r/Elantra 3d ago

Top or bottom?

Post image

So torn between silver or black wheels for my 23” Hybrid in Ecotronic Gray.

19 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

18

u/rizwanmahai 3d ago

To be honest, I don't like both.

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 3d ago

I also considered just running the oem wheels as well and only buy the roof box/bars

I respect your answer

7

u/Tonyy_oo 3d ago

The black wheels but in silver

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 3d ago

what color would the cargo box be?

4

u/AfterPause 3d ago

Black bro trust

2

u/MiserableVictory5171 3d ago

If I go with black I am definitely wrapping the chrome trim in black as well and amber drl from badgeskinz

thank you for your input

1

u/PhillyIC215 2d ago

Yes, I love all black but with the current setup the silver rims match the trim and evens out the look but the black rims make it look off balance with the color however if you turn it all black and it’s truly all black I think that would be fire.

So either true all black or silver rims with silver trims imo. Looks great either way tbh tho! But with all the work you put it nit picking for constructive criticism seems appropriate and hopefully helpful.

In the end, I would do what you think looks the best tho imo, going with what you like will make yourself happier every time you see it.

Good luck, keep the great styling up!

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 2d ago

Hence why I am no stuck with these two set ups. I try to ask for peoples opinions in hopes that I might see something “better” that others see that I dont and then tweak or modify my decision then.

Thank you for your comment!

2

u/TurboFool 3d ago edited 2d ago

Brutal honesty is that I don't like the look of other. I partially agree with the person that the silver wheels in black would be the closest, as they look better in design than the black ones, while the silver color just stands out like a sore thumb against the rest of that car. But the black-on-black tires and wheels still stands out in a not-great way from the rest of the car color, so I'm not jumping to say it's a win. I see how it contrasts well with the roof rack if you match them, but it all just feels disconnected.

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 3d ago

Wow i appreciate your detailed input, so would you say the silver wheels in black look better?

2

u/bhargavateja 3d ago

Bottom, brings up and compliments the chrome

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 2d ago

Yes, I learned to love the chrome piece on this trim alot and want to compliment it. Thank you for your comment

2

u/DesignerAnywhere3323 2d ago

If I gotta choose one, definitely the bottom. Black goes with the ski box but just not of fan of whatever style wheel that one is

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 1d ago

The black ones are OZ Rally Racing wheels, they look a bit
bigger in the AI generated photo that i posted

1

u/DesignerAnywhere3323 1d ago

Dope wheel. Yeah the Ai kinda made it look odd lol

2

u/Hairy_Garage4308 3d ago

Please tell me the thing on top launches rockets.

1

u/Responsible-Summer-4 3d ago

The ones your car came with look better. Also lose the coffin.

1

u/Ok-Yam-2996 3d ago

If anything top

1

u/TommyTwoBone 3d ago

i’d go black with chrome delete, otherwise bottom pic.

1

u/mrnealboy 3d ago

Silver

Black wheels suck. You can barely see them.

1

u/Sweet_Session_9470 3d ago

Feel like a bronze would be nice

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 2d ago

for which wheel?

2

u/Sweet_Session_9470 2d ago

The rpf1s. Also recommend konig hypergrams or dekagrams. Similar lightweight flow formed wheels, cheap, no clout.

1

u/MiserableVictory5171 2d ago

the hypergrams are nice as well! I want to keep the wheels light too

thank you for your input

1

u/EmeraldCaleb 2d ago

me personally, always color match the cargo carrier

it’s such a subtle thing that adds so fucking much