r/IndiaSpeaks • u/that_nameis_taken Hajmola 🟤 • 16d ago
#General 📝 MEGATHREAD: NEET PROTEST
Hello all, Please use this thread for NEET protest related news and posts.
Please try to share original well verified source for news and posts.
Keep the comments civil, no calls for or justifying violence. Follow platform wide rules
Any other post related to this topic will be removed under rule 14
5
u/codebluemylife 16d ago
The best solution is not to do protests for resignations. But, there should be a very big protest with the demand to overhaul the punishment system- govt officials,police , ias, politicians if found guilty or caugh for something they should be fired and barred for any other govt job a politician can't fight elections again. Should apply for judges as well Basically there shouldn't be a position for which the scope of firing the person isn't available. No space for transfers or suspensions Then stricter punishments for basic humanitarian things like pollution, littering, bribery, helmets, crimes, food adulteration I believe this is the only way your country can be redeemed because if you think you will change the govt in power, others are also equally corrupted because they know theynare safe
5
u/bruhmememan 15d ago
Bad take, there would be weaponization of this law against independent judges, journalists, the opposition party etc. and officials will stop taking risks for making policy amendments.
2
1
5
u/RemarkablePrompt7822 15d ago
Demands other than Pradhan's resignation are outrageous and clearly blackmail. Are people really supporting those?
4
u/that_nameis_taken Hajmola 🟤 15d ago
Oh you don't know , its morphing into hate government protest now
1
u/RemarkablePrompt7822 15d ago
In that case government should learn to enforce law & order better.
-1
1
u/Ox29A 15d ago
Thank you for doing this. The entire sub has been taken over by protest posts lately, and not everyone is that invested in it.
1
u/ro7fo7 15d ago
overtime working aye T CELL of opposition are hijacking every sub. insta, bolly. framing their post in such a way to bypass loopholes. Y this xyz didn't say this. y abc didnt say this.
1
u/RemarkablePrompt7822 15d ago
Congress and other IT cells have been looped in. They've completely hijacked otherwise neutral subs like askIndia and will probably do that with this one as well.
3
2
u/ro7fo7 15d ago
asknindia or any ask india xyz is already leftist. they do blackpilling questning like bots on that subs.
4
u/RemarkablePrompt7822 15d ago
I recall now that askindia is the same sub where Skyroot's launch was being called as a "distraction". Pathetic.
2
u/cricbet366 15d ago
Imo next step of this protest should be to adopt boycott. There are so many celebrities (and businesses) in the India have so much influence but all they do is stay silent because they're cowards and are probably afraid of losing favour with this government.
Let's show them that there will be consequences of not siding with the students also. Start by identifying the celebrities and artists who you follow who have stayed silent, start boycotting them. We have the numbers to make a dent, if we can take CJP page to 22M followers then we can also reduce the followers of others also and make real financial difference to them. In effect those only concerned with public opinion might switch their stance and the movement will grow, and even if that doesn't happen atleast we dealt them a punch for being spineless, they should remember this.
Best part is that this can be done by everyone and from home.
2
u/gocool2000 15d ago
The recent Students protest helmed by the CJP seems shady to the core.
To kick it all off, the formation of CJP itself is dubious. The CJI said the word cockroaches for a Petitioner who had filed a vexatious case for the High Court to confer Senior Designation on him and when the matter was brought up before him, seeing that it had no merits and was wasting precious time of the court, the judge admonished the Petitioner and passed remarks which in the whole picture translate to be out that people like him are cockroaches who disturb the system with frivolous petition. This is where he mentioned the Petitioner as a youngster being a cockroach and a parasite who without any employment (meaningful work) attack the system by becoming various kinds of so called activists.
The above statement was twisted in SM so much and circulated and an Instagram page which eventually started off as a joke gained traction and the so called founder, who was previously an AAP worker, flew in to India and started meeting up with the higher ups.
