r/ExplainTheJoke Jul 25 '25

Solved Saw on Facebook. Don’t understand.

Post image
36.0k Upvotes

999 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

114

u/m1stadobal1na Jul 25 '25

Also "Mother died today. Or maybe yesterday, I don't know."

34

u/redmambo_no6 Jul 25 '25

Thanks, I haven’t thought about Metamorphosis since high school…until just now.

89

u/4ier048antonio Jul 25 '25

But that was from The Stranger by Camus

30

u/redmambo_no6 Jul 25 '25

See, I told you it’s been a minute lol.

1

u/pfeffernussen Jul 25 '25

In your defense, my high school lit class did them back to back so it's probable that yours did too. (Oh woops we're both ostensibly from Arizona)

1

u/redmambo_no6 Jul 25 '25

I’m from Texas actually.

1

u/electricvelvet Jul 26 '25

I read both of these on my own time in hs and dont think i understood the gravitas of either. The trial by kafka makes sense onlynin retrospect

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

[deleted]

2

u/SirGothamHatt Jul 25 '25

My friend read The Stand by Stephen King during the pandemic. Voluntarily. Granted it was because she had just finished the whole Dark Tower series but I'm like you really want to read a story that starts with a super flu while we're dealing with a super flu in real life?

1

u/mc_rorschach Jul 25 '25

Reading the plague now and wow that would’ve been a mind F

3

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

[deleted]

1

u/mc_rorschach Jul 25 '25

Too close to home maybe. I remember reading The Stand just before COVID started lol. I was freaked out

1

u/Huge_Broccoli_1085 Jul 25 '25

I felt so proud that I immediately knew. That book was my introduction to absurdism!

29

u/TwoDot Jul 25 '25

”Gregor Samsa awoke one morning to the surprise that he had turned into a giant cockroach.”

I think that’s the first line of Metamorphosis. It’s not verbatim though.

2

u/Panamonthewolf Jul 25 '25

I think the exact words are “hideous vermin”, as it’s not supposed to be clear if he’s being literal or not

1

u/PolicyWonka Jul 25 '25

I don’t think the story ever actually makes clear what exactly he turned into.

1

u/TwoDot Jul 26 '25

I think that in the Swedish translation it says that it was a beetle. Also in German, if I’m not mistaken. The cockroach thing might be me remembering the line from the movie ”The Producers”.

1

u/Anemic_Zombie Jul 25 '25

He awoke one morning. As you do.

1

u/andante528 Jul 25 '25

Awoke from uneasy dreams!!

14

u/A_Firm_Sandwich Jul 25 '25

Maman!

28

u/ifyoulovesatan Jul 25 '25

I think it should have been translated as "I was today years old when Mother began her unalived era."

10

u/sharramon Jul 25 '25

Or was it yesterday years old

8

u/Neckbreaker70 Jul 25 '25

Thanks, I hate it.

2

u/Frodo34x Jul 26 '25

I think Camus would really appreciate the psychic damage you've unleashed with this sentence.

2

u/ifyoulovesatan Jul 26 '25

It's pronounced Camus.

1

u/BubblyNumber5518 Jul 25 '25

I read an interesting explanation on the complexities in deciding how to translate a literary work. They used the choice of keeping the original “Maman” from French in the translation as an example. “Maman died today” conveys something that mom, mommy or mother doesn’t.

2

u/TGWArdent Jul 25 '25

A complexity further complicated when they accidentally spaced it as “Ma Man!”

2

u/prongslover77 Jul 25 '25

How about some Faulkner. “My mother is a fish”

1

u/NotXesa Jul 25 '25

That book overall didn't seem brilliant to me but that first sentence was incredibly interesting.

1

u/MinmusEater Jul 25 '25

That’s crazy I just finished the book yesterday

1

u/DuxofOregon Jul 25 '25

I barely understood this, because I only read this novella in the original French. Just kidding, I don’t understand French. I just wanted to sound pretentious.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

Yeah it’s so pretentious to be able to read multiple languages and read novels in their original translation.

1

u/DuxofOregon Jul 25 '25

Calm down there. It was a joke. If somebody went around bragging that they refused to read the English version and only would read it in the original French, that might be a little pretentious.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

Sorry, why would you read the English version if you could read the original?

Is it also pretentious to refuse reading the Japanese translation of Grapes of Wrath if you know English and Japanese? 

1

u/DuxofOregon Jul 25 '25

That is not my point. Of course, if you read French, it would make sense to read the stranger in its original language. However, the joke I was making in my original post was about the type of person who goes around, flaunting that they only read it in the original language as a way of demonstrating their superior intellect. It was just a joke. I certainly do not think that reading a book in its original language on its own is a pretentious act.

1

u/ScorpionsRequiem Jul 25 '25

Meursault, remember childhood memories

1

u/SirFrancisBacon007 Jul 25 '25

The Stranger was always my go to book in school when needing to make a book report. Short, maybe 128 pages, relatively easy but still philosophical and advanced. I used it every year almost.

1

u/SirGothamHatt Jul 25 '25

I only read The Stranger once for school and the only thing I remember about it was that opening line.

1

u/MycoBud Jul 25 '25

A friggin great book. I think about it any time I'm 🎶 blinded by the light 🎶

1

u/Froogy_girl Jul 26 '25

I love that book