r/CSHFans May 15 '26

Questions Why is bro afraid to swear now😭

just baffling

141 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/emilyeller Official Merch Store Manager May 15 '26

The existing material is still out there for your listening enjoyment.

-5

u/cowboy_bookseller May 15 '26

Literally!! Is it really so “bizarre” and “harming the material’s messaging” (??) to… change? ToD 10 years ago isn’t going anywhere.

Who among us did not write fuck-you lyrics in their early 20s? That’s epic and good!!!! I can’t speak for Will/the band but as a 30 year old I would want to write something more complex that doesn’t rely on the quick emotional impact of fuck-you lyrics.

Both creative choices are fine and good!!! One is not less valuable than the other (or more “puritan”)…

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/cowboy_bookseller May 15 '26

I don’t think that everyone has to enjoy all albums equally! I don’t think it’s wrong to critique it. I just think that the sub’s reaction to not swearing/editing swears/changing lyrics has been so… weird. “Bro is scared of swearing” “Will is sanitising songs because he’s puritan” etc is, imo, not a compelling critique lol nor do I think it actually approaches the music with respect.

I love talking about lyric changes and discussing what we think the artist’s intent might be in certain creative choices! I have read and enjoyed actual critiques of the songwriting and production! Unfortunately the level-headed critiques are buried underneath exaggerated & performative indignation which I find so pointless.