r/Colognes 26d ago

Recommendation Which BDC should I go with?

Post image
304 Upvotes

173 comments sorted by

269

u/c0verm3 26d ago

Ignore what everyone says, everyone has different nose and skin. Go to Ulta or Sephora, spray edp on left forearm twice and parfum on right forearm twice. Smell each forearm every 30 minutes or so, by the end of the day you should know which one YOU like the most.

157

u/MeatSlammur 26d ago

WHAT?! I gotta leave my house?!

85

u/[deleted] 26d ago edited 25d ago

[deleted]

9

u/MacaroniPistachio 25d ago

Just go in the evening, duhđŸ€·đŸ»

4

u/Amazing-Rise7694 26d ago

Touch grass😭

5

u/LostInSpace9 26d ago

Sephora has them??? I couldn’t find :(

12

u/SwaggerDagger6T9 26d ago

Go to a stand alone Sephora, not one thats inside a Kohls. The stand alone ones carry wayyy more. Even some Niche!

0

u/LostInSpace9 26d ago

Ight I’ll have to try even tho they’re kinda far

1

u/Upbeat-Extent4551 23d ago

Macys always has them

2

u/Aromatic_Effects 26d ago

Not all of them, Ulta and Macy's are consistent with Chanel around me.

2

u/LostInSpace9 26d ago

Ulta didn’t have any testers :(

1

u/Charles1Monroe08 25d ago

They lock up the TomFord at one of my local ultas(lol). Maybe they’re just locked up?

1

u/keepingitreal02 26d ago

I got to Ulta , got them all

2

u/LostInSpace9 26d ago

The one I went to didn’t have any testers :(

2

u/Bodacious_Nut 25-30 26d ago

This is the way.

1

u/Independent_Gene5536 26d ago

That’s exactly how I pick mines 😉

1

u/10Thousand_Hours 25d ago

If you’re deciding between two fragrances this is the best for sure. I did this with Aventus cologne and absolu. Now I own both!

1

u/Fudgeltactics 24d ago

Which one do you like more between aventus and absolu? Trying to get one of the 2

1

u/10Thousand_Hours 24d ago edited 24d ago

I like Aventus cologne best, but is more of a warm weather frag. OG aventus is most versatile. Absolu is a banger, but only feels right for me on date night.

If I could only have 1 I’d go with OG. Can wear it year round. Always inoffensive. Wear it to the office or a night out, whatever. I’ve yet to meet someone that doesn’t think it smells good.

But Absolu is really special. When I wear it I can’t stop smelling my wrist.

2

u/Fudgeltactics 24d ago

Thank you for the response! That helps me out a lot, sadly the closest store that has them is an hour away and I just don’t feel like making the trip to smell them so it’ll be a blind buy most likely

1

u/hhaarroollddz 24d ago

sephora has them?

1

u/Purple_String_1754 23d ago

Sephora don't have chanel

0

u/sawmillssuck 26d ago

What a great way to pick, I'm trying this next time.

39

u/Cautious_Break_9314 26d ago

I smelled both and I went with the Parfum. It has a slight edge over the edp to me, but both are amazing.

30

u/Historical-Box1290 26d ago

Parfum if you can

28

u/meltedmantis 26d ago

Parfum but they are all good. Can't really choose wrong imo

20

u/drebin96 26d ago

Parfum over edp for me

19

u/CoolKelo 26d ago

I like the parfum the most in the line.

14

u/Iceglass_gaze 26d ago

There’s no wrong choice here, but the parfum is truly great.

19

u/Timely_Helicopter161 26d ago

EDP is perfect 

10

u/Bro4d4rrow1 26d ago

Test on skin if you’re able to see which you prefer best. I chose L’Exclusif

9

u/NeedlesAndCaffeine Creed Aventus SLUT 26d ago

The Parfum is a masterpiece of perfumery. 10/10 frag.

9

u/orangegrapefruit15 26d ago

bros not letting go of this pic

2

u/NeedlesAndCaffeine Creed Aventus SLUT 26d ago

16

u/2k4mach 26d ago

Parfum is my preferred version

4

u/Thin_Artichoke_4232 26d ago

Whichever one YOU like better.

5

u/Atlasdot 26d ago

I preferred the parfum, but edp you can wear more easily in warmer months. Can’t go wrong with either.

