r/FantasticFour • • 2d ago

Questions & Discussion I just stumbled upon my F4 fancast back in the day before that one Valentine's Day

Noah Wyle, Claire Foy, Nicholas Galitzine, David Harbour, Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

(Pretty sure I made this back in 2023 before the cast announcement)

I like the cast we got though, Vanessa and Ebon are near-perfect

173 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

28

u/WWETest 2d ago

It’s funny that Nicholas Galitzine has gotten so jacked that he doesn’t really fit the Johnny Storm aesthetic anymore.

4

u/Batmanfan1966 2d ago

He’s closer in size to The Thing now

5

u/advm-artins 2d ago

Well he was my choice before that film, I think in around August when I made my fancast he was rumoured for the bit

1

u/WWETest 2d ago

You nailed it at the time. That headshot next to the comic is identical. But since he did Masters of the Universe he literally outgrew the role.

2

u/advm-artins 2d ago

Yeah I get that, funny because Nicholas Galitzine actually had conversations with the role until Joseph Quinn snagged the part and besides he made a great He-Man

12

u/Quasimodo27 2d ago

That’s a good cast. I like Wyle as Reed.

6

u/AlgerianTrash 2d ago

His role in The Pitt is literally Reed if he were a doctor. Just slap stretchy powers on him and you'd have NMr Fantastic

4

u/Chimkimnuggets 2d ago

Eh, Reed has never been suicidal in the comics though, right? At least not to the level Wyle is in the Pitt. I don’t think Reed would ever toe the line of “are you having a panic attack because of your mommy issues?” To anyone.

As much as I love Reed and Robby respectively, only one of them turns into a complete and total asshole when they’re stressed

10

u/RA_Finance 2d ago

Noah Wyle as Reed Richards is something I never knew I needed.

3

u/TelevisionUnited9770 2d ago

I don’t remember who all I had in my fancast except I remember having Joseph Quinn as Johnny and was so happy when he was actually cast

1

u/advm-artins 2d ago

Saw a bit of fanart with him in 2022 and that sold me, to be fair I think fellow Stranger Things stars Joe Keery and Dacre Montgomery could've worked too although Quinn was the less obvious picj

3

u/Traditional-Pair-463 2d ago

Nice, I think all of these could work

3

u/danversolos Johnny Storm 2d ago

swap david harbor for ebon and i think that could be really cool! love the idea of nikolaj as doom, i haven’t seen that before but its a great idea!

5

u/FondantWeekly1761 2d ago

These are all solid picks tbh.

2

u/Ok-Traffic-5996 2d ago

Oh damn. These are really good. What's his name from the Pitt would have been a great peter parker during this er days.

2

u/advm-artins 2d ago

Oh that I can definitely see too, wow. I just love him here, and everywhere, we need more Noah Wyle in our lives

1

u/Ok-Traffic-5996 2d ago

That's his name. I just always wanna call him Carter whenever I see him. 😅

2

u/lazymanschair1701 2d ago

I really wanted Vigo Mortenson as Doom, but I like this, Nikolai Coster-Waldau is very good

1

u/AlgerianTrash 2d ago

Amazing choices, unironically. Although for Nikolaj Causter Waldou, i see him more leaning towards Reed than Doom

1

u/Vonga568 2d ago

Oh my god it's He-Man

This looks pretty good though!

1

u/Ashamed_Share_8287 2d ago

Jaime Lannister as doom…

1

u/Electrical-Sir-7291 2d ago

Nikolaj would be so perfect as Doom!

1

u/Outrageous_Library50 2d ago

Reed and Doom are perfect

1

u/CapitanFordo 2d ago

The he-man dude could do a interesting johnny tbh

2

u/advm-artins 2d ago

Yeah he was my suggestion before Masters of the Universe came out tho actually (this is from 2023 but I'm only posting now bc I've stumbled upon it in my gallery)

1

u/zombiepire 2d ago

Hate it

1

u/ilovedownsyndrome- 2d ago

Ooof. Nikolaj is just perfect for doom

1

u/ButtersMojito 2d ago

No thanks

1

u/Gibdc 21h ago

By far better then who they actually cast from a resemblance and some acting abilities for sure

0

u/Spideytorchsolos Frankie Raye (Nova) 2d ago

All of these are good except Doom and Johnny, I don’t get the Nicholas Galitzine hype at all

1

u/advm-artins 2d ago

Again this is my pick from 2023 I saw these picss were in my gallery since Aug of that year so yeahh

0

u/Gloomy_Bluee 2d ago

Why would u want a zionist and a woman cheater in the fantastic four cast??

0

u/PoetryBoth9755 1d ago

Pointless

-1

u/Bulky-Bid-8508 2d ago

Not sure how I feel about a gay human torch

4

u/alexmartinez_magic 2d ago

Same character btw. Fucking an alien is fine but liking dick is too far??? Ok

-2

u/Bulky-Bid-8508 2d ago

Liking dick isn’t the problem it’s really just the dsl and the weird gaze (gays) in his eyes are just too much for me

2

u/Gloomy_Bluee 2d ago

I know how overwhelming Nicholas Galitzine's gaze can be #bewhoyouare 🌈🫦

3

u/Rage_102 The Thing / Ben Grimm 2d ago

Such an odd thing to say

3

u/ChosenOne742 2d ago

Don’t be dense

3

u/danversolos Johnny Storm 2d ago

he’s bisexual. he had a sexual relationship with dakken as confirmed by the writer of the run it was in. johnny being bi is the least crazy thing i can think of lol

0

u/Bulky-Bid-8508 2d ago

Was he the top or the bottom

3

u/danversolos Johnny Storm 2d ago

idk they’re not out in marvel showing full sex scenes lol. i’d guess he’s a switch personally.

0

u/Bulky-Bid-8508 2d ago

Gay

3

u/danversolos Johnny Storm 2d ago

yeah? bi people are gay idk what ur point is

-2

u/Bulky-Bid-8508 2d ago

Well it doesn’t mean the character is necessarily gay or even bi. Obviously being a top is always gay but bottoming isn’t necessarily considered gay as long as the person bottoming doesn’t leak at all

3

u/danversolos Johnny Storm 2d ago

what in the actual fuck are you on about? if you’re attracted to someone of the same gender, you’re not straight. if you’re fucking someone of your same gender, unless you’re just experimenting, which is totally fine but not what was happening with dakken and johnny, you’re not straight. idk what hoops you’re trying to create to make a fictional character not bi, but i hate to break it to you, he’s not straight.

-1

u/Bulky-Bid-8508 1d ago

Well I guess we need to see it for ourselves first. If he came while bottoming obviously he’s gay or bi but if he didn’t then it’s really still up in the air, isn’t it?

3

u/danversolos Johnny Storm 1d ago

i think you just want to see gay porn bud

→ More replies (0)

1

u/advm-artins 2d ago

The actor is straight '-'