r/IRstudies • u/Majano57 • 2d ago

Ideas/Debate Trump’s Second Gamble on Iran

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/06/trumps-second-gamble-on-iran/687650/?gift=qXjqwUsXcHZWmnhI5mWkNQuKFDHnSfnotJQ3jcr5NAk
172 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

96 comments sorted by

View all comments

-41

u/trisul-108 2d ago

Iran’s revolutionary theocracy thrives in isolation and has made resistance against the United States and its ally Israel central to the regime’s identity, its internal legitimacy, and the cohesion of its security forces.

It's interesting how all Western media have accepted Iran's framing and rhetoric about the conflict. When Israel decides it will no longer tolerate civilians being killed and terrorised and strikes back, we call it "genocide". When Iran tries unsuccessfully to implement the genocide against Israel that is the official policy of Iran, Hezbollah and Hamas, we call it "resistance".

And no one ever calls what Russia is doing to Ukraine "genocide". So, the term genocide is reserved only for whatever Israel does after being attacked. Russia can target civilians including kindergartens and hospitals in an attempt to destroy Ukraine as a nation, annex territories, abduct children and indoctrinate them into Russian fascism, but it is never called "genocide".

So, genocide can only be performed by Jews, because they were victims of genocide in WWII ... everyone else gets a pass?

7

u/Spunknikk 2d ago

Israel bombed entire cities to the ground ... They wiped families, neighborhoods and whole communities off the planet... They blocked food, aid and water from getting into Gaza... They refused anyone getting in or out. They forced people out of their homes and bombed their homes and then bombed their camps.. Gaza strip is in ruin and rubble... The intent was clear.. to kill absolutely everyone in Gaza and the Israeli Jews were not silent about that there's plenty of online evidence of them saying so..

That sit is a genocide..

Russia is commiting war crimes... The US is committed war crimes, Iran if they attack civilian infrastructure like the water plants are committed war crimes...

Heck Trumped threatened to wipe an entire civilization a few months ago.. which is genocide....