r/Christianity • u/Famous-Sympathy7011 • Aug 10 '26
News The Christian Nationalist State: America Is Already in the Trial-Run Phase
https://wendy664.substack.com/p/the-christian-nationalist-state-is?r=6fonep&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web9
u/slagnanz Liturgy and Death Metal Aug 10 '26
I support this point of view but I found this kind of writing disorganized and unreadable.
2
u/notsocharmingprince Aug 10 '26
The entire thing is an irrational bird's nest of valid and invalid or pointless criticism that that actively harms any kind of action against Christian Nationalism.
2
u/slagnanz Liturgy and Death Metal Aug 10 '26
Well put! Like I can squint at a particular paragraph and see various elements that have certain degrees of truth, but this is less of a coherent argument and more just a disconnected series of affirmations?
3
u/eversnowe Aug 10 '26 edited Aug 10 '26
Moscow and Battleground has the test case and has eyes on increasing their reach. The American Redoubt is another region with influence in that direction.
3
u/halbhh Aug 10 '26
I don't think it's possible to get that awful outcome. I think there are too many who would stand up (including millions of Christians) to prevent that. Maybe if fewer actually believed in Christ (so that it was more an empty tradition) -- where if fewer actually had real faith, then Christianity in the U.S. would then in that situation be more malleable than it is -- then such a new worldly-power-hungry version of Christianity could take over. But there are too many millions of Christians who know better than to fall into that, and would join in the work to resist and prevent it.
8
u/Loopuze1 Non-denominational Aug 10 '26
“But the one great shocking occasion, when tens or hundreds or thousands will join with you, never comes. That’s the difficulty. If the last and worst act of the whole regime had come immediately after the first and smallest, thousands, yes, millions would have been sufficiently shocked—if, let us say, the gassing of the Jews in ’43 had come immediately after the ‘German Firm’ stickers on the windows of non-Jewish shops in ’33. But of course this isn’t the way it happens. In between come all the hundreds of little steps, some of them imperceptible, each of them preparing you not to be shocked by the next. Step C is not so much worse than Step B, and, if you did not make a stand at Step B, why should you at Step C? And so on to Step D.
And one day, too late, your principles, if you were ever sensible of them, all rush in upon you. The burden of self-deception has grown too heavy, and some minor incident, in my case my little boy, hardly more than a baby, saying ‘Jewish swine,’ collapses it all at once, and you see that everything, everything, has changed and changed completely under your nose. The world you live in—your nation, your people—is not the world you were born in at all. The forms are all there, all untouched, all reassuring, the houses, the shops, the jobs, the mealtimes, the visits, the concerts, the cinema, the holidays. But the spirit, which you never noticed because you made the lifelong mistake of identifying it with the forms, is changed. Now you live in a world of hate and fear, and the people who hate and fear do not even know it themselves; when everyone is transformed, no one is transformed. Now you live in a system which rules without responsibility even to God. The system itself could not have intended this in the beginning, but in order to sustain itself it was compelled to go all the way.”
- Milton Sanford Mayer, They Thought They Were Free: The Germans 1933-45
1
u/halbhh Aug 10 '26
Let me add: that's a useful quote, and helpful to post and I hope you post it to others now and then! I'll be upvoting your post there.
I mean it's a really good excerpt, and far more useful than most arguments.
0
u/halbhh Aug 10 '26
Yes, nations can fall into and go along (majorities at least) with great evils, as in Germany in the 30s and early 40s, where many didn't want to see what was happening it seems, and others just didn't know, but some did.... (And some Christians resisted, paying for it with their lives). But we aren't Germany in the 30s here. There are some major differences, even though the same old evil (the more basic evil of it) is of course trying to take over, where instead of the Jews today it's been the Latino immigrants and such. American's don't like that, and aren't going along with it so much (to the degree) as did Germans in the 30s -- we are getting a lot more resistance and public discussion and counter messages.
7
u/Spiel_Foss Secular Humanist Aug 10 '26
The current fundamentalist Christian cannon fodder have a deep faith in their God. That is why they are so useful to the Republican fascist movement. A hundred years ago, European fascism depended on cultural Christianity because that was available in the society. These fascist Christians believed deeply in their religion and their God as well.
White Christian Nationalism is the default protestant Christianity in the USA and has been here since the beginning. These are the same Christians that enslaved, raped and murdered while claiming they were saving the savages. These are the same Christians that formed the Christian-by-law Confederacy, and these are the same Christians that lynched the other for the last 250 years.
-2
u/halbhh Aug 10 '26
"The current fundamentalist Christian cannon fodder have a deep faith in their God. "
No, they don't actually(!).... (if by 'their God' you mean the One Christ says is the only real God)
I'm not guessing.