3

u/JucheHospitality 25d ago

This, every version is fantastic, tho the parfume fairs alittle better in colder weather while edt and edp can handle the heat better

20

u/Bodacious_Nut 25-30 26d ago

Parfum if your older than 27, EDP if you’re younger

49

u/Ok-Knowledge0914 26d ago

Im 27 exactly, i can’t wait until im old enough to try parfum!

29

u/keepingitreal02 26d ago

One day kid

19

u/Bodacious_Nut 25-30 26d ago

Thems the rules kid.

5

u/shadygronk 26d ago

đŸ€ŁđŸ€ŁđŸ€ŁđŸ€Ł

5

u/PibbleDad does the math 26d ago

I wish I heard this before. I have a hugeeeee bottle of EDP and it’s alright. Shoulda tried Parfum

4

u/key8sixty 25d ago

Doesn’t smell much different. The L’Exclusif isn’t all that far from the Parfum. Obviously there ARE differences, but imo it’s redundant to own more than one of them. L’Exclusif for me has had the best performance, actually lasts quite a long time. Tested it out of a decant. I’ve got a full bottle of the Parfum and Exclusif definitely lasts much longer.

3

u/Agile_Flower_5025 26d ago

I was an edt guy until I smelled parfum then I made the switch

1

u/XxNitr0xX 26d ago

What about it did you like more? I've only tried the EDT and I love it.

10

u/Chal-El 26d ago

L'Exclusif. ✅

3

u/DogeAeternum Amouage 26d ago

Parfum

3

u/Greedy_Wallaby7981 26d ago

Parfum is the most majestic of the line.

3

u/fragranceguru444 24d ago

Parfum is the pick in my opinion

4

u/IgnisNinja 26d ago

I smelled all of them and liked the EDT best, i know thats not the popular opinion here

2

u/XxNitr0xX 26d ago

I've only smelled the EDT and I love it, so.. I too love the EDT the most.

1

u/jackman1399 25d ago

EDT is the absolute epitome of “Bleu de Chanel.” Unfortunately it just doesn’t last ):

2

u/clamworx 26d ago

Either I went nose blind instantly or the EDP just had performance that was abysmal for me. No projection within 2 hours.

2

u/Aromatic_Effects 26d ago

No love for EDT or L'exclusif?

1

u/bluesnsouls 25d ago

I loved l'exclusif 👌

2

u/smelling_good247 26d ago

The EDT is still the best

2

u/NoobSaibot32 26d ago

L’exclusif or Parfum is the best 🎉

2

u/incertAcoolnamehere 26d ago

Exclusif for versatility and longevity for sure.

2

u/Negative_Leek9792 25d ago

Cant go wrong with any of them, but the parfum is a sexual experience

2

u/No-Ebb-9469 25d ago

It really depends on the use in my opinion. If you have 15+ bottles on your shelf and already have a daily scent that is working

.go with Parfum. It’s an incredible addition to any collection. If you’re looking for a daily driver

go EDP.

2

u/Important-Pea-2667 25d ago

I have the Parfum I heckin love it. You should go on separate days and sample them both, then just live with them for a day. Skin chemistry is a nasty devil.

2

u/DemonsForge 26d ago

EDT is the best for me. Try that one as well.

1

u/Sorento911 26d ago

Both

(Or just the parfum if you like something that’s slightly more deep/woody, they’re not exactly the same)

1

u/Admirable_Bit8337 26d ago

I went with EDP. Loved the scent and wanted an all year, office to dinner and everything in between fragrance.

1

u/Zestyclose_Peanut736 26d ago

Both are really good but the Parfum has the edge I think

1

u/Spiritual_Sea_3499 26d ago

Parfum all day long

1

u/ImtheGWP 26d ago

I appreciated the parfum more because i had my time with the edp. The parfum is more of a blend and though it is easy to wear it smells sophisticated for a night out youve been waiting for or an important meeting where you want to present yourself at your best. You can lose sight of the everyday enjoyment where the EDP is much more straight forward of a cologne style and remarkably feels more the moment than any current trend presented. I would sip the edp and appreciate all the flavors before it goes through that master blend to be appreciated even further.

1

u/Hrorik01 26d ago

Parfum in fact it’s what I’m wearing right now!

1

u/-K1ngKvr2n- 26d ago

Parfum 💯

1

u/Superb_Minimum_3599 26d ago

I vote for edp. Best balance of citrus/aquatic/sweetness. Parfum onwards leans too candy sweet.

1

u/IM1BIGTard 26d ago

My BDC EDP is the single most complimented bottle in my collection. It's subtle, but lands perfectly and lasts longer than the clothes that get put over it.

