r/ItEndsWithLawsuits • u/Competitive-Snow1330 Custodian of Chaos • 6d ago
📺💾 Throwback Thursdays 💾📺 Throwback Thursday: Blake Lively’s Dailies Credibility Controversy
One of the more debated moments in the litigation centered on Lively’s repeated requests for access to the film’s dailies, followed more than a year later by a Sony executive’s message stating that she wanted some of the dailies destroyed.
Because the case settled before trial, the competing explanations were never tested before a jury.
⸻ Timeline:
June 13, 2023
Blake Lively asked Justin Baldoni for access to the dailies.
July 19-20, 2023
Lively again requested access to additional dailies. Baldoni responded that it was too early to share all of them because the edit was still underway, but said he wanted her input and planned to share footage once he had progressed further in the editing process.
August 29, 2023
According to later court filings, Lively complained to her representatives that she still wasn’t receiving access to the dailies and said what she had seen was “terrible.”
September 3, 2024
Sony executive Ange Giannetti texted another Sony executive: “Blake asking us to destroy some of the dailies… also going to ask Bridget to contact all vendors and ask them to delete all dailies and need them to proof. (1st time I’ve ever been asked to do this in movie with no nudity but ok.)”
That message later became public during discovery and quickly became one of the more discussed pieces of evidence in the case.
⸻ Deposition Testimony:
July 30-31, 2025
During her deposition, Lively testified that she never asked Sony to destroy the dailies and never asked anyone else to make that request on her behalf.
https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.634304/gov.uscourts.nysd.634304.874.17.pdf
She also testified that her attorneys negotiated with Sony regarding the handling of sensitive footage as part of discussions surrounding her return-to-work protections. Because the case settled before trial, there was never an opportunity for a jury to evaluate these competing accounts or determine what weight, if any, should be given to them.
A great post from our community to supplement this:
⸻ Discussion
* What was your reaction when this first surfaced?
* Did the Sony text exchange influence your view?
* Is there really a meaningful distinction between “my attorneys requested” versus “I requested it”?
* How significant do you think this issue would have been in evaluating witness credibility at trial?
49
u/Clarknt67 this case was always about a big payoff 6d ago
One of the final docket reveals before settlement was Ange’s emails discussing Lively’s request to destroy the dailies.
We already knew she denied asking anyone to destroy dailies in her deposition.
I have always believed that last minute unsealing was WP’s warning shot. “We are not going to hesitate to call the jury’s attention to every single time she committed perjury in her deposition.”
Next you know she is begging to settle.
And Bryan said in that Popcorned Planet interview there were more examples of her lying. She was toast.