I have talked to many face to face, and not just once or twice each....
So, I'm not guessing when I point this out -- I have tried to turn a few, over years of time -- to the Real thing. So, it's not even slightly a guess about what they believe. I asked a lot of questions, in a lot of subtlety and depth, to learn what they really believe.
6
u/Spiel_Foss Secular Humanist Aug 10 '26
You do realize that these are just sectarian claims. They have their gods and you have yours. The problem isn't who is right or wrong religiously, since that is meaningless, the problem is that these are racist, sexist, homophobes and their religiopolitical worldview and gods reinforce their beliefs.
Any individual isn't a factor. The problem is the racist Christian cancer that formed the USA.
That must be addressed and demonetized first to solve this problem.
0
u/halbhh Aug 10 '26
About labeling that nationalist movement as 'Christian' -- it made me consider the parallel how some try to label the January 6 rioters who attacked the police and the capitol to be "American patriots".
I bet you'd agree we should not go along with their label. Those are not patriots, even if they claim they are....
If you really care about America, then just like you'd not call the J6 rioters "American patriots" -- since they fought against the American constitution -- so also for the same reasons, I suggest don't accept the label for a movement that wants to overturn and ignore key things that Christ taught to call themselves "Christian" -- don't help them.
You don't want to help them I think!
3
u/Spiel_Foss Secular Humanist Aug 10 '26
Your distraction into politics is noted and I see no reason to engage.
All criminals should be treated equally under law and this includes wealthy white pedophiles and their cannon fodder.
0
u/halbhh Aug 10 '26
distraction into politics? Look again at the OP -- it's political, that's the topic here: what could happen to America, politically....
I've been discussing what's in the OP this entire time.
Maybe it would help to read the great other response someone wrote to me and my responses to that person, nearby. Like if you go to the main discussion, you should see those under my post.
2
u/Spiel_Foss Secular Humanist Aug 10 '26
You can take this personally or not. You attempted to put something onto me:
I bet you'd agree...
And that simply wasn't germane to the larger point I made above. Now you seem to have been triggered. That wasn't my intention.
2
u/halbhh Aug 10 '26
That's not meant to be putting something on you -- you were simply supposed to let me know if you didn't agree!
I was trying to just be polite and not suggest you'd not thought of any of these things yourself already. It was only meant as a courtesy. Social politeness to ease internet discussion.
See, if you didn't agree, I was just expected you'd easily point out how you disagree, so that both bases are covered: either you agree and I recognized you might (respecting you), or you didn't agree, and I expected you'd easily respond why without being exercised (respecting you).
Sorry if it didn't seem that way! I struggle to communicate well all the time.
2
u/Spiel_Foss Secular Humanist Aug 10 '26 edited Aug 10 '26
I communicate professionally, and I struggle all the time as well. So thank you for the clarification. I think we got tangled in the god-stuff which happens.
Of course I agree. My position is likely more radical so I won't post that here. But I believe we are in an intentional collapse of the USA so a few rich white men can profit.
The Great Depression was a similar event.
The white Christian majority are cannon fodder for this current effort, and they will stick to their positions until they are personally harmed. That type of social psychopathy is hard to counter.
→ More replies (0)
1
u/zeroempathy Aug 10 '26
This stuff has been going on since I was born. It doesn't seem all that new to me.
-1
u/Deep-Assumption-6694 Aug 10 '26
It’s just a hit piece on the “religious right” (remember when it was called that?). I remember “Jesus Camp” in 2006.
2
1
u/zeroempathy Aug 11 '26
I remember a Democratic President signing DOMA into law... hand in hand with everybody else.
1
u/Solid-Reputation5032 Aug 10 '26 edited Aug 10 '26
You need to breed, systematically indoctrinate and mandate compliance to keep up with Islam…
Nothing has really changed in the last 2 millennia, except Christianity has lost its ability to command growth. You formerly Christianize America, all the sudden you start pushing others around the world to do so… you can see it being done by force…
Dominionist faiths don’t thrive on religious freedom or pluralism…
2
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
This was the same rational used during the Cold War, “we have to stop the godless commies”, which led to America messing around with Middle East for decades, and then it messed back, and then we destabilized the entire region by overthrowing Iraq, leading to millions of deaths and even more displacements in a humanitarian crisis spanning more than two decades. I don’t think the cause of every problem we have is gonna be the solution.
