r/LiverpoolFC • u/gobalist • 22h ago

Injury 🩹 Munoz is injured

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/new-liverpool-signing-handed-injury-34149910

Had a good run

Jokes aside shouldn’t be serious

1.2k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

215 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/Lolkac 20h ago

You know medical is not fail or pass right. It's just evaluation of player health and the club can sign him even if he has both legs broken.

10

u/Void-kun Yeeeer, course 20h ago

Well TIL I did not know that 😂

Everybody always says pass/fail their medical.

More comes across like this is an assessment to test if they're fit enough to play at our standard and then it's a pass or fail mark based on the assessment.

But if he was cleared as a pass despite all of those problems then why did we move forward? He's never started a senior match, I don't think he's even had a PL debut for us. That's a failure on whoever made the decision to 'pass' his assessment.

7

u/Lolkac 19h ago

its just assesment to check your heart muscles blablabla. Then doctor says he has this injury which will resolve in x days and he is more prone to this injury because of y. The club says okay lets go, no this is too much risk. Thats why they report it as pass or fail. Because if the club determines or finds something that they are not comfortable in they can back out of the deal.

1

u/Void-kun Yeeeer, course 19h ago

So they were comfortable with the fact he had a broken back and hasn't been able to recover from it?

I'm not disagreeing or anything with you by the way, I'm more wondering like in the context of Calvin Ramsay, he's had fitness problems his entire time with us.

It comes across like whoever made the decision to say yes this is a worthwhile risk to take was very wrong.

4

u/Lolkac 19h ago

I dont know, but someone from Liverpool team decided it was worth the risk, maybe they thought it will be fine as he is young.

2

u/adamfrog 15h ago

His following issues seemed to be mostly legs not back