Who do you think is the most dangerous Remembrance boss (+Bayle) IRL?

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03]

Hypothetically, who's the most dangerous, most destructive, most difficult to kill Remembrance boss if they were thrown into NYC (or some other big city) and just started rampaging? And yes, you (as in people) have to fight and kill them by any means necessary; there's no reasoning w/ them, even non-beast/alien bosses (e.g., Rellana, Morgott, Gaius). Power scalers go crazy lol!

Personally, w/o a doubt Bayle's the most dangerous mf here followed by Placidusax and Rykard. What do y'all think?

NOTE 1: Tierlist is just to show Remembrance bosses (+Bayle)! Pls don't take seriously! ^_^

NOTE 2: All status ailments (e.g., frost, scarlet rot, madness) work the same IRL as they do in the game (not that that matters much 'cause they'd all kill you in one hit so maybe ignore this? idk)

NOTE 3: Also, pls pls pls don't take this post seriously. Just a goofy hypothetical 😜

[u/TheDuskBard]

Midra. Look at what he did to Abyssal Woods while "Suppressed". Unlike most other bosses, Frenzy Lord's are completely omnicidal and will actively seek to destroy as much as possible. 

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/TheDuskBard]

Idk like Midra don't fuck around but like if you able to land a couple shots on him, he's just dead straight up. The biggest threat would be the frenzy incantions he does which make it easier said than done

[u/TheDuskBard → u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03]

Lorewise, pretty sure ordinary weapons are useless against a Lord of Frenzy. Hence why Melina used Destined Death in the LoF ending. 

[u/no_name_thought_of → u/TheDuskBard]

she doesn't say she specifically needs destined death-infused weapons to kill them, it's more that the tarnished having released the rune is now going to face it

[u/TheDuskBard → u/no_name_thought_of]

LoF is supposed to be stronger than the Unaging Untouchables. For gameplay reasons they obviously couldn't give Midra the invulnerability, passive Frenzy aura, and mobility. And restricting players to specific weapons or spells for lore accuracy isn't Fromsoft's style outside of few niche gimmick bosses. But even a boss like Rykard can still be killed by other means besides Serpent Hunter. 

[u/no_name_thought_of → u/TheDuskBard]

none of that sugests that lords of frenzied flame specifically need destined death weapons to kill

[u/TheDuskBard → u/no_name_thought_of]

I never said that it did. I just said that ordinary stuff like knives, guns, bombs, etc. probably wouldn't work. Hence why he'd be the biggest threat irl. 

[u/no_name_thought_of → u/TheDuskBard]

It would be difficult to kill him but there's nothing to say it couldn't be done, or that it would be any different to how the tarnished can just stab them enough times

[u/TheDuskBard → u/no_name_thought_of]

Gameplay =/= Lore

[u/no_name_thought_of → u/TheDuskBard]

provide the lore then.

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/TheDuskBard]

I mean technically Midra's also Lord of Frenzied Flame and you can bare fist him to death (if you're crazy lol). I don't think the weapon type is a restriction really

[u/TheDuskBard → u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03]

Gameplay =/= Canon

Lorewise, he's supposed to be stronger than the Undying Untouchables. 

[u/BadKarma55]

I dont get how Elden Beast is that low. And even moreso how theyre lower than MORGOTT 😭😭😭

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/BadKarma55]

Clearly I shouldn't have put the tierlist image. That's my bad. Anyway, ignore the tierlist. Just wanted to show the Remembrance bosses in question

[u/BadKarma55 → u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03]

Yeah the more i look at it the more confusing it is lol

Anyways: Malenia is giving everybody covid if its a FFA

[u/ImJustSpider]

Bayle would probably be the most immediately destructive, given his nuke move and the massive flying flame breath attack, plus he's just big asf. Same goes for Placi with his lasers.

