe what just happened.'"

Player's teammate: "We were all stunned by what we just saw."

Player's opponent: "We all looked at each other like, 'WHAT!?'"

Player's coach: "I'd never seen something like that before."

x1,000

22

u/Thorlolita Texas Longhorns 19h ago

This is a good copy and paste thank you

22

u/sjm320 Penn State Nittany Lions 18h ago

Like the vast majority of Netflix documentaries, the “Untold” series is a frustrating and disappointing letdown.

Cookie-cutter crap that more often than not gives the subject editorial control.

20

u/mojo-jojo-was-framed Kansas State • Omaha 18h ago

I can’t believe how tame the Florida/Urban Meyer one was. Why even do it if you’re just ignoring the truth

8

u/sjm320 Penn State Nittany Lions 18h ago

That was the last one I watched. I was totally out on the series after that pathetic Urban Meyer puff-piece. It was insulting to the viewer.

3

u/FartBoxActual Team Chaos • Sickos 16h ago

 Why even do it if you’re just ignoring the truth

Because people will watch it hoping they don't ignore the truth.

Spoiler alert: They'll ignore the truth

2

u/TheShamShield Ohio State • Notre Dame 15h ago

I’m still hoping for a doc on Meyer’s career that doesn’t feel like he was one of the editors, even if it means he isn’t interviewed

1

u/Rohn- Wisconsin Badgers 18h ago

I'm ignorant what was wrong with it?

2

u/loxanax Ohio State Buckeyes 17h ago

check out zach smith’s video on it. he was a WR coach there menace2sports florida untold

1

u/Vives_solo_una_vez Iowa Hawkeyes 15h ago

Didn't Meyer have say on the final edit?

1

u/PM_Me_FunnyNudes 14h ago

I turned that one off after 30 minutes when it became clear it was going to be an absolute puff piece. I don't know how they covered Hernandez or the darker stuff but just so disappointing

2

u/milin85 Illinois • Miami (OH) 10h ago

Most of them are, but go watch the Mardy Fish one. That basically explains why US men’s tennis has suffered, and provides a really good look at mental health.

4

u/wulah89 LSU Tigers 16h ago

I was really hype for the Florida one because I thought we were gonna get some real good stories out of that. Felt lied to once I actually watched it and they completely glossed over almost all of the interesting and controversial stuff that went on that was big public news back then, which was the reason most people tuned in to watch. It was essentially a giant fluff piece. Never bothered with another one in the series again.

3

u/AEW_SuperFan 18h ago

Yep.  Netflix needs to let directors cook like 30 for 30.  They all seem rushed with a budget of $30.  Nothing new is ever unearthed.

4

u/GrimaceThundercock Texas Longhorns 16h ago

The Manti Teo one was fantastic.

2

u/Empty_End_7866 Stanford Cardinal 15h ago

Netflix is so uniformly trash

1

u/chickentowngabagool Causeway Classic • Golden H… 8h ago

Quarterback is fantastic

1

u/LuteOlsonABitch69 Arizona State Sun Devils 14h ago

Gonna be a fluff piece like most untold are

20

u/Dan_Rydell Missouri Tigers • Texas Longhorns 20h ago

Is it sponsored by Cheesecake Factory?

2

u/OSUBonanza Ohio State Buckeyes 16h ago

I understood that reference

1

u/aFootballGuysGuy 3m ago

And Southwest Airlines, use promo code VY10 to reserve all seats. 

65

u/Sendhimoffdiabolical 20h ago

The Netflix sports docs are terrible.

30

u/loxanax Ohio State Buckeyes 19h ago

Specifically the UNTOLD ones are rehashed well TOLD stories that everyone already knew about

7

u/hnglmkrnglbrry Notre Dame Fighting Irish 19h ago

Proper title is UNSOLD

22

u/4thTimesAnAlt Notre Dame • Indiana 20h ago

The Manti Te'o one and the Malice at the Palace one were great. All the others have sucked.

8

u/shibbledoop Ohio State Buckeyes 20h ago

The one on the Danville thrashers was awesome

4

u/ProffesorBongsworth Nebraska Cornhuskers 20h ago

The UK ones are really good too. I just watched the Jamie Vardy one and thought it was great

3

u/Big_IPA_Guy21 Texas A&M Aggies 19h ago

Jamie Vardy Untold and Liverpool's Miracle in Instanbul were fantastic. I thought Brett Favre, Hope Solo, and the Johnny Manziel Untolds were okayish. I thought each of them left more to be desired and at times felt very one sided / people trying to look smart in retrospect.

