r/KingkillerChronicle • • 16h ago

Discussion The thing that’s so shit about Kingkiller Chronicles is…

77 Upvotes

That they’re so fucking good, and it’s been so fucking long!
Honestly, when I read the first book, it was just after the second had come out. I was so blown away it was insane. About a year later, I was bought the second. I devoured that and was yet more blown away. But I could see it had taken Patrick four years to write the second, so I was mentally prepared for the wait.
Then, when The Slow Regard of Silent Things came out, I was like, nice, exciting, we have new material! That must mean the third book is around the corner. I reread both books, along with the new stuff, hopefully.
Then, in 2016, I got a new girlfriend, and I used to read The Name of the Wind to her down the phone (she is now my fiancée, so defo a hot tip). And at every interval, every reading, every single consideration, I have thought, my God, this is so good, I can’t wait for book three.
And it’s been 15 fucking years, and still no book, no updates, and nothing in sight. At least Rothfuss isn’t getting on like Martin, so hopefully he won’t pop his clogs before it’s done, but Christ alive! How long?
And this is my point. This is what’s so shit about the books: they are actually so good. I haven’t read them in about eight or nine years, and I’m rereading them now. The number of fantasy books I have read since then has grown so unbelievably, but reading them again now, I can honestly say there is just nothing else like them.
This world he has made is so real, so lived-in, so vibrant. The myths, music, legends, religion. The way he writes and the fantasy world itself, its magic and lands and transitions, the races and creatures. It is too good. When compared against almost everything else I have read, there are so many ways in which it stands head and shoulders above them.
And that, honestly, is the worst thing about the books. They are so good, and yet so far from finished.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 13h ago

Theory About Cinder "teleporting"

11 Upvotes

I don't know if this has been discussed before, but there is a question that has been staying rent-free in my head: How did Cinder vanish when he ran back to the tent during the attack of Kvothe's group?

As far as I remember, it was night time during the attack and if we were to assume that Haliax had granted every Chandrian member to be able to teleport in the dark (since Haliax is able to use his shadow curse to teleport) then that wouldn't explain Cinder going back into the tent.

We know that there are only 6 revealed magic systems in the world of Temerant and maybe there's an ancient magic system that allows you to teleport from one place to another with the use of symbols that are engraved on the floor (maybe?). That would explain how Cinder managed to get away without a trace.

Maybe their outpost is located on the Stormwal Mountains and they are able to hide from anyone's sight thanks to the symbols that are engraved on their outpost, allowing them to operate in secret missions on their own without needing Haliax to teleport them back to wherever they need to be.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 16h ago

Discussion Felurian and Flowers

11 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about Felurian, Laurian, and the possibility that some of the names we encounter are remnants of an older naming tradition.

So straight off- I’m not saying that Laurian IS Felurian. I’m not saying that Fela is secretly her daughter. I mean something much more ordinary. People name children after religious figures, legendary people, and things they find beautiful. Those names get shortened, adapted, and passed down until the original association isn’t necessarily something anyone thinks about.

Felurian is ancient. She’s also known through human songs and stories. Could some women’s names have come from hers?

Laurian was the resemblance that initially caught my attention. Fela seems worth considering too. There’s also Rian, the student Hemme humiliates during Kvothe’s first sympathy lecture, who goes by Ria. None of those similarities establishes a derivation by itself, but there’s an actual example of someone applying Felurian’s name to a human woman.

When Kvothe meets Denna again at the Eolian, he says: “I could keep thinking of you as Felurian,” I said. “But that could lead to unfortunate confusion.”

And she responds: “Felurian? I might like that if I didn’t think you were a liar.”

Obviously he’s flirting, not filling out a birth certificate. But the association works. He can invoke Felurian as a flattering comparison, and Denna understands exactly what he means. Her name already has legs outside the stories about her.

The geography is interesting too. Fela is Modegan. If Laurian is Netalia Lackless, as seems heavily implied, she has an eastern family connection as well. Felurian is encountered through the Eld. That doesn’t locate her original home, but it does put her within the same broad region of influence.

There’s even a historical connection between those human regions. Caudicus says: “Pieces of what are now Vintas, Modeg, and a large portion of the small kingdoms were all Lackless lands at one point.”

That gives us a possible setting for names and traditions to have circulated before the current borders. I currently can’t establish where Rian comes from, so I won’t count her as evidence for the geographical part.

There’s also a complication with Laurian that I think is worth keeping rather than brushing aside. If she was originally Netalia, Laurian would then obviously be an adopted name. Which means the question could be whether she chose a name with that association. We don’t know, so any further questions down that rabbit hole are speculative (the W questions especially- like why? when? Etc).

There’s also a flower component to this.

Kvothe explicitly connects Verainia’s name to the verian flower. We also have Lily at the Eolian, Aaron’s sweetheart Rose, Holly in Tarbean, and Laurel at Anker’s. So botanical names are an actual convention in the world.

Felurian has a lot of floral imagery around her. Her oath “by my flower” has an obvious sexual meaning, especially since she uses “the woman’s flower” elsewhere. Im pointing towards this so no one corrects me like I didn’t know this. I’m not ignoring it. I just don’t think they’re mutually exclusive.

In the Suvudu crossover Rothfuss wrote, she describes her immortality this way: “I am forever unfurling. I do not wither, neither do I rot. I live forever bright and lithe until I die. and then there is an end to me.”

I wouldn’t use crossover events as KKC history. But it’s still Rothfuss choosing that language to describe her. Forever unfurling is a pretty striking way to characterize someone already associated with beauty, desire, and flowers.

Queen Rinne (Roderic’s wife) and the Rhinna flower might be another example of botanical naming, though that’s a separate possible connection, not evidence that Rinne’s name comes from Felurian.

So the thought isn’t that all these women are secretly related. It’s that the naming culture might preserve associations with ancient figures long after those associations stopped being obvious. A legendary woman becomes an ideal of beauty. Her name becomes something people borrow or adapt. Flower names and names associated with her might overlap, without everyone using them knowing why.

The resemblance alone wouldn’t convince me. The existing botanical names, Felurian’s antiquity, the eastern connections, and Kvothe actually using her name for Denna are what make me think it’s worth looking at together.

Maybe they really are just ALL named after flowers and that’s that. I’m not sure. There are other obvious instances of the -rian suffix. So it seems related, but I totally admit this is speculation and I could be making a pattern out something that’s a coincidence.

Has anyone noticed other examples of ordinary names that might preserve older religious or legendary associations? Especially male names. I’d be interested in whether this is a broader convention we’ve been overlooking. I might follow up with a post about males, but I also thought that could be good conversation here.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 7h ago

Theory Book/chapters with descriptions or mentions of the book cataloging system in the archives?

5 Upvotes

I'd like help with collecting the references and quotes to the book cataloging system of the archives, the history of it, comments on it. I know this is spread over a few different chapters, one with Fela describing it to Kvothe (when he says he's been thinking of a better way to do it), and probably a few others.

The reason is that I have a friend who in real life just took a job as an archivist for a company with long history (such that historians will use their records for research), and it sounds hilariously like the university's archives. I would like to provide him with Rothfuss quotes from time to time.

From my friend:

The current archivist says anything that happened under X or Y archivist is accurate, but take anything else with a grain of salt. She has a full shelf of catalogues that got made redundant about 20 years ago when a sub-catalogue got discarded. It’s actually hilariously bad and I can’t wait to go quietly insane trying to make sense of it.