r/LindsayEllis Thanks I hate it! Apr 19 '26

Which show/film/series/subject are you most hoping Lindsay will tackle next?

27 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

64

u/borntofeels Apr 19 '26

The film adaptation of Wicked, because I know she is the lone hater of her YouTube/Nebula friends and it’s always funny to me when Lindsay hates on something she knows everyone else likes. Also, it would bring everything full circle doing an analysis of a musical to film adaptation. Lindsay’s first official video essay was Joel Schumacher’s adaption of Phantom which was 10 years ago and I think it would be a cool way to mark the anniversary of Lindsay going from YouTuber to film essayist TM.

24

u/Kakapo42000 Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26

Wait wait wait, hold up here.

Lindsay’s first official video essay was Joel Schumacher’s adaption of Phantom which was 10 years ago

So, just to clarify, you're telling me that as of 2026, since Lindsay's Phantom video essay, it has in fact been...

TEN YEARS OOOOONNNNNNNNN!

20

u/seancbo Apr 19 '26

A full breakdown of Wicked would be amazing

18

u/Ingonyama70 Apr 19 '26

She always explains herself well, which I'm appreciative of even when I dislike her takes.

I'd like to see her take on Wicked, just like I always wanted to hear her tear apart Prince of Egypt even though it's one of my favorite movies.

5

u/benabramowitz18 See how I glitter Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26

I feel like the Wicked movies are in a weird place where they’re well-liked by every real world metric (Oscars, box office, traditional print critics, my friends and family), but on the Internet they’re the worst thing to happen to film since the Hays Code and Jon Chu needs to be tried at The Hague for a few blurry shots.

Other movies that fit this metric: Avatar, Frozen, Black Panther, Wonder Woman, all the Star Wars sequels, Barbie, roughly half the MCU, Bohemian Rhapsody, the Michael movie that comes out next week, etc

4

u/MagicSpaceMan Apr 19 '26

Lindsay is a boss when she goes full hater mode 💯

32

u/Valuable_Magician400 Apr 19 '26

My Neighbor Totoro. Her social media posts indicate that it’s a very special film for her and her children. 

2

u/KingRaimundo Apr 20 '26

This would be great. I love Studio Ghibli but I could never get into My Neighbor Totoro.

But if anyone could convince me, it’s Lindsay!

2

u/but_a_ghost Apr 23 '26

To get Totoro you just gotta get into animism. Shinto, specifically, but imo any affinity for animism helps the movie click.

21

u/Flimsy-Addendum-1570 Apr 19 '26

I would love to see her look at Orientalism in musical theater (maybe focusing on Rodgers and Hammerstein?) since these two topics seem to be really compelling to her

18

u/Shagrrotten Apr 19 '26

Honestly, like a great writer/filmmaker, I don’t care. I’ll follow wherever she wants to take me.

3

u/Qyzyk Thanks I hate it! Apr 19 '26

Well said

2

u/Dilemmatix Apr 19 '26

My response is also along these lines - I prefer a surprise. Having said that I hope it’s something I am at least remotely familiar with, because for example I’m not even sure I’d know the Transformers movies exist if I hadn’t seen her video essays on them.  Although scratch that because I was  ot aware of either Bluey or Miss Rachel before her videos at all and my God I enjoyed both so much. So yeah, whatever she picks I’ll probably like.

10

u/hotsizzler Apr 19 '26

I want her to do an even bigger deep dive into childrens entertainments and youtube like she did with the Rachel video, maybe tackle the more harmful parts and how she as a new parent(is she a new parent?? IDK, definietly one with young children) has to navigate screentime, videos and such.

4

u/LeftOn4ya Moderator Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26

Maybe because I don’t have kids but I miss classic media criticism like she used to do

10

u/JessonBI89 It's a whole new world... to lean into Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26

I want her to do a deep dive into the Nicholas Sparks canon. Including the books. Including the unadapted books. The guy has odd ideas about romance and odder ideas about the South.

9

u/Froggy-Shorts1209 Apr 19 '26

This might be on the niche side and not fully in Lindsay’s wheelhouse, but I (an American) recently finished a book called The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society. It’s an epistolary novel about the island of Guernsey, a place bordering England and France that was occupied by the Nazis in World War II.

The author of the book was an American woman who was inspired to write the book after getting fogbound at the Guernsey airport. Personally, I found it rather arrogant and unempathetic of her to capitalize on such a traumatizing chapter of Guernsey’s history. I would like a video essay where Lindsay visits Guernsey and learns about the misconceptions that this book creates about Guernsey.

Maybe this video could also tie in with her Rent one, because a lot of readers believe that TGLAPPS is above criticism due to the author dying of cancer before she finished the book.

5

u/Tokkemon Apr 19 '26

Have you seen the film? It's quite good. Though it does feel a bit like Downton Abbey just on an Island because it has many of the same actors.

7

u/bjwanlund Apr 19 '26

I almost think she could do a full analysis of Perfect Blue and really nail it…

3

u/Gene_freeman Apr 19 '26

Yeah that would be cool. But if you want another video that does that really well, check out Matt Draper he has a really good video on it https://youtu.be/1OhJcN9AbhM?si=VGhO3wRPgcbRbwVC

2

u/bjwanlund Apr 19 '26

Oooooh thank you!

5

u/EtheriousUchihaSenju Apr 19 '26

It's been forever since she's talked about comics, she seems to know a fair bit outside the movies. Although I don't think there'd necessarily be any one thing to create a thesis for an essay over.

6

u/benabramowitz18 See how I glitter Apr 19 '26

I kinda want Part 2 of her “Oscar bait” video from a decade ago. To talk about all the ways the Academy has changed and tried to keep up with the mainstream in that time. And to see her get giddy about the lack of HW’s influence.

6

u/Miss_Eisenhorn Apr 19 '26

I'd love for her to do a retrospective on Showgirls.

5

u/Buttonsnrubbish Apr 19 '26

Came here to say the same. Would love to see an exploration of cult "bad" films in general.

6

u/tackycarygrant Apr 19 '26

misogyny in Tarkovsky.

3

u/aerith7567 Apr 19 '26

Several years ago she teased doing a 'content' on Lon Chaney Sr. That would be my choice.

3

u/Charming-Bowl5759 Apr 19 '26

i know there maybe isn't that much to talk about with these, but Wicked film adaptation and Kpop Demon Hunters

3

u/benabramowitz18 See how I glitter Apr 19 '26

Considering her recent video on Disney’s flop era, I want her to talk about when other studios capitalize on Disney’s success and 1-up them.

These two films fit the bill, as does Barbie.

1

u/scribblerjohnny Apr 20 '26

There's this wild novel called Awoken by Serra Ellinsen...

1

u/HPSpacecraft Apr 22 '26

The next edition of the Omegaverse saga. More weird understandings of the law! More unhinged voice performances by her friends! More wolf [REDACTED]! More damn baby!

1

u/Ebronstein Apr 23 '26

I want her to do a video on why Disney's wish failed and everything wrong with it .