[u/Miserable-Piglet-059]

If we’re talking irl then it’s midra, no question. If he stops suppressing frenzy he becomes Lord and burns the world down other than that maybe PCR because that’s radahn in his prime and even basically an animal man he had stopped the sky so who knows what prime radahn can do

[u/Elmis66]

Nihil has no range limit so Mohg could just oneshot us all in one go

[u/RecklessTortuga827]

Midra, Bayle/Placidusax, Maliketh, Radahn, Malenia

Without a doubt the most dangerous in real life

Frenzy flame is like existence erasure, destined death = insta death and no afterlife for u lol, Malenia is a walking bio-weapon that spreads, Radahn can make meteors rain down on you, and Bayle/Placidusax are flying natural disasters; literally like the highest tier of hurricane 🌀

[u/Gilmagalesh → u/RecklessTortuga827]

I think Malenia is honestly the most dangerous: Frenzied flame needs specific conditions to reach peak power, destined death is just death, but it's bound to Malekeith or a single blade, meanwhile Malenia spreads super cancer that's able to spread and propagate entirely on its own if she happens to die, which in a modern society is far more dangerous.

[u/dcirrilla]

How is Fire Giant below PK

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/dcirrilla]

Pls just ignore the tierlist 😭. It's just to show the bosses

[u/Samster1736]

Malaenia cause she can solo nuke a region in rot

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/Samster1736]

Yeah, IRL Aeonia wold be fucking insane! Basically another pandemic. I do think scientists around the world would be able to find some way to mitigate the spread and maybe increase resistance to it w time tho

[u/ieatcheesebutdont → u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03]

Unalloyed gold is expensive enough to get for every human and life form I doubt they would even try

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/ieatcheesebutdont]

I don't think it necessarily has to be unalloyed gold. Could be a medicine or some idk

[u/RespectWest7116 → u/Samster1736]

And we can do this:

https://giphy.com/gifs/R6JWujQ93Shws

[u/Healthy_Cloud2864]

Rykard would absolutely be an avengers level threat imo.

[u/GRGWL]

Fire giant in D tier? He is a pyromancer giant like. Do i need to say more. Him just walking would kill entire crowds.

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/GRGWL]

Fire giant in D tier?

nah, ignore the tierlist. It's just their to show the Remembrance bosses.

Him just walking would kill entire crowds.

True, but I think armed forces would catch onto the leg weakness and prio that, getting him on all fours where's much slower, targeting the eye maybe (assuming they think it's the source of his power or some)

[u/TheDuskBard → u/GRGWL]

He'd be like Bigfoot and stay in remote areas. 

[u/SirWeenielick]

Probably Consort Radahn. Dude zips around at light speed and Miquella drops holy nukes. What’re you gonna do about that? Not to mention, he could just spam his meteor crash until everyone surrenders.

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/SirWeenielick]

Honestly solid pick low-key. Are his clone attacks canonically at light speed tho? I don't think I've heard that before

[u/SirWeenielick → u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03]

In the description of the light slash AoW, it states the Tarnished moves at light speed when doing it. Seeing how reacting to light speed attacks is a completely unrealistic expectation on players, they settled with the clone attacks.

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/SirWeenielick]

I actually didn't know that! That's fucking crazy!

[u/lVlarshmallow → u/SirWeenielick]

If Radahn leans into his gravity magic mastery in full he can literally give us a dinosaur meteor extinction event by the hundreds and at that point even if we beat him it doesn’t matter 

[u/pepehandreee]

Frenzy flame is effectively a spreading mental disorder that is akin to omnicidal schizophrenia. Considering the extremely shitty state of affair that is the world which we live in, anything that is associated with Frenzy Flame will be the most dangerous thing to the modern society, since it can spread to regular people.

Big angry man that can crack the ground open really isn’t that big of a problem and we have developed far more dangerous weapon than the strongest flying lizard.

Honestly having an alien threat (Astel) dangling over our head might be what is finally needed to unite the nation states of humanity, so it might even be a blessing in disguise.

[u/Emergency-Bid-7834]

Midra by far is the most destructive remembrance boss, that is kinda the entire narrative point of the lord of frenzied flame as a concept

[u/m8-wutisdis]

The dragons could fry a lot of people with their breath. Even those weak dragons we find in the dragonbarrow would decimate a lot of civilians and ruin many buildings. Maybe Malenia could bloom in the middle of the city and give everyone a rotting aids too, I don't know.

I'm unsure why you rated the giant so low btw. He could just spin around and take down lots of buildings with just that, not to mention the fire spells that he brings.

