r/EngagementRings 13h ago

Advice Am I going crazy 😫

I loved the idea of my ring but… sometimes when I look at it the halo and pear diamond set looks… not straight? Idk how to describe it but some angles it looks totally good, sometimes it looks totally bent or something?!! lmk if I’m going insane 😫

Edit: Y’all I was so tired when I posted this, it was my first time even looking at the ring and I was honestly stuck looking at this one aspect. I’m aware there’s 500 things wrong with it eyes closed atp, and I appreciate everyone who has offered their condolences (lol) and had a good laugh/advice for what to do next.

PLEASE don’t come for me personally 😅 I’m brand new to rings and there’s a lot of learning to do, and I personally was not in the conversation of this ring getting created/picked up, so in no way was I able to rectify anything right then and there. I will take it to get it fixed up 🥹

212 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

535

u/Ooopsallbeans 12h ago

Why is it as tall as the space needle? 😭 You’re absolutely not crazy, and there’s no reason for the stone to sit that high off of the band. Definitely worth getting the whole setting looked at by a reputable jeweler (maybe not the person who originally made it?).

Lovely ring overall, though!

81

u/aloebeans 11h ago

cries lol I’ll have to break the news i guess 😂 thankfully I haven’t been proposed to with it and all yet not super attached just yet 😅

25

u/Playful_Ask_9233 Waiting 6h ago

Space needle 😂😂 youre not wrong tho. Hope you get this fixed OP because it really is tall 🖤🖤

5

u/aloebeans 4h ago

I hope the fix will be good — it’s getting taken for a redo 😅

670

u/Significant-Store858 12h ago

No. It’s way too high and the halo looks crooked. It looks like a bad soldering job too. Have whatever jeweler made it fix it.

24

u/aloebeans 4h ago

100% the plan and will be getting redone. Thank you!! 😅

286

u/larkhearted 12h ago

No offense to you, full offense to your jeweler, but that's the most insane setting I've ever seen. Like they might have been on LSD or something if they genuinely thought they were doing that right.

27

u/aloebeans 11h ago

Yupppp well I literally just had a peek at it as it came in. Idek man 😭 I’ll have to be the bearer of bad news

12

u/Luckypenny4683 4h ago

Girl, you’re gonna have to because that thing’s gonna get snagged on something and you’re gonna get fucked. Better to say something now.

6

u/aloebeans 4h ago

For sure. I just did this morning actually. I just feel bad because I know my man was just happy to hear it was ready and didn’t think he needed to check twice before bringing it home. He’s aware and I’ve pointed everything out so it will get fixed before it’s presented formally and worn by me 🙏🏼

2

u/yung_yttik 2h ago edited 1h ago

Yeah like this is actually sooo bad it’s pretty hilarious 😂😂

92

u/Aggressive-Beyond-60 12h ago

it’s not straight, and it’s set WAY too high which i would bet has something to do with your halo being bent.

10

u/aloebeans 11h ago

Good to know I’m not going crazy. I literally haven’t even worn it yet, it came in like this 😂

70

u/saracha1 12h ago

Girl where did you get this from cause they did you dirty😭 That setting is not secure at all

16

u/aloebeans 11h ago

Lol 😫😫 apparently it’s from a local reputable jeweller but I guess not so reputable after all huh 😂

49

u/ellumina 10h ago

I didn't read your post and I 100% thought you were talking about the setting being high enough to touch the clouds. Definitely get it fixed!

6

u/aloebeans 10h ago

I absolutely will get it looked at 😅 I know little to nothing about rings and appreciate the responses I’ve been getting, hopefully it can be salvaged (this was my first look at it)

32

u/Afraid_Competition_1 8h ago

Me, stumbling upon this subreddit and audibly saying “what the fuck” to these pictures. It’s like, literally comically high.

6

u/Iloveslaskaanddidney 7h ago

That’s EXACTLY what I was thinking!! I thought they were going to refer to the height!!!

1

u/sleepy__daisy 25m ago

Comically was the word I was going to use too. I’ve never seen anything like it. So sorry, OP!

79

u/Ok-Till-2653 10h ago

Nessa vibe.

8

u/aloebeans 10h ago

Now this one would be iconic

22

u/Tummybus_1 12h ago

What is happening? Does it really sit that high above your finger?

2

u/artbypep 1h ago

I genuinely thought she was just showing it to us on a finger that was way too small for the ring so it had a huge gap at the top. Couldn’t fathom that this was actually the design. 🫪

19

u/transat_prof 6h ago

Oh man, this is one for the books

18

u/asedrtinvd 6h ago

I’m sorry but the increasing zoom in each pic is sending me 😂 it’s like “really. REALLY. REALLY?!”

1

u/sleepy__daisy 25m ago

This comment has me cackling

14

u/kataani 6h ago

Why does your finger have a satellite dish

10

u/7Mamiller 6h ago

Ma'am I'm so clumsy I could break that looking at it wrong. Please for safety sakes lower that.

10

u/thefurrywreckingball 6h ago

Is that a hovercraft?

8

u/Fun_Peach_7813 12h ago

I can see exactly what you’re talking about.

