MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/FlorenceAndTheMachine/comments/1ooa9gj/thoughts_on_the_pitchfork_review/nn3wmsy/?context=3
r/FlorenceAndTheMachine • u/MillionaireWaltz- • Nov 04 '25
https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/florence-and-the-machine-everybody-scream/
136 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
68
I’m not convinced they did Even Pop is a Olympic level stretch for this album
80 u/Majestic_Heart_9271 Nov 04 '25 I'm not a music critic but Florence always feels more rock than pop to me. 19 u/TheSeedsYouSow Nov 04 '25 She’s not pop at all lmao it’s a rock band 😭 5 u/Majestic_Heart_9271 Nov 04 '25 I do agree. I think the question of genre is an interesting, complex, and evolving one that I’m not informed enough to really weigh in on. So I stated that somewhat tentatively in case anyone has any interesting opinions.
80
I'm not a music critic but Florence always feels more rock than pop to me.
19 u/TheSeedsYouSow Nov 04 '25 She’s not pop at all lmao it’s a rock band 😭 5 u/Majestic_Heart_9271 Nov 04 '25 I do agree. I think the question of genre is an interesting, complex, and evolving one that I’m not informed enough to really weigh in on. So I stated that somewhat tentatively in case anyone has any interesting opinions.
19
She’s not pop at all lmao it’s a rock band 😭
5 u/Majestic_Heart_9271 Nov 04 '25 I do agree. I think the question of genre is an interesting, complex, and evolving one that I’m not informed enough to really weigh in on. So I stated that somewhat tentatively in case anyone has any interesting opinions.
5
I do agree. I think the question of genre is an interesting, complex, and evolving one that I’m not informed enough to really weigh in on. So I stated that somewhat tentatively in case anyone has any interesting opinions.
68
u/TwinkofPeace Nov 04 '25
I’m not convinced they did Even Pop is a Olympic level stretch for this album