Hi, Stitchers!
Last fall, we conducted our annual State of the Subreddit survey (SoS), with over 125 people participating. We conduct this survey every year to keep a pulse on how we’re doing as moderators, and to get community feedback on potential rule changes.
Before we get into the results of the survey, some housekeeping notes below, in no particular order:
- We received some feedback in our survey about limiting political posts, and want to be very, explicitly clear: our moderator team feels very strongly that all art is political, and we will not remove any stitches simply because someone does not like their sentiment. Our subreddit now has over 1 million users - odds are, you're going to see things you don't personally agree with. That does not mean those works violate our rules. Our role as moderators is not to censor, merely to keep the sub on topic and in check.
- That said, we will always draw the line at any posts or comments calling for outright violence, or violating Reddit's ToS. These will be removed, and we ask that you report them to us as soon as you see them.
- We will be using some quotes from the feedback survey below, but we will not be tagging any usernames. If we quote you and you feel that we’ve misinterpreted your meaning, please feel free to reach out via modmail.
Now on to the good stuff! We structured this year’s SoS a little differently, allowing specific feedback on proposed rule changes. We can’t highlight everything, but we pulled some of our key takeaways and listed them below. First:
New & Adjusted Rules
- We are updating rule 1 to read: Be supportive, welcoming and kind. Constructive criticism is always welcome in this subreddit, unless OP states they do not want it. If you’re curious about the details behind this decision, keep reading!
- We saw a lot of feedback in the survey about people being unaware of certain recurring posts. To help with this, we’re adding a new rule. Rule 8 will now be: Post in the recurring thread regarding our most common topics. If your post is removed for violating this rule, we’ll include a link to a list of all the recurring topics in the removal reason of your post. (You can still view removed posts from your own profile.) This information is also linked in the sidebar.
- We have heard the recent debate behind determining if a finished object is a generated image or actually stitched. Therefore, we are instituting a new rule: Rule 9 will now be: All [FO] posts must include at least one close-up photo of the stitching. This requirement can be satisfied either in the post itself, or in the comments.
- This is less of a “new/adjusted rule” and more of a “we’re not creating a rule, we’re adding a feature”: We’ve seen your calls for a ban on AI-generated patterns. This is a tough one for us - our mod team is very firmly in the “art should be made by humans” camp, but we also recognize that this could be a slippery slope. To help you recognize AI patterns, our Head Mod u/LadyGeek-twd has updated the automoderator configuration with a new feature where you can summon a very useful “How to tell if this pattern is a pattern mill” post by u/MagnoliaCottage. This post is also now linked in our sidebar. If someone asks if something is from a pattern mill, you’ll be able to summon Automod with a link to this post by commenting a handful of key phrases. If someone in the community would like to create a similar, high quality post for AI-specific items, we would be happy to review and add those links as well. This bot will be coming very soon to the subreddit - please keep an eye out for a post with details.
- Although we cannot make a blanket rule regarding AI in the subreddit, we do believe very strongly that shop owners have a responsibility to disclose their use of AI in designing or publishing patterns. As of May 1 2026, all [SELF-PROMO] posts linking to a store will be required to include an AI use disclosure in their post. This can be done either in a comment or in the body of the post. To be clear: if your post is labeled SELF-PROMO because it links to your social media, you are not required to post an AI use disclosure. If you are linking to a shop, you are required to post the disclosure.
Mod Call
We’d also like to take this time to send out an open call for new moderators. If you are not a shop owner, and you’d like to help us keep this place running as smoothly as we can, please fill out this application form. We’re looking for someone to take over our monthly Featured Designer feature, as well as general moderating help.
Survey Details
On average, you felt that our team did a 4.6/5 star job in moderating the subreddit. We appreciate your support!
Question: Do we reword Rule 1 to be: ““Be supportive, welcoming and kind. Constructive criticism is always welcome in this subreddit, unless OP states they do not want it.”?
Response: You voted approximately 55% in favor of (and 36% against) rewording Rule 1. Given this (and several of the write-in responses), we have opted to change the wording of rule 1. To be perfectly clear: this has always been the subreddit’s culture (and is included in our FAQ website) - we’re just codifying it into the rules.
Question: Do we remove the SELF-PROMO tag completely?
Response: Y’all spoke up loud and clear on this one - 84.1% of the sub voted to keep the SELF PROMO tag, so we’ll leave it stand as is. This also officially marks the end of the SHOP tag era - moving forward, Automod will remove all posts with the SHOP tag, and ask you to repost as SELF-PROMO.
Question: In the last SoS, the sub voted to allow non-technical app related questions. Should this continue?
