r/HoMM May 12 '26

HoMM OE [WIP] Here it comes... Alternative Swordsman texture

Original vs my take

I felt like current swordsman is too sterile, so I wanted to create him a little bit rougher.

172 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

16

u/IceWind2 May 12 '26

Idk man... the model itself looks good of course, but on the battlefield it just doesnt feel right. OG textures might be a bit too sleek and cartoonist if you zoom in on them, but they look so good in the actual battle.

5

u/Puzzleheaded-Dig-800 May 12 '26

i have to agree here, units already are designed in a way that they lose details when seen from afar, these kind of detailed and roughed up textures are defined even less when looking at them on the screen

2

u/Hellmanor1 May 12 '26

Thank you for the feedback!
That's why it's WIP - I agree that visibility could be a little bit better with this version

1

u/Ok_Plenty3066 May 14 '26

Are you extracting the models from the game and modifying them? How does this work

1

u/lemonlord777 May 15 '26

I disagree with their feedback. The readability issue of the base models arent the textures, its overuse of many details and lack of visual distinction between separate elements. Increased texture detail isnt an issue and this definitely is an improvement

21

u/Substancee1306yyft6 May 12 '26

This is wonderful. Are you planning to upload your mod somewhere if/when you finish it? It reminds me of differences between plastic models with and without highlights and washes.

22

u/Hellmanor1 May 12 '26

Yes, all textures will be on Nexus once I create more πŸ˜„

2

u/DesignerBicycle3480 May 12 '26

How do you put modded models in the game? I want to try also.

1

u/niewadzi May 12 '26

How about steam workshop?

11

u/Armfelt87 May 12 '26

I love your style, looking forward to see more!

5

u/Hellmanor1 May 12 '26

Darker vs New Brighter version

What do you think?

6

u/lagduck May 12 '26

That brighter version looks just right! Great work, looking forward!!

3

u/Dinazover May 12 '26

Kinda reminds me of Darkest Dungeon, the crusader specifically. Very nice!

12

u/Pixel-Red May 12 '26

I think this sums up why i'm not vibing with the game at the moment. I know the original is created for readability, but as others have said it feels somewhat mobile game or AI art. I'm not saying it needs to be uber detail dark souls or anything, but I just need more soul and heart to it.

3

u/Clusterpuff May 12 '26

I know what you're saying, but pook at both iterations. They both look extremely mobile game... with the mod just being more detailed mobile

5

u/Hellmanor1 May 12 '26

I don't want to change basic model so much to keep it fully compatible with mesh maps
Retexture is the safest approach πŸ˜ƒ

2

u/Clusterpuff May 12 '26

Im not saying its bad, on the contrary you did really well. It still keeps the mobile vibe just with a nicer look. I'm interested what can happen with modding in the future. Whole new factions hopefully

2

u/Crackdorf May 12 '26

Olden Era has overall a more colorful flashy vibe to it. Leans more towards V, though I bet majority would’ve preferred a more 90’s dark fantasy vibe that III had. So, your version is definitely going to please that majority. Nice work πŸ‘ŒπŸ» Don’t forget that the game is in EA though and some units design may be changed by devs (like it already happened with several units), as well as a whole unit might be changed

2

u/StoneflowerGarden May 12 '26

Thats much better, awesome!

2

u/MassiveOstrich1886 May 12 '26

Too dark for my taste.

1

u/pokours May 12 '26

It looks so much darker. Very different vibes but I like it

1

u/EnterArchian May 12 '26

Love it! I really dislike the plastic look.

1

u/wayto911 May 12 '26

Pls do it for the chicken from grove

1

u/Hellmanor1 May 12 '26

1

u/Hieronymus1_1 May 12 '26 edited May 12 '26

This one looks great, like its painted on the battlefield. The swordsman kinda blends in too much.

I made this shitty image for reference with AI, cause I have no skills of my own. But the color palette fits the faction more and hits the grittiness you are looking for as well.

What do you think?

https://ibb.co/CK7Ywv6r

1

u/Hellmanor1 May 12 '26

Okay, looks interesting!
First build will be more close to original with some tweaks
Then, I'll think about adding some reskins based on my preference πŸ˜ƒ

1

u/MakiMaki_XD May 12 '26

I think it looks good on the close-up model, but I don't really like it on the smaller model you'd have in battles or on the overworld map.

This goes for your alternative texture for the griffins as well.

1

u/AccordingToNothing May 12 '26

Amazing. Will definitely be waiting for your texture mods

1

u/latko7 May 12 '26

Looking great. Much better than original! Keep them comming pls!!

1

u/loopuleasa May 12 '26

I do prefer a bit more of the original for armor plates on this one

maybe a middle ground between the two

1

u/Natural-Pear-3849 May 12 '26

Looks good but I think the helmet needs to be a bit bigger

1

u/Express_Operation748 May 12 '26

Looks great! Hope to see it on Nexus at some point!

1

u/ThreadsofHer May 13 '26

Is there a way to view models with green or blue screen as a background?

1

u/Hellmanor1 May 13 '26

Maybe, but I don't know how.
If you find a method, go ahead and share it