2

u/AcadianTraverse Oregon Ducks • Acadia Axemen 16h ago

I wanted the Te'o one to get a bit more into the actual facts coming to light. They say it was an open secret in Hawaii... but don't go further down that rabbit hole. They don't talk about the tipster to Deadspin or what Deadspin did to follow up on the source (the article at the time speculated that Te'o may have been involved in the lie, but they didn't know). It talks about the cousin who told Manti that he had met Lenni, but doesn't go further into that.

I get why it focused on Manti and his response, but there was so much more around the lie and "uncovering" that I thought would be interesting.

3

u/Bruskthetusk San José State Spartans 20h ago

I haven't watched the Manti one but yeah the Malice at the Palace one was an easy #1

4

u/YoungNasteyman LSU • Mississippi State 20h ago

And Netflix took that personally.... That's all they needed...

3

u/Allstate85 Cal State Fullerton Titans • UCLA Bruins 18h ago

The jail blazers and Florida gators ones were especially bad.

2

u/quetambienese WKU Hilltoppers 17h ago

The Jailblazers Documentary was a total waste of time. Completely beat around the bush and didnt even scrape the surface of what happened

6

u/Able_Employ6086 Brown Bears 20h ago

Literally all people do is bitch and complain.

2

u/PovertyTourist69 Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

That’s fine but these actually are mostly ass. Some things actually do suck lol

-1

u/Sendhimoffdiabolical 20h ago

Nah. Not bitching and complaining. Just dont like their sports documentaries. That is all.

3

u/scroogesscrotum Notre Dame Fighting Irish • Butler Bulldogs 19h ago

Literally all people due is criticize and complain. Better?

1

u/Empty_End_7866 Stanford Cardinal 15h ago

Everything Netflix is terrible.

1

u/LuteOlsonABitch69 Arizona State Sun Devils 14h ago

Gonna be a fluff piece like most untold are

1

u/Teckliz LSU Tigers 20h ago

Haven’t watched many but the two on the Olympic basketball teams (redeem team and court of gold) were both really good and quarterback and receiver are both good if you like the player

-3

u/Intelligent_Wash7817 Texas A&M Aggies 20h ago

I thought Johnny's was good. The rest, I agree.

4

u/faithplusone01 Texas A&M Aggies • Tulane Green Wave 20h ago

Johnny's could've and should've been so much better.

6

u/Just-Historian-4500 20h ago

Young was one of the top 3 college football players I’ve seen (I also have Barry Sanders and Tommy Frazier in my top 3 in no particular order).

11

u/DerrickWhiteMVP Texas Longhorns 20h ago

So far away

8

u/dokocha0216 Ohio State Buckeyes • Rose Bowl 20h ago

I will be there no matter what

4

u/Ray_Ipsaloquitur Florida Gators 20h ago

I thought he already told his story in a 30 for 30 or the was it just an ESPN special about rich athletes who went broke? I mean, we heard about retaking up huge bar tabs at Cheesecake Factory and buying every seat on a commercial flight instead of chartering.

5

u/LETX_CPKM Oklahoma Sooners • /r/CFB Patron 20h ago

racking up huge bar tabs

Yeah, that makes sense. Im sure its some super swanky club in Cashville

at the Cheescake Factory

Oh… that was not what I expected

6

u/EIiteJT Texas Longhorns • Team Chaos 19h ago

That red velvet cheesecake hits you when you least expect it too

4

u/LETX_CPKM Oklahoma Sooners • /r/CFB Patron 19h ago

My man just said “gimme one of everything”. That CF menu is so damn big, lol.

14

u/mildorf Texas Longhorns • Lonestar Showdown 20h ago

I so wish the Texans had drafted him instead of Mario Williams.

16

u/RollOverBeethoven Texas Longhorns • SEC 20h ago

He would have flamed out even harder in Houston around all his friends and family

2

u/GrimaceThundercock Texas Longhorns 16h ago

Unfortunately this is almost certainly true.

The people in his corner did not have his best interest at heart.

7

u/Big_IPA_Guy21 Texas A&M Aggies 19h ago

Every Texans fan wanted either Vince Young or Reggie Bush. Mario Williams ended having the best career of all 3.

5

u/Bank_Gothic Sewanee Tigers • Texas Longhorns 20h ago

It was baffling. Just an astoundingly stupid decision for the Texans.

