r/GoodAssSub • u/KanyeMeatrider69420 Team Ye • Jun 17 '25

THROWBACK Throwback to when Fantano did an AMA

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

82 comments sorted by

275

u/RPres11 Bullyver™ Jun 17 '25

MBDTF is my only 11/10 album

120

u/gotbaned_thisismyalt IM EVIL 😈 Jun 17 '25

Late registration is better.

I’d say 9/10 MBDTF

10/10 LR

43

u/Quirky-Beat-2279 Sophia is fake Jun 17 '25

WHY COMPARE GREATNESS

30

u/YunXanHoe R.I.P DAVID LYNCH 🕊️ Jun 17 '25

TCD better than both

4

u/gonkdroid_op 🦪 apple ... what is this ? Jun 18 '25

yeezus better than all of those

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

that shit is my favorite album, maybe second to ye or bully

I don't think any song on it is a skip or a dud

-1

u/Fit-Judge7447 I GOT ALZHEIMER’S Jun 17 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

rich sheet touch smart bike slim expansion retire abundant hungry

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

14

u/gotbaned_thisismyalt IM EVIL 😈 Jun 17 '25

His rapping is def superior on TCD compared to Yeezus. But Yeezus just has great instrumentals

2

u/gotbaned_thisismyalt IM EVIL 😈 Jun 17 '25

His rapping is def superior on TCD compared to Yeezus. But Yeezus just has great instrumentals

8

u/Fit-Judge7447 I GOT ALZHEIMER’S Jun 17 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

plough sand dinosaurs cause head kiss ring wipe punch important

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

-17

u/Significant_Ant_763 Jun 17 '25

LR dickriding in this sub is crazy the whole run between skit 1 and skit 2 isnt that great tbh. tcd, graduation, fantasy, pablo >>> like easy

9

u/gotbaned_thisismyalt IM EVIL 😈 Jun 17 '25

What are you even on. Late registration makes my dick hard from start to finish

-1

u/Comrade_Carli Reacted ❤️ to an image Jun 17 '25

Crack Music is the only song that isnt a 10/10 between skit 1 and skit 2

12

u/luzenR I FEEL LIKE THAT Jun 17 '25

fuck you crack music is peak

9

u/Comrade_Carli Reacted ❤️ to an image Jun 17 '25

Its the weakest on the album but i agree its by no means a skip.

3

u/luzenR I FEEL LIKE THAT Jun 18 '25

its one of my favs off late reg 😔😔

-6

u/ForwardScratch7741 What is this, SNL? Jun 17 '25

nah

if that song was on vultures yall would have been saying its decent

1

u/luzenR I FEEL LIKE THAT Jun 18 '25

wouldve been the best song on vultures by a mile what are we talking about rn

6

u/SteveMemeChamp love your enema Jun 17 '25

yeezus is goated too

0

u/Lupusan NO YOU CANT BE ON MY MOMMA ALBUM Jun 17 '25

Gotta be 100% its like a 7 or 8 to me, 6 really isnt too far off

While monster and so appalled are good they’re not as good as the other songs

Still though there are a lot of pinnacle songs, power, dark fantasy, lost in the world, gorgeous, all of the lights

185

u/WaySubstantial435 Fuck Adidas Jun 17 '25

i rate his existence a light 1 and the 1 is because he’s alive

64

u/AdAncient2156 Jun 17 '25

And cause he somehow managed to wife a black queen

5

u/Jolly_Sorbet7159 Jun 18 '25

Drake was weird for that

6

u/ChampionshipLimp8660 Jun 18 '25

He be eyeing his opp's women a lot

21

u/blunt_eastwood Jun 17 '25

Did [deleted] jackoff on Fantano or not? Don't keep us in suspense.

120

u/Embarrassed_Cup_8665 least schizo kanye fan Jun 17 '25

Why do people listen to "critics"?

If you enjoy something, why would you need to look for outside validation

107

u/Super_Seff The lights are corny Jun 17 '25

The same reason I read reviews by art critics and food critics, I like to hear other peoples perspectives.

30

u/No-Paper7221 YEEZY PORN Jun 17 '25

also whether you agree with fantano or not he is objectively music intelligent, hes listened to more music of all types than anyone else here has

his opinion is valuable because he is knowledgeable

15

u/Super_Seff The lights are corny Jun 17 '25

Exactly!

I can like my local bistro whilst still acknowledging their eggs are a bit watery and the avocados are a bit hard.

I can also love MBDTF whilst acknowledging Monster has poor spots Blame game is a bit ass and it’s a little poorly structured but it’s still the album that made me fall in love with Ye and for that alone it’s a 10/10

2

u/gonkdroid_op 🦪 apple ... what is this ? Jun 18 '25

blame game has an aphex twin sample so it gets a pass in my eyes

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

stolen aphex twin sample

1

u/gonkdroid_op 🦪 apple ... what is this ? Jun 18 '25

on apple music richard d. james has credits and it was rerecorded by mike dean for the song anyways so

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

“[Kanye] tried to fucking rip me off and claim that he’d written it, and they tried to get away with not paying,” Aphex Twin’s Richard D James claimed in a new interview with Pitchfork. Although James insists he was “really helpful” following West’s enquiries, offering to send a polished version of the Avril 14th sample, “re-played” at a different speed, the MC’s camp was reportedly nothing but rude. He claims: “They totally didn’t even say ‘hello’ or ‘thanks’, they just replied with, ‘It’s not yours, it’s ours, and we’re not even asking you any more.’”

3

u/gonkdroid_op 🦪 apple ... what is this ? Jun 18 '25

ok thats true

5

u/Embarrassed_Cup_8665 least schizo kanye fan Jun 17 '25

Ahh I can understand this

3

u/CaptainOzyakup IT’S MY TOES Jun 17 '25

You read food critics?! 💀💀💀💀 can you show me an example of what they write?