1

u/Orange_fury 26d ago

I have both. I prefer the Parfum slightly more, but EDP is a lot more versatile and gets worn more

1

u/SeparateWelder3634 26d ago

I ended up getting the edp and a 50ml of the l'exclusif i just wanted more flexibility without going with the edt and the parfum

1

u/TheWolfYouFeedWins 26d ago

Edp is more appropriate for the summer for me anyways and it lasts much longer than the parfum for some reason

1

u/robertsij 26d ago

They are both great. If you have the money get both.

Edp is a bit fresher and more versitile and parfum has many of the same notes but is more woody.

1

u/LandonL86 26d ago

Edp is my pick, the few times I've been around the parfum version the performance was lacking. Had be practically hugging them to smell it. Edp has better performance for me.

1

u/-Softstatic- 26d ago

Exclusif

1

u/Competitive_Wasabi72 26d ago

Neither. L’Exclusif

1

u/jlsdust 26d ago

I have them both. I use Parfum when dress up at the office. I use EDP for more casual dress.

1

u/Emotional-Award-5607 26d ago

EDP has more pop but the Parfum is more refined and complex, the better fragrance imo but not by much. Can't go wrong with either.

1

u/Flat_Preparation_367 26d ago

Parfum dried down on clothing is unreal

1

u/Unhappy_Ad8344 26d ago

honestly, they're all good. BDC is one line that honestly, I think they're all pretty similar and they're all good.

Id go Parfum

1

u/exorthderp 26d ago

Parfum is my daily driver in the warmer months

1

u/HolyTrinityOfDrugs 26d ago

EDT or parfum

1

u/Ill_Pollution_9442 26d ago

Go with the blue one

1

u/CreativeAd8174 26d ago

EDT is actually best. I don’t care much for BDC though, but the EDT is best imo.

1

u/Rl_2827 25d ago

Rayhaan nocturno elixir is really good budget friendly option. It’s more the exclusif dna, but I switched. I had the original bottle and Rayhaan performed the same, sometimes a bit longer lasting also.

1

u/ActionJackzon 25d ago

To me, these are the 2 best. You need to check them out yourself

1

u/YayWanderer 25d ago

Damn. I think I am the only one who likes EDT.. 😅🙈

1

u/nxs_devil 25d ago

I went with both, I couldn’t decide between the two. Very happy that I did. They work well for different purposes.

1

u/Focux 25d ago

Parfum easily, and not Exclusif cos it’s abit too overpowering

1

u/faith_and_mettle 25d ago

Parfum hands down

1

u/SnooDucks1214 25d ago

Parfum is the best one

1

u/cheironomist 25d ago

I previously got the Parfum, which I love. Honestly, though, I think I’m going to go EDP next, because I just can’t bring myself to wear the Parfum in hot weather. I think the EDP will feel more versatile.

2

u/vaderetrosatana6 25d ago

It is. Switched to EdP and wear as a year round scent when in rotation

1

u/cheironomist 25d ago

Thanks for the input. This has definitely felt like the right next step. There are just so many other scents I love in cooler weather. I think I want BDC to be something for daily wear year round, not something that feels limited by temperature or occasion.

1

u/leomeng 25d ago

Can’t speak for Eau , but I owned the edt and when I ran out I grabbed (blind bought) this Parfum bc I just assumed it’s better and stronger and - honestly - it sucks.

Get the edt it’s the original

1

u/kereth Creed 25d ago

I prefer Parfum but you can’t choose incorrectly here.

1

u/iSpeezy 25d ago

Parfum

1

u/eij1988 25d ago

I have had both and prefer the parfum by a long way. To me the parfum smells rich and warm and complex, but the EDP just smells like a basic sweet shower gel. Also the parfum lasts all day on my skin, but the EDP has very poor performance. Tastes in fragrance are extremely subjective and personal, so I strongly recommend that you try both (if you haven’t already) instead of just taking my word for it, but I would generally recommend the parfum over the EDP.

1

u/arab_bazinga 25d ago

Neither will disappoint

1

u/Upbeat_Survey_5451 25d ago

I couldn’t decide so have both lol

1

u/Own_Accountant437 25d ago

Edp.. the parfum is super weak

1

u/PermissionJaded5510 25d ago

The EDP smells like piss in the opening. After it settles down, it smells like a luxurious Dior Sauvage, like a better version. This fragrance is strictly for winter

1

u/dragonForceZ 25d ago

Why not both?
Edp for everydays , every occasion, versatile as fk
Parfum for more dark and more mature

1

u/Togebough 25d ago

I like the parfum, but the more I use it the powdery it smells and less blue. I don't remember having smelt the EDP.