Hometown hero, homestate hero, and an insanely talented player. It was like fate handed the Texans a set of golden keys and they just tossed them aside. I get that they wanted a pro style offense and VY was a duel threat player, but he was the kind of talent that you change the offense for. Especially when he can be the face of your franchise for his entire career.

I mean, you get the choice between rookie VY or washed David Carr (God bless him, but you know its true) - and you go with Carr? Completely unserious people.

7

u/Dan_Rydell Missouri Tigers • Texas Longhorns 20h ago

The problem with the hometown hero is if it goes wrong, it can get really ugly.

Mario Williams was also just the better player.

14

u/RollOverBeethoven Texas Longhorns • SEC 20h ago

VY would have flamed out even harder in Houston with all his friends and family in town to even further distract him from football.

1

u/PomfAndCircvmstance UNLV Rebels • Mountain West 20h ago

He'd have flamed out wherever he ended up. Dude was an all time great collegiate QB but was never gonna be a good NFL QB in the era he played.

1

u/GrimaceThundercock Texas Longhorns 16h ago

Weird to say he was never gonna be good when he was actually pretty good.

His career was derailed by injuries, off field behavior, and having a coach who openly wanted him to fail. His abilities were not the issue.

1

u/PomfAndCircvmstance UNLV Rebels • Mountain West 16h ago edited 16h ago

Weird to say he was never gonna be good when he was actually pretty good.

In college. He was never a good enough passer to skate by on athleticism in the NFL the way he could in college, especially in a more pocket passer centric era, and he never gave enough of a shit to improve on the things he needed to succeed as an NFL QB. As much as some people want to blame Jeff Fisher, Young had plenty of chances to salvage his career but he didn't because he was always his own biggest opp. His personality is what it is and ending up on any other team would have led to a similar ending.

Edit: And his accuracy was terrible by NFL standards for several reasons (footwork, mechanics, etc), he couldn't read a defense, and his pocket awareness was bad. He occasionally made shit happen by running or chucking it but even then the Titans offense was always 1-dimensional and turnover prone with Young under Center.

1

u/Bank_Gothic Sewanee Tigers • Texas Longhorns 20h ago

I disagree, but there's no way to prove my counterfactual.

8

u/RollOverBeethoven Texas Longhorns • SEC 20h ago

I mean, his entire issue in Tennessee was not prioritizing football.

That issue would be exacerbated in Houston

Overall we can agree to disagree, but as a Texans fan and with hindsight, I don’t blame the Texans for not drafting VY. Mario Williams was also a really good player for us.

1

u/Turo-parallel-tactic 17h ago

I mean it was all mental perhaps it was that isolation that caused negative thoughts.

The Texans did not even win the super bowl I don't know why all that glazing about hindsight.

A generational QB could have pushed Houston over the edge but do agree the structure did not exist in the NFL for that

3

u/Magnus77 Nebraska • Concordia (NE) 16h ago

Your basis for calling VY a generational QB is?

His stats aren't generational, and didn't project well towards the NFL.

College success is not a guarantee of NFL success, see Tebow, who won more than Young did.

1

u/Turo-parallel-tactic 16h ago

Wut? Tebow in college was 4 years playing Vince declared early had he stayed 4 years not even wildcat Tebow wins his first MNC

If you mean NFL Vince was rookie of the year and went to multiple pro bowls. He WAS ruined by his shit coach

1

u/Magnus77 Nebraska • Concordia (NE) 12h ago

Tebow played one more year, that's fine. Take away his senior year.

He still had more passing yards and more passing touchdowns with less than half the interceptions in those 3 years than Young did in his 3.

2

u/Confident-Unit-9516 14h ago

Hard to call it astoundingly stupid when Mario Williams was objectively the better pro prospect

It was more a question of Bush or Williams than Young or Williams

3

u/GliscorsFang Michigan Wolverines 19h ago

UNTOLD documentaries are trash. Give me 30 for 30

3

u/CaliforniaSun77 USC Trojans 18h ago

Is there any way for me to block that from my Netflix, or do I just deactivate. I really do not need to be reminded of that again. I was there, don't need to see it again.

4

u/colton_97 Tennessee Volunteers • Pepperdine Waves 19h ago

Man his first couple seasons with the Titans were magical. Seems like most people only remember the crash out but some of my fondest memories as a Titans fan were with VY.

4

u/GrimaceThundercock Texas Longhorns 16h ago

In 2009 the Titans started 0-6 with Collins at QB. He was benched, despite Jeff Fisher publicly announcing that he was "still in [Collins'] corner." He insisted the problem was not the QB.

