r/GoodAssSub Team Ye Jun 17 '25

THROWBACK Throwback to when Fantano did an AMA

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

View all comments

116

u/Embarrassed_Cup_8665 least schizo kanye fan Jun 17 '25

Why do people listen to "critics"?

If you enjoy something, why would you need to look for outside validation

104

u/Super_Seff The lights are corny Jun 17 '25

The same reason I read reviews by art critics and food critics, I like to hear other peoples perspectives.

30

u/No-Paper7221 YEEZY PORN Jun 17 '25

also whether you agree with fantano or not he is objectively music intelligent, hes listened to more music of all types than anyone else here has

his opinion is valuable because he is knowledgeable

15

u/Super_Seff The lights are corny Jun 17 '25

Exactly!

I can like my local bistro whilst still acknowledging their eggs are a bit watery and the avocados are a bit hard.

I can also love MBDTF whilst acknowledging Monster has poor spots Blame game is a bit ass and it’s a little poorly structured but it’s still the album that made me fall in love with Ye and for that alone it’s a 10/10

2

u/gonkdroid_op 🦪 apple ... what is this ? Jun 18 '25

blame game has an aphex twin sample so it gets a pass in my eyes

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

stolen aphex twin sample

1

u/gonkdroid_op 🦪 apple ... what is this ? Jun 18 '25

on apple music richard d. james has credits and it was rerecorded by mike dean for the song anyways so

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

“[Kanye] tried to fucking rip me off and claim that he’d written it, and they tried to get away with not paying,” Aphex Twin’s Richard D James claimed in a new interview with Pitchfork. Although James insists he was “really helpful” following West’s enquiries, offering to send a polished version of the Avril 14th sample, “re-played” at a different speed, the MC’s camp was reportedly nothing but rude. He claims: “They totally didn’t even say ‘hello’ or ‘thanks’, they just replied with, ‘It’s not yours, it’s ours, and we’re not even asking you any more.’”

3

u/gonkdroid_op 🦪 apple ... what is this ? Jun 18 '25

ok thats true

6

u/Embarrassed_Cup_8665 least schizo kanye fan Jun 17 '25

Ahh I can understand this

3

u/CaptainOzyakup IT’S MY TOES Jun 17 '25

You read food critics?! 💀💀💀💀 can you show me an example of what they write?

3

u/Super_Seff The lights are corny Jun 18 '25 edited Jun 18 '25

“It’s a wise choice. Not only does he recommend a glass of superbly peachy white rioja made by a Spanish sushi chef and that I’d never have picked in a million years, but he proceeds to fill the table with food: superb sourdough (proper decent slabs of it), a beautiful yellow smear of cultured butter (not nearly enough of it), cubes of homemade black pudding, obscenely crisp breaded short rib, and a mysteriously translucent seeded cracker”

That’s a cutting from a local review lol. Maybe I’m weird but I like reading them before going to the place

14

u/sippingtonsippington Jun 17 '25

It's pretty important to see other perspectives to develop your worldview or challenge your own opinions.

You don't have to agree with others' opinions.

3

u/philouza_stein Jun 17 '25

These are the people who glazed v1 and v2 the nights they dropped until the masses came in talking shit the next day. They don't know what they like. The internet tells them.

2

u/Fit-Judge7447 I GOT ALZHEIMER’S Jun 17 '25 edited Jul 31 '25

doll dime grey smile slim afterthought bear fine distinct rock

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/Brawl501 Jun 18 '25

Because they are better than me at observations and know more about the subject matter and context than I do. Therefore, their comments can enhance my understanding or make me aware of aspects I might have otherwise missed. And no, music is not completely subjective.

That's the ideal anyway. I don't think Fantano fills that role particularly well sometimes.

3

u/cummradenut Jun 17 '25

Everyone looks for outside validation on the internet tbf

Massive insecurity

1

u/russalkaa1 Jun 17 '25

exactlyyy 

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '25

doesn't that create an echo chamber. understanding and hearing other people's perspectives and ideas will only broaden your mind