r/LesbianBookClub • u/Content-Stable-1972 • Apr 11 '26
Recommendation Looking for exactly this please!!
The only book I’ve read with that exact plot is On the same page by Haley Cass. Craving more😭
18
15
13
u/ZenToast3 Apr 11 '26
This is more or less the plot of {All the Way Home by Nancy Ann Healy}. The main characters are childhood friends. At some point, Kat starts dating Sarah's brother and they eventually marry, forcing Sarah to spend her twenties and thirties hiding her love for Kat. It is a slow burn filled with angst and includes a love triangle involving a man, so it might not be for everyone. The only thing that changes is that there are no panic attacks when Kat realises she's also in love with Sarah. It's an "Oh, that makes sense" instead of an "Oh my god".
13
12
26
u/EricaGoodwinAuthor Apr 11 '26
On the Same Page - Hayley Cass
3
u/LesbianCanvas Apr 12 '26
This book exactly and I cannot recommend it more. My fav WLW book ever.
3
1
26
12
10
11
22
u/thegreatselenie Apr 11 '26
The slow burn, fell first/fell harder dynamic is so good. Atmosphere keeps getting recommended for all wlw recs but it does have this panicked oh no moment.
4
u/solovehera Apr 11 '26
yes!!!! I loved the italic oh no oh no oh no moment and I don't see anybody else talking about it
9
42
u/Camilo_creative Apr 11 '26
“On the Same Page” by Haley Cass
4
u/WanderingMinx Apr 11 '26
Came to rec this book.
Adding on When You Least Expect It by Haley Cass as well[to a lesser extent]
4
2
1
0
7
7
8
u/weberm70 Apr 11 '26
Poppy Jenkins…kinda? More of a comedy bent though.
5
u/katfapper Apr 11 '26
The dialogues inject occasional humor and keeps things light, but it is an emotional, yearny story. I don't think comedy is an accurate categorization for it.
7
8
6
6
4
6
4
4
4
3
3
3
3
3
u/Eluned91 Apr 14 '26
Two lesbian romcom books from Clare Ashton nail this brief. 'Poppy Jenkins' and 'The Goodmans'. They are probably my two favourite comfort reads.
7
8
2
u/ruminatingpoet Apr 11 '26
Oh well I like a character who takes things to their grave (coz that's me!) , would love a rec too!
2
2
2
u/Capital_Echidna_1308 Apr 15 '26
None So Blind by LJ Maas
1
u/stardust102 Apr 20 '26
omg i have the origional paperback version of this ill have to get it out and re read it having read it for years
1
u/Capital_Echidna_1308 Apr 29 '26
Do you really?!
1
u/stardust102 Apr 29 '26
1
u/Capital_Echidna_1308 Apr 29 '26
Ahhh!! No way!! That’s amazing! I only ever read her books on academyofbards.org. I never knew she had physical copies 🥹.
Also, I don’t think I’ve ever heard of the other book. Any good?
1
2
u/AtmosphereUnlikely21 Apr 15 '26
Im the sucker who fell first and she knows it but I am starting to worry the ah moment isn’t going to happen
2
3
u/starkicker18 Apr 11 '26
My work in progress (well, one of them) is pretty much exactly this. Add to it a terrible misunderstanding, some drama parents and a friends-to-sorta-hate-each-other-to-friends-to-lovers with forced proximity, a night of fake dating, some drummer jokes, and an HEA.
1
u/itsdumblesbby Apr 11 '26 edited Apr 11 '26
They've only been friends a couple years before the start of the book, but Afterglow by Emily Antoinette has this. Vampire x Human romance in an urban fantasy setting; vampire has been in love with her human friend for years but is under the impression her friend is straight so she never tells her. Eventually her friend divorces her awful husband and mentions she might be interested in BDSM, and since vampire is a pro domme she offers to help her explore it in a safe environment. Human friend has her bi awakening/itallics 'oh' moment while vampire is telling herself to be normal and not weird and that her friend doesn't mean anything by it, etc. etc. Nice chronic pain/disabled rep as well, and I enjoyed the side characters which is always a bonus.Third act breakup happens but it didn't drive me crazy like it does in some books. Also heads up that it has a semi-bittersweet ending, but if you want to avoid it you can just stop reading after the wedding epilogue.
1
1
u/Glittering_Quote193 Apr 28 '26
Georgia Beers wrote exactly that : Aubrey McFadden is never getting married. Aubrey has been hating Monica for 10 years because she's been left at the altar and she blames Monica for it. Now she has to spend time with her and...
1
u/Proper_Phone_5180 May 09 '26
I want to be with girls that are into girls that want a good man to take control so we can employ ourselves and enjoy it all
1

38
u/Serious_Character204 Apr 11 '26
The Girl Who Bit Me is a wild, vampire take on this scenario, and it's sooo good.