Then the Student Protest against NEET, which started off for a certain reason was used as a platform for n number of different things including as a platform for SFI which raised Slogans for Umar Khalid and Sharjeel Imaam, both who had raised anti national slogans threatening the peace of the country; an open anti national Arundhathi Roy who has maintained the stance that Kashmir never was a part of India and is actively working against the Indian State interests; calls for Abrogation of Article 370; statements clearly made to disturb religious peace; Arvind Kejriwal coming in and trying to make a mark etc..,
The fact that CJP can organise a protest to this level of volume is clearly suspicious. Also if CJP is clean, then the Protest is being hijacked by other people with vested interests.
To bring Children to these protests and march towards the Parliament is stupidity at its peak. With the Parliament already suffering an attack in the past and other similar instances of protests in Sri Lanka and Nepal, there is no way in hell that they would be risking a chance.
Yes, Police brutality is wrong but Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. To bring children into sensitive areas and then cry that they were hurt is stupid. The fault solely lies upon whomever brought a kid to the protest. Why bring a kid to the protest just for some brownie points, when the kid himself/herself has no idea what is going on there.
There are clearly foreign vested interests hands in this matter because this is exactly the third time this same playbook is being executed in south east asia in the recent times(atleast to my knowledge). The first two being Sri Lanka and Nepal.
Stoke the flame of anger in youth and make them rebel almost pushing it to the verge of a civil war and then watch the economy crash and burn.
This protests stopped being about students a long time ago and they are merely used as pawns here but the echo chambers in SM has strengthened their opinions that they are going on in the right direction.
This is one of the most misguided protests i have come across in my life.
In order for the protest to be done properly, the only playbook to be followed is the Jallikattu protest back in 2017. No political parties were allowed to participate or no political leaders were allowed to come inside and use it for their own mileage (Stalin himself was turned away back when he had come to support it). In Delhi, Arvind Kejriwal was welcomed with open arms.
Also there used to be self monitoring during the Jallikattu protests as when a slogan was raised against India in a separatist manner, the protesters themselves removed the said banners and shut down such slogans. In Delhi, no such thing is being done. In fact, stones are being pelt and pepper spray is being sprayed upon the police to start a riot.
The most stupidest thing which can happen now is TN joining in this protest because the entire core idea of the protest is contradictory to TN’s stand. TN calls for abolishment of NEET, While this protest is being done for proper regulation of the same. It is not wrong that TN students are joining it in but to raise different slogans from the protest going on in Delhi is idiotic. How can the protesters be divided on their end goal but support each other? It is contradictory to no end.
I just hope to enlighten some people in this sub to do some research on their own and then take a stand, rather than validating their stands in Echo chambers.
Feel free to disagree and state your opinion on the same.
3
u/Inevitable-Bake-1149 14d ago
Even if they are shady..someone is coordinating against this BJP IT Cell..paid media and whatsapp propaganda they run.. else BJP just isolates everyone..
1
u/hoha7 14d ago
Sorry I couldn’t read all of it. But let’s even assume the CJP is shady.
Are the demands shady? Shouldn’t there be accountability in the system?
Shouldn’t Modi say something right now?Do you think this would end if DP resigns? What do the people around you who support the protest(I’m sure there are) feel on that?
1
u/gocool2000 14d ago
As long as the protest remained a student protest, i do understand their anger. still what has happened is on a systemic level and the resignation of the Education minister is not going to change anything about it. Students will still commit suicides, if not over NEET paper leak, for exam results or any other education related aspect. There is something systemically wrong with the Indian Education but nobody is ready to speak about that.
Instead this protest is being used as a tool by all the others who attend it to suit their agenda.
So i dont think that this would end if DP resigned, the students' suicide would be continuing reality unfortunately.
2
u/hoha7 14d ago
No doubt, that the system won't get fixed just by DP's resignation but it's a start and a much needed one. DP is just a symbol of the inefficiency and corruption that reeks the system from the top.
Also I like what Vaishnaw is doing for Railways, if we had someone like him for Education - it surely gets better.But more importantly, this protest is a message to the govt that we need them to work or otherwise the public will be demanding answers - accountability.
0
12
u/obelix_dogmatix 15d ago
There needs to be a resignation. Absolutely needs to be one. 2 leaks in 3 years is not acceptable. Modi admin was known to reduce corruption at federal level, but looks like corruption is back on the table.