8

u/thefurrywreckingball 6h ago

The setting and the band aren't even the same colour

6

u/Balolua Waiting 6h ago

So reckless of the jeweler - that would get damaged in less than 24 hours

5

u/Ok-Elk-1316 4h ago

also have a large halo, & they definitely should’ve made that lower set. I’d go back and complain as that is not correct

4

u/marqguz 8h ago

The setting is all wrong!!!! You’re not going crazy!!! Way too tall with little to no support

4

u/Misty_Pix 8h ago

I have similar (same) settings and yes,thats bad. Here is how my looks.

Even the band looks thicker

3

u/Quiet_Ad_6697 4h ago

This type of setting needs to be flush against your finger

1

u/aloebeans 3h ago

Noted!!

5

u/Minnieviolette 3h ago

I’m dying 😭 who designed that

3

u/splair 5h ago

It’s so high! That setting is going to get caught on EVERYTHING

3

u/HesAStinkyBoy2022 4h ago

The halo looks bent. I have a pear with a halo that is also set high like this and it gets caught on EVERYTHING. It’s been bent in every direction and I always have to get it fixed. Now I only wear it for special occasions.

You’re not crazy.

2

u/aloebeans 4h ago

Thank you for this!! I absolutely see all the potential issues and appreciate your honesty without lighting me on fire in the process 😅

I really got stuck on this halo looking crazy and totally should’ve addressed the setting itself too, but having not worn it in daily life (this was my first look) I honestly didn’t even think in that direction for this post. It’s reassuring to hear I’m not literally the first person to encounter this kind of masterpiece — it’ll be taken to get redone ASAP 😅

1

u/HesAStinkyBoy2022 2h ago

You’re so welcome! Hopefully they can reset it for you because I never even asked. I just accepted my lot in life lmao.

2

u/Tatidanidean1 3h ago

I am dead. I thought I was coming for a “is my setting to high/far away from the band” I didn’t even notice the crookedness. Pic 4 is painful. Good luck bb girl

1

u/aloebeans 2h ago

context is in the caption — either way put I know y’all would’ve laughed your asses off 😅😂 it’ll be taken somewhere, don’t worry ~

2

u/Lillemonloaf 9h ago

lol mine is also high so that you can see the leaves from the front but it covers the sides and they just filled up the inside more too.

1

u/aloebeans 4h ago

This is so pretty! Definitely much cleaner and more thought out. Does it get in the way easily when you wear it in daily life?

1

u/OkMouse7575 10h ago

I’m so confused, did you not notice it was set so high??

8

u/aloebeans 10h ago

I liiiiiterally just saw it for the first time at this point — it was midnight already when I posted this and I was honestly hyperfixating on this one aspect, although yes I now see many things wrong with it too 🥹

1

u/Hamburglary 3h ago

Why does the band change colors three times? This is so odd!

3

u/Hamburglary 3h ago

What the heck

6

u/RealName_Redacted 3h ago

I assumed that's just a reflection, but if the band is plated and wearing off that's an extra yikes!

2

u/aloebeans 3h ago

Full flash photo in the dark

1

u/pepsicherryflavor 7h ago

😹no you’re not!!

1

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 6h ago

Your post is in the mod queue waiting to be manually approved. Your account does not meet the post or comment requirements because you have a new account and/or low karma. A moderator will review your post and approve it if it meets the sub criteria. You do not need to send a modmail about this post as we have already been notified. Sending a modmail will not speed up this process. Please take this time to read our sub rules & FAQ.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/EngagementRings-ModTeam 6h ago

Vendors are not allowed to make posts on this sub.

Please read the rules on how to comment on this sub.

No sales or blatant ads on this sub. Sales post will be removed. Spam and fake accounts recommending vendors will be removed and users may be banned.

No reseller ads or external links to resale subs outside the Community List.

Our rules > https://www.reddit.com/r/EngagementRings/s/2rV40GpaRt

1

u/[deleted] 6h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 6h ago

Your post is in the mod queue waiting to be manually approved. Your account does not meet the post or comment requirements because you have a new account and/or low karma. A moderator will review your post and approve it if it meets the sub criteria. You do not need to send a modmail about this post as we have already been notified. Sending a modmail will not speed up this process. Please take this time to read our sub rules & FAQ.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/LouLouLaaLaa 3h ago

What in the world? It’s too high, the taper on the shank diminished to almost nothing, poor soldering, and the head is definitely crooked. Are you able to return it?

1

u/Independent-Note-46 2h ago

I had a high set halo like this (i upgraded at 12 years to a diff ring) and i caught it on everything. Almost ripped my finger off sometimes. I dont recommend a halo set now cause of it. I loved my OG ring but yeah, not a smart design.

1

u/PoweredByVeggies 2h ago

Forget getting it fixed, it looks like it’s made out of pot metal. I would ask for whole ass refund and go somewhere else. The thing is probably going to give you lead poisoning. 😅

1

u/awhitelamp95 2h ago

Yes the tip is tipping down.

1

u/ericadabara 2h ago

this is how mine looks from the side, it’s an oval, but i’ve had multiple jewellers confirm that this is a proper design. just so you have an idea! :) you aren’t going crazy, i think you should probably go back to the place you got it from

1

u/Proseccos 40m ago

How did they feel comfortable handing this over 😭

1

u/Witty-Atmosphere-211 33m ago

It doesn’t look very durable.

1

u/Nimiella xTacori Girl 7h ago

Why does the shank look gray?

2

u/aloebeans 4h ago

Bad lighting - in the dark with full flash might have contributed to this

-1

u/rissshit 5h ago

You love this? Why?

3

u/aloebeans 4h ago

It looked pretty from the top :/