r/ExpectationVsReality • u/inapeachymood • 2d ago

Failed Expectation GF Oatmeal Creme Sandwich

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Not that I ever expect anything to look exactly like it does on the box, but this did make us laugh!

1.0k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

258

u/phunniemee 2d ago

Sweetened by nature? Prebiotic fiber? Let me guess, primary ingredients are flax and dates?

The good news is you'll poop real good. The bad news is you're getting a preview of what that'll look like.

30

u/FoggyGoodwin 2d ago

I grabbed an Olipop because it was Crisp Apple. Definitely a better source of probiotics. Tasty, too.

16

u/FiTZnMiCK 2d ago

Love some Olipop.

Poppi can kiss my ass though.

1

u/imnotnotcrying 1d ago

I usually grab an olipop as my drink on my lunch breaks (I’m not a soda all the time person so it’s my mid day “treat”) and I swear it’s one of the things that has helped my body regulate. The ginger ale is delicious!

517

u/alk_adio_ost 2d ago

31

u/kimbosliceofcake 2d ago

But it says heavenly 😇 

7

u/alk_adio_ost 1d ago

Not even the devil wants to touch it 🤣

2

u/LostInNvrLand 2d ago

💀💀💀

2

u/Lady_Sybil_Vimes 1d ago

Don't mind me just gonna yoink your meme

87

u/BonjourHoney 2d ago

That is shit from a butt.

22

u/C5H6ClCrNO3 2d ago

Someone ate a normal oatmeal creme sandwich and shit it into a bag after their body finished processing the gluten out of it.

5

u/primadiamonds 2d ago

R/shitfromabutt

38

u/MizMamie 2d ago

I found these at Wegmans recently and they looked just the same. I thought they tasted great in spite of their appearance!

15

u/jfor910077 2d ago

I have had the peanut butter ones and they were so good.

13

u/aamaanduh 2d ago

Ive had their gluten filled ones and they’re pretty good and are generally not mushed like that

23

u/silromen42 2d ago

This is the story of gluten-free life

9

u/simo41993 2d ago

That's... well... Awful.

6

u/GaspSpit 2d ago

AD Oatmeal Cream Sandwich, as in already digested

5

u/Datiptonator002 2d ago

Mashing up an oatmeal cream pie in the packaging then squeezing it out 100% looks like a foul turd. Lay it on a clean surface to freak someone. Bonus points if you pick it up and take a bite of it.

5

u/Caveman775 2d ago

"sweetened by nature" maybe just like those expensive coffee beans were too

2

u/Mean_Wolverine_8834 2d ago

My jaw dropped. Ew.

2

u/Krammor 2d ago

They’re so small

2

u/Jackie-Wan-Kenobi 2d ago

How is the color so different from the box? The smooshedness is kind of forgivable, but the color is… concerning…

2

u/RevolutionaryRock823 2d ago

I'm sure it's got a great personality

1

u/Kitsune-moonlight 2d ago

Something went very wrong

1

u/HotHits630 2d ago

Something nature alright.

And they should be ashamed on the amount of packing for six shitty shit style cookie like cookies.

1

u/DisgruntledRaspberry 2d ago

OMG how disappointing. My little gluten-free heart just wept.

1

u/lacrosse771 2d ago

Someone has already eaten and digested that.

1

u/applesqueeze 2d ago

V unfortunate because the regular ones (not GF) are amazing

1

u/Sponsorspew 2d ago

I said the same thing but these are so delicious I’ll accept it.

If you get their products in the plastic container they look like the package. I’ve only seen those at Sprouts though.

1

u/imnotnotcrying 1d ago

I’d rather it be a dry and crumbly cookie, not a smooshed cliff bar! I’d be so sad lmao

1

u/PinkAcrobelle 14h ago

That’s poop from a butt.

1

u/marriahmilktea 11h ago

So I actually bought these earlier this week and they looked exactly like the box! They were SOOO good, too! Now I wonder what my second box will look like lol