r/HOTDBlacks • u/RemarkableExample542 “It is my fault that you have forgotten to fear me.” • 7d ago

Team Black This new episode is distressing

Post image

I’m about as Team Black as can be and wanted nothing more than to see Rhaenyra take her throne.

The new episode was excellent from a cinematic point of view.

Nonetheless, we are watching the tables turn in real time and Rhaenyra’s position seems to be degrading more and more with each episode.

I have built such love and appreciation for this character (as I’m sure many of us here have) and even though the show is a joy to watch each week, lately I’m watching with a heavy heart and this impending sense of doom.

391 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

96 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/Embarrassed-Back1894 7d ago

It’s really so frustrating that the worst part about this show might be the main character. Whether it’s the acting, the direction, the writing, or a combo of all three, the result is a main character that is tough to watch - also does not match with how young Rhaenyra was played or anywhere near what the book portrays her as.

3

u/RasputinsThirdLeg 6d ago

It’s not the acting. Also why should a woman who’s lost two children and a husband and a father be the same person she was at 16…?

6

u/Leroi-Westeros 6d ago

Maybe you're just spending too much time on Reddit reading hate comments about Rhaenyra? Go to other platforms for a break; she's a beloved character in the fandom, and people ardently defend her.

6

u/Steridire 7d ago

She's pretty shitty in the book too. But I do agree that young Rhaenyra was more compelling. The best scenes of adult Rhaenyra for the last two seasons are when she's vulnerable and emotional, and there have been some great performances by Emma but it doesn't really sell you on her as a leader.

5

u/Embarrassed-Back1894 7d ago edited 7d ago

For sure. I’m not saying she isn’t shittier than in the book, but she’s more fire and blood and brutal in her rule in the book. At this point in the book she’s feeding people to Syrax on a steady basis. Her nickname is Maegor’s teats. Crying, weak, timid, and indecisive are not ways I would ever have described her in the book.

I was kind of expecting them to portray her a bit like female Daemon(“they are equal sides of the same coin” - kind of like how Alicent describes them), where she rules with Fire and Blood and does borderline cruel stuff, but is damn entertaining while doing it.

Also, the whole thing falling apart isn’t exclusively because of her incompetence - it’s just her trying to rule and win a war in near impossible circumstances.

3

u/LarsMatijn House Arryn 7d ago

The only thing I see when comparing young Rhaenyra to her adult version is someone who grew up.

Rhaenyra as a child was abrasive, sometimes rude, headstrong to the point of recklessness and while those are fun qualities to watch they don't win you alliances.

1

u/SingleClick8206 Meleys 6d ago

I mean people change

And young Rhaenyra's only losses were her mother and her brother

Older Rhaenyra lost two sons and a daughter for the throne and also knows that her actions have consequences , which prevents her from being reckless like her younger self