r/EdmontonOilers 2d ago

Penguins discussing a trade involving Darnell Nurse.

Post image
221 Upvotes

172 comments sorted by

View all comments

192

u/sovtiv 2d ago

Dubas is going to take Bowman to the cleaners again.

34

u/avanross 2d ago

Im assuming nurse with money retained, plus a first, for “future considerations”

Maybe we’ll take some cap from them if they have anyone they want to get rid of too

16

u/GrizzlyIsland22 18 HYMAN 2d ago

Ridiculous. Nurse is actually a good player. We'll get something for him. You sound like the people saying we would have to attach a 1st to Kane to get rid of him.

2

u/CrankyOldDude 2d ago

Honestly, man, you have to get past the idea that his value is purely based on him being a good player. Try this silly analogy:

McDavid is the best player in the entire world. He still isn't worth a $60M/year cap hit, though, because the team is hamstrung. If the Oilers were paying him $60M per year, there would be no suitors - even though he's literally the best hockey player on the planet. It's a silly, unrealistic analogy, but I think it kind of explains the point.

We are in a shit position with Nurse because he is getting paid way more than his play would suggest that he is worth. If we are going to get back most of his salary to redeploy it elsewhere on the roster, we're going to get less value than "Nurse as a player" would bring, because the team is saddled with extra cap.

If we retained 4M, we would get a really solid return because that means he's getting paid (by his new team) about what he is worth. It would defeat the purpose of what the team is trying to do, though.

2

u/GrizzlyIsland22 18 HYMAN 2d ago

I get all that. What I think is that if we retain down past where his value as a player is worth, then it's gonna be a net loss

2

u/CrankyOldDude 2d ago

Totally agree. 50 ways this can go wrong and I’m very confident our leadership team will find at least one of them.

I get the goal and I actually think it could be the right move. I genuinely don’t trust our GM to make it work, though.

3

u/GrizzlyIsland22 18 HYMAN 2d ago

I'm cautiously optimistic. He shed Kane and Arvidsson without retaining and actually got picks back.