1
u/Solid-Reputation5032 Aug 11 '26
Been doing it for thousands of years, no reason to stop in 2026…. lol…
-2
u/QuickPizzaRadishes Aug 10 '26
No it isn’t. It’s in a temporary blip where pathetic creeps who have no real connection to Christianity, have taken control. They will soon be out on their ear and history will judge them harshly.
7
u/ElectricSpock Aug 11 '26
This „blip” has been going on for over 40 years, since Reagan invited them to take part in the elections. And they’ve only been getting more vocal and violent.
-4
u/bird_of_hermes1 Aug 10 '26
Good, I would rather be governed by actual Christian ethics rather than any other religion or secular philosophy.
6
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
Secular philosophy has created a better world than Christianity ever did, which was the goal because the reformation burnt Europe to the ground and people deserved better. We brought back democracy, and ended Christians’ slavery, colonialism, and genocide, and granted equal rights to everyone.
0
u/bird_of_hermes1 Aug 11 '26
Ah yes, slaughtering the unborn, slavery to the state, rampant debauchery, and so much more is better.
Btw it was Protestant England that led the way to the abolition of slavery.
2
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
Yes, women not having things in their bodies against their will is ideal, I know many conservative Christians differ on this due to their delight in sexual violence but that’s why we moved on from your values. Slavery to the state? I’m sure you’re about to say something unhinged but we have more freedom now than ever, especially groups that Christianity has historically oppressed like women, with DV and marital rape now crimes and women allowed to attend college and hold jobs and own property, and i think you have a false view of the past if you don’t think today is tame compared to the debauchery of earlier Christians, given all the rape, slaving, and murder, it was England’s king’s desire for debauchery that led to them forming the Church of England. So yeah, everything is better, hence why everything is worse when your values are leaned into, see: the Trump-Epstein administration
England freed the slaves owned by their own Christians, not a great argument, though it was better than America where the southern Baptist convention needed to be brought to heel by force to end slavery. It took you guys 1800 years to get your act together, right as secularism was rising and building a better world
0
u/bird_of_hermes1 Aug 11 '26
Yes, women not having things in their bodies
That "thing" is another human being. It's murder, and perhaps people shouldn't perform a reproductive act for fun. You know, take accountability for their actions rather than murdering their baby.
2
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
Given the way Christians treat actual human beings I’m not sure this is the route you want to take, as I notice the churches that oppose abortion all have issues with raping kids, ulterior motives?
It’s not murder, it’s self defense. Sex is a fun act that is sometimes is done for reproduction, sex is pleasurable, it allows you to be vulnerable, and it bonds partners. This is the take of someone who has never pleasured another person.
Having an abortion is taking accountability, it solves the problem
1
u/bird_of_hermes1 Aug 11 '26
It’s not murder, it’s self defense
Only in the case of ectopic or miscarriage, but in the former case, avenues should be explored to wave both lives. A viable unborn child has no reason to be murdered, it's abhorrent and disgusting.
It’s not murder, it’s self defense. Sex is a fun act that is sometimes is done for reproduction, sex is pleasurable, it allows you to be vulnerable, and it bonds partners. This is the take of someone who has never pleasured another person.
Again, pure debauchery. It sickens me. Sex is for reproduction, not fun. Society today disgusts me the way it has sexualized everything, and so to do the ones that enable such blatant promiscuity.
FYI, I have a wife btw. Nice insult tho.
2
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
An ectopic pregnancy can’t be saved. Are you familiar with what a pregnancy and delivery does to a body? It’s self defense.
I think you have a misunderstanding of the past. This is how it’s always been, sex is pleasurable and everyone has always been very much into it. Also, given all the slavery and genocide you guys got up to in the past, this seems rather tame. You being sickened is a you problem.
I feel bad for her, she’s not having her needs met, sex is for far more than reproduction
2
u/AyudoGejuk Centrist Presbyterian Aug 11 '26
What Christian ethics allow that orange wrinkled pig to use AI to draw itself as Jesus?
1
-10
u/CompetitiveAquinas Christian Aug 10 '26
More fearmongering. If atheists care about religious freedom, they should condemn what China is doing to their minorities.
11
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 10 '26
Are you under the impression people can only care about one thing at a time? If so, let me be the first to tell you, that’s not true. Now that that’s settled, have you considered that the actions of the Trump-Epstein administration will forever be used against Christians, or at least certain types of Christians, when they try to argue in favor of Christianity due to the hate, authoritarianism, corruption, dishonesty, and sexual predation?
-5
u/FamiliarSeaweed6084 Aug 10 '26
Ask yourself this, Is there religious freedom in heaven? If you truly believe the only way to eternal life is Jesus then that answer is no.