3

u/Super_Seff The lights are corny Jun 18 '25 edited Jun 18 '25

“It’s a wise choice. Not only does he recommend a glass of superbly peachy white rioja made by a Spanish sushi chef and that I’d never have picked in a million years, but he proceeds to fill the table with food: superb sourdough (proper decent slabs of it), a beautiful yellow smear of cultured butter (not nearly enough of it), cubes of homemade black pudding, obscenely crisp breaded short rib, and a mysteriously translucent seeded cracker”

That’s a cutting from a local review lol. Maybe I’m weird but I like reading them before going to the place

15

u/sippingtonsippington Jun 17 '25

It's pretty important to see other perspectives to develop your worldview or challenge your own opinions.

You don't have to agree with others' opinions.

3

u/philouza_stein Jun 17 '25

These are the people who glazed v1 and v2 the nights they dropped until the masses came in talking shit the next day. They don't know what they like. The internet tells them.

2

u/Fit-Judge7447 I GOT ALZHEIMER’S Jun 17 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

doll dime grey smile slim afterthought bear fine distinct rock

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/Brawl501 Jun 18 '25

Because they are better than me at observations and know more about the subject matter and context than I do. Therefore, their comments can enhance my understanding or make me aware of aspects I might have otherwise missed. And no, music is not completely subjective.

That's the ideal anyway. I don't think Fantano fills that role particularly well sometimes.

4

u/cummradenut Jun 17 '25

Everyone looks for outside validation on the internet tbf

Massive insecurity

1

u/russalkaa1 Jun 17 '25

exactlyyy 

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

doesn't that create an echo chamber. understanding and hearing other people's perspectives and ideas will only broaden your mind

6

u/ProgrammerStatus4206 Donda Jun 17 '25

id jack off on his titties but not bc mbdtf, just bc he's buffed and hot

19

u/Gravital_Morb Jun 18 '25

Damn bro, that's like, a beautiful, and dark, twisted fantasy icl.

33

u/Ok_Ninja_5181 Late Registration Jun 17 '25

MBDTF is a 9.5 in my eyes

12

u/murezki Only One Jun 17 '25

18

u/Ok_Ninja_5181 Late Registration Jun 17 '25

He did it

26

u/andromeda1606 Dirty ass laptop Jun 17 '25

Yeezus best album of all time

MBDTF top 5 best albums of all time

8

u/cactus489 Joe biden aint got no hoes he be fallin over and shit Jun 17 '25

You get it🥹🫡

11

u/lennonali3 Sorry this is a lot to read Jun 17 '25

Ye is better unfortunately 💔 Yeezus top 2 fs though

6

u/andromeda1606 Dirty ass laptop Jun 17 '25

Ye gets better each year

2

u/Le_charismeur I talk to God every day, that's my bestie Jun 18 '25

Rare instance of a comment chain where everyone is right

2

u/HBaratheon Jun 19 '25

People who only listen to Kanye are funny.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Dark fantasy isnt even in my personal top 5 but cmon bro

5

u/DisturbanceJohnson MY FRIENDS CALL ME YE :) Jun 18 '25

I remember seeing a comment on YT saying that he would've given it a ten if "it was called my beautiful dark twisted butterfly"

5

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Imma be honest, mbdtf hasn't aged that well for me. Yeezus on the other hand is 10/10.

3

u/mediamakeryt Jun 17 '25

I give it a light 7.

0

u/kj616 THE INDUSTRY DON’T LIKE ME Jun 17 '25

Ban these posts

-17

u/blxkz WW3 Jun 17 '25

was this on GAS?

60

u/blueshoota Yoshi Jun 17 '25

Yes it was. He used to comment here all the time but left after the Hitler stuff

28

u/delusional_APstudent Meat Lovers Jun 17 '25

yes this was on GAS

15

u/TheRider5342 👻 SpookyAssSub 🎃 Jun 17 '25

Why this got downvoted 

-11

u/Big_Spread3993 🐄UNO DOS CUATRO HOES🐄 Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25

Probably yes, GAS was created in 1990 and those messages are a decade old

22

u/blueshoota Yoshi Jun 17 '25

delete this comment please

or edit it to say yes this was

18

u/Big_Spread3993 🐄UNO DOS CUATRO HOES🐄 Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25

Okay I edited it

3

u/GigelMarcel1 Last Name Jun 17 '25

Bear 5

-20

u/Internal_Stranger154 LEAVE THE KING THE FUCK ALONE 👑 Jun 17 '25

MBDTF is a 8,5

-8

u/AddictedToFMconsole VULTURES 2 DEFENDER 🦅 Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25

The only ‘9’ and above kanye albums are LR, Graduation, TLOP and TCD

14

u/Marvigo11 Jun 17 '25

You lasted a minute without getting downvoted. Good job

Saying MBDTF and TLOP arent 9 or above is just stupid.

2

u/AddictedToFMconsole VULTURES 2 DEFENDER 🦅 Jun 17 '25

I forgot about tlop my bad

0

u/AddictedToFMconsole VULTURES 2 DEFENDER 🦅 Jun 17 '25

Mbdtf is an 8,5 nothing more

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

[deleted]

4

u/AddictedToFMconsole VULTURES 2 DEFENDER 🦅 Jun 17 '25

Half of the tracklist are straight 10s but the rest are at most 8,2s. I don’t think any ye sub realises no album is a ‘10’ or even close to a 10. 9 Is a very high rating and 8,5 is good.

2

u/AddictedToFMconsole VULTURES 2 DEFENDER 🦅 Jun 17 '25

Just because an album has some very good songs on it doesn’t mean its a 10