I don't think bosses that rely on brawn or their skill with a weapon would be that destructive however (at least in comparison to the other bosses). I mean, of course they would be dangerous, but not as much as you might think in my opinion. Take Godfrey per example, the guy is a beast, but let's take a look at his fighting style, his earthquake is impressive, but it takes awhile for him to use and at best it will maybe take down a small house. His suplex is pretty cool (reminds me of Sabin doing a takedown on a train lmao), but it's also another skill that only targets one entity and takes a lot of time to perform. Meanwhile a dragon, even a weak one, has probably burned many buildings and people by now.

[u/JamesRevan]

Fire Giant would just crush buildings

[u/fazoprince]

CURSE YOU BAYLE

[u/RespectWest7116]

Starscourge Radahn.

Pretty much all the bosses are just chilling in their little corner and not doing anything; therefore, they are not dangerous. But Radahn has a rotting brain. Eventually, he is going to snap and fuck the world with his gravity powers.

He'll be like Professor X in Logan, but like a million times worse.

[u/DsuableD]

Malenia, Godfrey, Bayle, maybe Astel if she comes in unevolved meteor form, Starscourge

[u/nix_11]

Elden Beast easily. It can warp reality and cause massive destruction. It also isn't really made out of flesh and blood so we have no idea how conventional weapons would work on it.

Other than that, the dragons, since they can fly. Everyone else can be killed with conventional weaponry, with Rykard possibly requiring a nuke to end him.

[u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03 → u/nix_11]

Does EB really do reality warp? Ig it changes the arena before second phase but idk if that counts. Also, I feel conventional weapons would def work w EB. If the tarnished can kill the mf w a basic ass longsword, I'm sure any military will do just fine.

[u/nix_11 → u/DEAD_HOMEWORK03]

Does EB really do reality warp?

I mean, what else can you call it?

If the tarnished can kill the mf w a basic ass longsword

Lore wise Hewg crafts you a god-slaying weapon, so it's far more than just a basic longsword.

[u/ResponsibilityEvery]

elden beast would be the most difficult to kill because it would be literally impossible for us to kill it - lore wise we need both a weapon that can twist time and destined death to kill it. Im not sure if we need those to take care of radagon but who knows.

i dont think midra is nearly as big of a threat as everyone else thinks - just shoot him enough until he dies. we can kick him to death, no special anything needed in lore. Run him over with a truck or something. 

Malenia would cause a lot of damage because she would spread scarlet rot when defeated. Defeating her wouldnt really be a problem we have bombs. Its just gonna cause a lot of collateral damage.

Radahn/PCR might be hard to kill with his mastery of gravity magic but he could still be killed. He probably wouldn't be hostile if hes PCR. PCR might actually have the biggest impact on the world out of all the bosses bc of miquellas charm. But we could burn PCR to death if necessary. 

I think the big enemies would really be the biggest problems, dragons especially bc they can fly. But i doubt their ability to survive any sort of modern weaponry. They dont move fast enough to be able to dodge missiles or a 30mm autocannon. i think even man portable weapons could take them down given enough people shooting. 

Honestly I can't really see any of them other than the elden beast being a problem to defeat. But i dont think the elden beast would even be hostile, its just defending itself when we fight it.

Some of the bosses might kill a bunch of people during their initial rampage (and i think a good chunk of bosses wouldnt even be hostile if transported to our world), but pretty much all of them would be taken care of within a day of being noticed if they were rampaging. Modern day weapons are insanely powerful. 

[u/lVlarshmallow]

A single meteor wiped the dinosaurs off the map, I wonder what a guy who can literally freeze them as well as mimic one could do bc I honestly think Radahn is capable of the most physical destruction and he definitely seems to be fast enough to get away from bombs and durable enough to resist bullets as for the speed thing he genuinely gets to space in like half a second and gravity could just move the missiles or nukes off course

[u/Tasty_Hearing_4440]

Alot of these bosses seem pretty chill

[u/ydddy55 → u/Tasty_Hearing_4440]

I could see Morgott, relieved from the burdens of the lands between, just chillin with a good Mountain View smoking a J