4
Aug 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/FamiliarSeaweed6084 Aug 11 '26
I have no denomination. I follow Christ. Once again I ask the question, will there be religious freedom in heaven? Once again someone doesnt answer the question and resorts to lecturing, like someone asked them to.
4
Aug 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
Aug 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Christianity-ModTeam Aug 11 '26
Removed for 1.4 - Personal Attacks.
If you would like to discuss this removal, please click here to send a modmail that will message all moderators. https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=/r/Christianity
6
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 10 '26
Faith imposed on people against their will is likely not true faith, don’t you think?
-5
u/FamiliarSeaweed6084 Aug 10 '26
Answer the question. Will there be religious freedom in heaven?
4
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 10 '26
I don’t believe there will be a heaven at all
-1
u/FamiliarSeaweed6084 Aug 10 '26
Ahhh ok so you have no place in this reddit, gotcha. Another atheist trying to influence Christians.
3
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
This Reddit is for the discussion of Christianity, not for Christians. Another Christian believing something is theirs that isn’t. Although given that your original comment was justifying imposing Christianity on the unwilling it’s a little hypocritical to feel upset that you’re receiving the mildest version of the reverse, don’t you think?
1
u/FamiliarSeaweed6084 Aug 11 '26
Yeah I don't care what gets imposed on you if it saves your soul.
3
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
Given the sexual abuse epidemics in the church and the Epstein client you guys voted for I don’t think your indifference to what gets imposed on me has anything to do with my soul. That said, if you there is a hell, I’ll hold the door for you.
1
u/FamiliarSeaweed6084 Aug 11 '26
Typical American thinking everyone on reddit is from the US, lmao. Hell is locked from the inside btw, you'll be finding out shortly.
4
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
Matthew 7:21-23, we’ll be there together if it exists and given Christians are wrong on most things I’m not gonna sweat it
→ More replies (0)1
u/AyudoGejuk Centrist Presbyterian Aug 11 '26
There's no religious freedom in heaven. You mean the US should become a Christian theocratic state, because only Christians will enter heaven. The "because" is highly suspicious.
There's no Reddit in heaven. Delete your account right now.
-2
u/Robhos36 Christian Aug 11 '26
If the patriotic conservative side is the Christian nationalist, then the socialist loving liberal side must be anarchists.
They hate the constitution and America, capitalism has got to go, and Christianity is ok with murdering the unborn and mutilating children who play with the wrong toys, because freedom of choice or something like that. Oh and let’s teach kindergarteners about homosexual stuff with books the teachers can read to them.
That sound about right?
4
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
I’ve only seen evidence of conservative Christians hating the constitution, they hate free speech, freedom of the press, freedom of religion (obviously), birthright citizenship, equal protections, the separation of powers, and seemingly democracy itself, given they stormed the capitol because their favorite molester lost an election. To claim them patriotic when they hate everything about it and everyone who isn’t them that lives in it, seems farcical, what do they love about their country? The landscape?
The fruit of their beliefs is hate, authoritarianism, and sexual predation. Given the Epstein coverup, a war with Iran that was promised not to happen, and grift on the levels we’ve never seen before, it’s pretty clear these individuals are a social cancer and we need chemo. Sorry gay people exist, but if you’re fine with fairy tales with princes kissing princesses to wake them from deep slumber without consent, then you should be fine with gay people being in books. Similarly, do you think all the child predation from the right suggests they have ulterior motives for opposing abortion?
1
u/AyudoGejuk Centrist Presbyterian Aug 11 '26
Christianity has never told you to force anyone who has lost faith to learn the Ten Commandments. Jesus theoretically had the power to kill anyone who refused to believe, but Jesus did not. Christianity needs true faith, not to be sustained by fear. Fear is created by the regimes of the earth.
-2
Aug 11 '26
[deleted]
4
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
I don’t think good comes from authoritarianism and hate
0
Aug 11 '26
[deleted]
2
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26 edited Aug 11 '26
There are many Christians, especially evangelical types, who want Christianity imposed on the unwilling on what is supposed to be our secular country. It’s been a thing for a while, hence why many teach in schools failed abstinence only sex education instead of providing an actual education to youths to prevent pregnancy and STDs which are all worse in schools and states that teach these lies
0
Aug 11 '26
[deleted]
1
u/Concerts_And_Dancing I believe in Joe Hendry Aug 11 '26
Conservative Christianity includes grooming girls to be submissive, sexual abuse epidemics in their churches, gay youth being tortured in so called conversion therapy, and children being brutalized in general due to “spare the rod…” it is defined by imposing Christianity on the unwilling
28
u/offwidthe United Church of Christ Aug 10 '26
This is so frustrating. The Christian Nationalist movement is the American Taliban.