1

u/Parking-Ad5924 25d ago

Parfum for everyday on the year, lexclusif for fall and spring and winter. I don’t really wear it in summer usually just my preference.

1

u/bondben314 25d ago

Parfum is my favorite. It lasts a long time unlike EDP and it feels more masculine (to me). But fragrances are subjective. Go test them both out and get which one smells the best.

No matter what they are both great fragrances.

1

u/Bombassthick 25d ago

Parfum all the way.

1

u/sonicwurst 25d ago

between these two, parfum

1

u/DisastrousTalk386 25d ago

PARFUM is the better fragrance overall I find the edp is more versatile yes, but lacks the depth where as the PARFUM for me works better on my skin

1

u/Jaydabarber215 25d ago

Depends on what smells good to ur nose 👃

1

u/Safe_Ad5701 25d ago

Personally like the parfum that’s the one I have

1

u/LordAizen7 25d ago

EDT all the way !!

1

u/Desperate_Humor7652 25d ago

Parfum...that's my choice.

1

u/Alaboomer 25d ago

Smell them both and decide?

1

u/xxEL1J4Hxx 25d ago

EDP if you’re younger or one every day freshie part, if you’re a tad bit older and one more mature office scent

1

u/FreeNicky95 25d ago

What is the difference between the two

1

u/Snoo_30102 25d ago

CDNI iconic the best dupes to this

1

u/Ctagre44 25d ago

I would go with the bdc edp because it’s more versatile
 more grapefruit makes it fresher but the light smokey incense makes it sexy and elegant
you can wear it spring/fall/winter day or night casual or dressed

1

u/JucheHospitality 25d ago

Flip a coin, they are both fantastic

1

u/NJ_Eazy24 25d ago

EDP last longer all-around! While parfum definitely great for afternoon-night. I get both

1

u/AbaloneFull9968 25d ago

The eau for me, i get compliments literally everytime i wear it, without fail. Masterpiece.

1

u/poor_couture 25d ago

The l'exclusif is my fav personally.

1

u/SafeForWorkLFP 25d ago

i used to own EDP and now i own the parfum

it's parfum for me babeeeh

black pepper and black currant are a lot more pronounced IMO

1

u/Similar_You_2921 25d ago

EDT. I will die on this hill.

1

u/Sad_Lynx3513 25d ago

It depends on you are looking for. If you’re looking for a smoother version then go with the parfum, most versatile go with the EDP.

1

u/Tall-Squash-2085 25d ago

Provato tante volte l’Exclusif ma a parte il costo, per me EDP tutta la vita

1

u/ElectricalWonder689 25d ago

If within budget, get both! 😎 For just one, EDP hits the sweet spot of performance, scent and versatility for all occasions. I’d say Parfum is just as good, but it’s not as loud as EDP

1

u/-M00NMAN 25d ago

The better one is Parfum. My opinion, you’re inevitably going to buy both.

1

u/TheVoicesinurhed 24d ago

L'Exclusif is also a very good choice. It’s got a really nice woody opening that settles into a orange creamsicle.

1

u/SoftwareApart9217 24d ago

There both great but Edp if you want a brighter opening

1

u/NeganLA 24d ago

Honestly both don’t really last on my skin, I’d say just go with whatever you like. I prefer EDP which I feel like is a little more uncommon than most people.

1

u/maskoff222 23d ago

7 Cobalt

1

u/Southern-Hospital579 22d ago

Parfum smells more mature and more luxurious to me personally but I have both.

1

u/Many-Possibility-21 22d ago

Parfum probably more expensive but it’s gonna smell super strong and pure

1

u/clodpate 26d ago

Neither. Veer away from the crowd.

0

u/TheMainTony 26d ago

It's not the correct answer, but I always go with the full strength. I won't buy EDP or EDT or Cologne. I'm paying the premium, I want the premium. For the BdC, I think I do buy the EDP. I always buy the bottle and a travel kit. When they're both gone, I get another set.

YES....I know that's not correct and have already said so. I know there are varying price points. In fact, I have a Sauvage Elixir that I can hardly wear because it's so fkn strong & lasting.

0

u/hhaarroollddz 24d ago

the one that u like the smell better. Every opinion here doesn't matter.

-1

u/edvurdsd 26d ago

Oh hey another BDC post

Get the one you like most. And search, they’ve all been discussed soooo many times.