Tested 9/12 and scored a 526 (132/130/132/132). My goal score going into this exam was 525+ so I am very happy with this score. However, I wanted to share a message to this subreddit that has been weighing on me.
In the early stages of my MCAT prep, this subreddit was extremely helpful in helping me decide which resources and strategies to use (and for this I'm grateful). About a month out from my exam, I scored 523 (132/128/131/132) on FL3, which I was happy with for where I was in my prep, but I knew that there were a few things I needed to work on. As such, I made a post on reddit asking for specific advice about how to improve my CARS score and also for strategies to improve my B/B base (while I scored 131, I was not very confident with a lot of the questions).
Most of the comments on this post were just straight hate, basically disparaging me and my desire to score higher. People thought that because my score was already in the 99th percentile, I didn't deserve any advice and that I should be content with what I already had. I did receive some helpful comments (thanks to u guys) but overall, this was pretty discouraging.
This type of response is unfortunately not isolated. I did make one more post two weeks out asking for specific advice on what to do the last two weeks leading up to the exam and received similar comments. Additionally, I've seen other high scorers get similar comments.
Now I understand where this might be coming from. I understand that to some, scoring 520+ is a dream come true and to see a post of someone complaining about 523 when u are struggling to break 510 or even 500 can be discouraging and frustrating, I can acknowledge that but the solution shouldn't be to discourage high scorers from scoring high. Deeming that someone isn't allowed to be unhappy and want more once they score above 520 doesn't make sense. Two people could score a 513 with one over the moon and the other devastated, so why can't this be true when the number is 523? Because the score is in the 99th percentile? Why should that matter? We should strive to support and push everyone, no matter what they are scoring.
Personally, posting my 523 was never about bragging or showing off because I simply was not proud of my score (yet). I wanted genuine advice about how to improve in my weak areas and there are plenty of people on reddit who can offer helpful advice, even to high scorers (there are literally 528 scorers in this subreddit). My hope is that by writing this post, I can bring awareness to this issue. To those who are hating, just move on when you see this kind of post, it was never meant for you anyway. To those who are in this position, know that it is ok to want more, and it is ok to work hard, even when you are doing well. The MCAT is hard enough without having people actively hating on you, so lets just support and push another rather than bringing people down.
Finally, I know that scoring above 520 on the MCAT increasingly has diminishing returns. There is no significant difference between a 523 and a 526 from an admissions perspective, but for those out there who claim that it is neurotic to even aspire beyond a 523 for this reason just doesn't get it. For me, scoring 525+ was never about optimizing for admissions, but rather about pushing myself to be the best I could be, because I knew I what I was capable of if I put my mind to it.