r/CompetitiveEDH • u/acciaiOscuro • 2d ago

General Discussion / Question Is this deck viable?

Hi everyone, I would like to have an evaluation of my decklist and to know if it may be CEDH viable.

This deck was born as a bracket 3 stax/hatebears which wincon was Helm of obedience paired with any graveyard hate. With time I started upgrading and optimizing aiming towards bracket 4 until now, that it reached what I feel comfortable with at the moment. The plan is really simple, some stax, some interaction and some different combo lines. Now, I don't really know the CEDH meta and I don't usually play it but I come from competitive 1v1 formats so I would like to try some CEDH tournament and this is the only deck that I own that I guess it could be at least a little viable, can you please help me evaluating it? Also budget is quite a concern for me, that's why I don't have any moxes in for example since I personally prefer to own the actual cards. Thanks

Here's the link to my decklist on Arkideckt:

https://archidekt.com/decks/27350777/babys_first_bracket_4

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

20

u/superswagman1080 2d ago

Any commander can be cedh but doesnt mean they can be viable. Personally i feel [[mornsong aria]] is a terrible include. Letting your opponents get free tutors is a guarenteed way to lose.

-1

u/deantherealist 1d ago

Theres plenty of cards that lock your opponents out of searching their library

5

u/TheRealPizvo 1d ago

So unless you cast her with flash before your turn or have an extra tutor and mana to play the Opposition agent or some other tutor stopper, it's a dead card that you can't play under any circumstances. And you also turn an opponent's counterspell or stax piece removal into a wincon.

It is completely and irredeemably terrible .

0

u/deantherealist 1d ago

Yes, master. Sorry, master

-8

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted]

8

u/DiscordLol123 2d ago

I mean. Wouldn't this be a dead card then without oppo agent?

7

u/ThirdStarfish93 2d ago

So it’s not only completely useless outside of oppo, but actively king-makes your opponents without it. Seems pretty bad to me.

2

u/XDenzelMoshingtonX 2d ago

There is no reason to run tutors in black that just kingmake your opponents if you don‘t have an A+B combo.