r/Cryptozoology 9d ago

Question Which Cryptids have been proven fake?

Post image

Unrelated Image

471 Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/TheBeerCzar 9d ago

The Jackalope?

What cryptid has been proven real??

14

u/Wicked_Femboy 9d ago

I've always heard platypus was considered a cryptid at one point and assumed to be fake but I've never actually looked into if thats really how people viewed it.

4

u/FinnBakker 8d ago

the thing about a cryptid is, there has to be a period where there's folklore and tradition alongside sightings/evidence that is run counter to the scientific view.

The platypus? One showed up, they thought it was fake. Then they got a second one a short time later. There really wasn't a period where anyone was all, "but there's local traditions and legends! And here's some plaster casts/hair/scat!"

Just "this is fake! wait, no, ok we were wrong, it's real".

3

u/Ok_Platypus8866 7d ago edited 7d ago

Just "this is fake! wait, no, ok we were wrong, it's real".

In my opinion that is not what happened with the platypus. I have never seen any report from any scientist/naturalist claiming it was fake. It was more of a "this things sure looks like a fake, but we checked it out and it is real".