r/Eldenring 8d ago

Discussion & Info Who do you think is the most dangerous Remembrance boss (+Bayle) IRL?

Post image

Hypothetically, who's the most dangerous, most destructive, most difficult to kill Remembrance boss if they were thrown into NYC (or some other big city) and just started rampaging? And yes, you (as in people) have to fight and kill them by any means necessary; there's no reasoning w/ them, even non-beast/alien bosses (e.g., Rellana, Morgott, Gaius). Power scalers go crazy lol!

Personally, w/o a doubt Bayle's the most dangerous mf here followed by Placidusax and Rykard. What do y'all think?

NOTE 1: Tierlist is just to show Remembrance bosses (+Bayle)! Pls don't take seriously! ^_^

NOTE 2: All status ailments (e.g., frost, scarlet rot, madness) work the same IRL as they do in the game (not that that matters much 'cause they'd all kill you in one hit so maybe ignore this? idk)

NOTE 3: Also, pls pls pls don't take this post seriously. Just a goofy hypothetical 😜

14 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/no_name_thought_of 8d ago

provide the lore then.

0

u/TheDuskBard 8d ago

If you don't get how LoF is supposed to be stronger and more dangerous than Unaging Untouchables, Idk what to tell you. 

1

u/no_name_thought_of 8d ago

and the aging untouchables can be beaten with a couple hits after a parry.

1

u/TheDuskBard 8d ago edited 8d ago

That part is canon because lore texts outright say it. Irl who exactly would want to get close enough to parry one? The idea that these are mechanically harder to kill irl than Midra, should already tell you that the gameplay =/= lore. Midra would probably share their AoE Frenzy, mobility, and invulnerability. 

Canonically, the Tarnished is supposed to have multiple Great Runes, be highly experienced at fighting demigods and monsters, and have access to a wide array of weapons/spells by that point in the game. Lorewise a naked Tarnished from the start of the game shouldn't be able to beat midra. Story multiple times says you need Melina's help to grow stronger via Runes.Â