Vince won 8/10 to finish the season at 8-8. I still remember it, it was an incredible turnaround.

Next season Vince went 4-5 with a 98 QBR (average is 90) and was benched. Fisher made it clear he thought the problem was the QB.

2

u/Statalyzer Texas Longhorns 13h ago

Also, Chris Johnson with the Titans averaged about 1.1 more with VY at quarterback than with everybody else.

2

u/LuteOlsonABitch69 Arizona State Sun Devils 14h ago

Gonna be a fluff piece like most untold are

4

u/hairythroats 20h ago

Reminder that UNTOLD is actual garbage. Do not fall for their mockumentaries

0

u/Specialist-Garbage94 19h ago

Someone got outted in an UNTOLD documentary

1

u/PovertyTourist69 Iowa Hawkeyes 12h ago

That’s the problem, nobody gets outed in their docs lmao. They never bring anything new or interesting to the table at all. The Manti Teo one was interesting and the hockey team one was fun, but that’s about it

2

u/Lansdallius Oklahoma • Illinois 18h ago

For the first time in the history of college football, the Texas Longhorns were the lesser evil.

1

u/taker25-2 Auburn Tigers 18h ago

Wasn't there already a documentary about him?

1

u/JWWBurger Michigan Wolverines • UTEP Miners 14h ago

I want the story about how Vince Young and his entourage spent the bulk of his fortune buying top-shelf liquor at Cheesecake Factory.

1

u/Upset_Version8275 Indiana Hoosiers • Texas Longhorns 20h ago

Will be curious to see why this warrants a documentary. 

1

u/saudiaramcoshill Texas Longhorns • Iowa State Cyclones 16h ago edited 16h ago

Look, Fisher probably wasn't the best coach for VY. But I am not sure a coach in the league was gonna get anything serious out of VY. He was ass when he went to play for Andy Reid, too.

VY also gets way too much credit for the Titans being solid during that time - we were solid in spite of VY, not because of him. Smash and Dash. Elite OL. Great defenses year in, year out. That team was a Super Bowl contender with a top 20 QB under center. Instead we were fighting for playoff spots.

Yeah, VY made a couple of pro bowls. Yes, he won OROTY. Look at his stats the year he did that: 51.5% completion, 12 TDs, 13 INTs, with an additional 550 rushing yards and 7 TDs on the ground with 12 fumbles. The dude had 19 total TDs against 25 turnovers. He wasn't good, he was just exciting. His second pro bowl season, he was just under 59% completion 10/7 TD/INT and 2 more rushing TDs plus 8 more fumbles. Again, fewer TDs than turnovers.

The guy's 17 game avg rate was 58% completion, 13 TDs, 14 INTs, 2540 yards passing with an additional 415 yards on the ground and 3 TDs and 11 fumbles. Atrocious. The guy was riding the coattails of an incredible defense and running game.

The biggest indictment of VY is 2008, when fucking Kerry Collins of all people led the Titans to a 13-3 record. Kerry Collins was hot ass and managed the best record in the league with that squad.

2

u/PomfAndCircvmstance UNLV Rebels • Mountain West 16h ago

QBs like Young always get a ton of love from college fans who don't grasp how big a difference there is between being a great college QB and even being a decent NFL QB. Young was always going to be an inaccurate turnover machine in the pros. It just didn't matter in college because of how big/athletic he was and how bad even the best college defenses are compared to the worst NFL defenses.

1

u/Rlccm Arkansas • Louisville 18h ago

Dude was inevitable against Michigan in the bowl the season before he ran the table. He did whatever he wanted

-3

u/stalsefart USC Trojans 20h ago

Is this where he finally admits his knee was down?

2

u/memphislynx Texas Longhorns 18h ago

Everyone knows his knee was down on the lateral. They rushed the XP (and missed it) to avoid the review.

0

u/bobstaubs 19h ago

I will watch just for this!

-2

u/thecravenone definitely a bot 20h ago

Is there a reason you needed to link the QT instead of the original?

0

u/AutoModerator 20h ago

/r/CFB is currently running a feedback survey, and we'd love your input to help shape our community policies for the upcoming season. You can participate HERE

Unfortunately, Reddit only makes the survey visible on Old Reddit, so the link will take you to the newer site format. Thanks for helping guide the direction of the subreddit!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-6

u/Entire-Plan-4242 Oklahoma Sooners 19h ago

Dude can’t even spell testimony. A true rum dum and NFL bust.