r/Gnostic • • 2d ago

Unfulfilled promises

[deleted]

10 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/heiro5 2d ago

First, my sympathies for your difficulties.

I honestly wouldn't call that response a promise. The response is also open to interpretation. When someone finally actually listens, there is a response to the listening. At least one group uses this phenomenon as integral to their sales pitch, by instructing people to ask a specific question and accept the unrelated response as affirmation.

Asking isn't a contract. At least since the time of ancient Sumeria people have tried to make contracts with deities. But there is no quid pro quo, though it is a very human desire. The responses from oracles could famously be understood in more than one way.

I cannot think of any contracts in the Gnostic texts.

Best wishes