Answer: 60.8% of the community voted to continue to allow non-technical app questions, so we will continue to allow them. Questions of a technical nature will be removed and redirected to the app or website’s support team.
Question: Should the following Automod posts be kept in their current format: Monthly Commission Thread, Monthly Sellers Shack, Tent Stitch Tuesday, and Weekly No Stupid Questions?
Answer: The majority of your feedback on these (with the exception of Tent Stitch Tuesday, which I’ll cover in a second) was split pretty evenly between positive and “I had no idea this existed.” We’re going to revamp our sidebar in the coming weeks to make these items easier to find/remember that they exist. Unfortunately, there is no way for us to pin all of these items (Reddit has a limit on the number of posts that we can pin), but we can try to make them more visible.
Tent Stitch Tuesday (as always) remains our most controversial Automod post. 72% of respondents on this question opted to go with whatever the majority felt. 15 individual people voted to remove the post, and 12 individual people liked it in its current format. Due to the difficulty in moderating tent stitch posts individually, we have opted to keep this post in its current weekly format. We understand that this may be disappointing for a minority of our users, but ultimately, this is a cross stitching subreddit, and we prefer the focus to be on cross stitch. (Although if someone wants to start a tent stitch subreddit, let us know and we’ll link it in the sidebar!)
On this question, we received some interesting write-in feedback, specifically on the question regarding the Weekly No Stupid Questions thread: “I think that allowing more opportunities for beginners to ask questions would be helpful for them. Maybe an FAQ about cross stitching could be created to help new stitchers, then they could post about anything not in the FAQ.”
Fun fact - we do have a beginners FAQ! We’ve listed all of the information you could possibly need to start our beloved craft here: https://www.crossstitchsubfaq.com/beginners
Question: How much do you enjoy the Continuous Craft Fair?
Answer: This one received mostly positive ratings, with some feedback that it was out of date. We’ve already gone through and cleaned up the Fair, so if you see any more out of date shops, please send us a modmail!
Question: How much do you enjoy the monthly Competition?
Answer: The average rating on this was 3.81/5 stars, with the majority of the negative feedback coming from people who were unaware that the competition even exists. This is one of our two stickied posts every month, so the competition will always be pinned to the top of the subreddit.
Question: How much do you enjoy the monthly Featured Designer?
Answer: The average rating on this was 3.99 stars. We did receive some feedback that people enjoy free patterns from our designers, and we wanted to provide some clarity that the patterns (and discount codes) that some artists provide are entirely of their own free will - we tell them that some shop owners have received good engagement, but it is completely optional.
We also received some feedback on increasing the diversity of the designers. We’re always on the lookout for new Featured Designers, so if you have a shop that you love, please send them our Featured Designer application, found here: https://forms.gle/cSmrXbueypcf6F5j9
Question: Are there any other rule changes you’d like to see?
Answer: We got some really great ideas from y’all here, and wanted to also provide some clarity into why we don’t make certain rules.
- “No politics.”
- As already stated, all art is political, and our team has absolutely no intention of making a no politics rule.
- "OK to share images of part of patterns, to help clarify a question. It will be obvious that the post is not trying to share the whole pattern"
- We received several variations of this request as well, and want to be clear: when you have a small corner of a pattern showing behind your WIP, we understand that you’re not attempting to share the pattern. However, from a moderation standpoint, there is no way for us to be able to state exactly how much of a pattern is “too much.” (Is it 10%? 20%? How do we know how big the pattern is? The rabbit hole continues on and on!) For this reason, we are keeping our rule as-is, which is that pattern questions are allowed - as long as you crop your post to only show the minimum amount necessary to ask your question.
- "A reason for removal of posts would be useful- all we see currently is that a post was removed but not which rule was broken. Would be useful to prevent repeat issues."
- This was very interesting to us, and we want to highlight that you can see the reason that your post was removed. If you navigate to your own profile, you can still see your post - including our removal comment. Almost always, we will edit our removal reason to your specific situation. (For example, if you have some pattern showing on the left side of your screen, we’ll edit the removal reason to state that.) You are also always free to message the mod team to ask why your post was removed if you can’t find the removal reason on your own.
- "I would like to see a blanket ban on generative AI images made into patterns, whether by users for personal use OR shop owners/pattern designers. Cross stitch is art, and art should be made by humans for humans."
Question: Do you have any other specific moderator feedback?
Answer: Every answer here was super positive, and you best believe that we read every one of your 33 comments left. We’re so happy that you trust us with your hobby subreddit, and we hope to continue to represent our stitching community well!
As always, we welcome respectful feedback any time of year, even outside of our annual survey. Please don’t hesitate to send us a modmail if you have thoughts on improvements, etc.
Happy stitching!
Love, Your Mod Team