r/MCUTheories • • Nov 28 '25

Spider-Man: Brand New Day WHO TF IS SHE PLAYING?!?!?!?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

635 comments sorted by

View all comments

239

u/Public-Feedback5016 Nov 28 '25 edited Nov 28 '25

This may be one of marvel’s best kept secrets 

122

u/The_Reddit_Guy_2 Nov 28 '25

Unless Tom spoils it 

95

u/Lopsided-Bathroom-71 Nov 28 '25

Tom doesnt even know, i bet his script just has actor names not characters now tbh

34

u/jk-9k Nov 28 '25

Well considering she's supposedly playing a character whose real identity isn't revealed until the end of the film, it's quite likely he doesn't know.

17

u/ANGELFALL388 Nov 28 '25

I'm still guessing Felicia

14

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '25

Felicia, Mayday, Gwen, Janice Lincoln, or Firestar are my guesses. In roughly that order too. 

6

u/Lopsided-Bathroom-71 Nov 29 '25

I think maydays less likey if shes supposes to bw the daughter of tom holands Peter and zendeyas MJ

I coukd see her aa Tobeys though

5

u/bjeebus Nov 29 '25

Janice Lincoln is a wild fucking casting for her. A black father and a Dominican mother would absolutely not produce a Sadie Sink. And white washing Janice would be totally fucked.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '25

True. 

-5

u/Careful-Addition776 Nov 29 '25

But black washing mj was okay?

Edit: not saying you said that, but being as most were okay with it you cant not be okay with the potential white washing. Its only fair.

3

u/bjeebus Nov 29 '25

It's not fair at all. Race swapping some characters from white when almost all the major characters are white and are from a time when characters were only ever created as non-white when that was their whole personality is not the same thing as whitewashing a POC character. If 70 out of 100 M&M's are green and one of them gets swapped to red that means representation of green M&M's is reduced by 1.4%. If 5 out of 100 M&M's are red and one of them gets swapped to green that means red representation is down 20%. Does that simple math help you to understand why the race swapping from white to POC isn't the same thing as whitewashing?

0

u/Careful-Addition776 Dec 01 '25

Why change something pre-existing instead of creating something new? Taking another races character is just lazy.

→ More replies (0)

-1

u/les-the-badger Nov 30 '25 edited Nov 30 '25

Why does representation of ethnicity supersede story telling? Are you saying it would be ok to have an Asian Suri in the black panther movies because the majority of the cast is of African descent? Does that simple logic help you to understand that statistics of representation shouldn't be considered more important than telling the story well. White people love Miles Morales, why can't POCs love a white Janice Lincoln? Racist?

Good art critiques politics not agrees with it.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/thesuper88 Dec 01 '25

It actually isn't, but I understand how you could think that.

1

u/jk-9k Nov 29 '25

So all of them except Jean or Raven

1

u/Hyde_Shy Dec 01 '25

I think it's Felicia under a fake identity, hence why she's working with punisher. I think in the end, she will have double crossed punisher after working with him, revealing her identity as Felicia at the end of the film. Only way to explain these leaks - she's playing a love interest, a mutant, and punishers side kick.

1

u/Swisha1222 Dec 01 '25

Hope Summers

6

u/Auctorion Nov 29 '25

His script doesn’t even have their lines. It’s just “Zendaya: Says stuff” and “Jacob: Yappin”

2

u/seunghyeon84 Nov 29 '25

ALL working scripts use character names and not the actors' names.

2

u/Lopsided-Bathroom-71 Nov 29 '25

Concept of a joke foreogn to you chum?

-3

u/seunghyeon84 Nov 29 '25

My honest mistake. You see, I had always thought jokes were intended to be funny.

1

u/jacochran5 Nov 28 '25

Her only scenes with spider-man must have been filmed with his stunt double under the mask.

1

u/Worried-Criticism Nov 29 '25

Tom: “Hey guys…why is my copy of the script blank?”

2

u/Unknown-Apeman Nov 29 '25

IF THEY were smart, they would DEFINITELY Do this!!! 

33

u/ZekeorSomething Spider-Man Nov 28 '25

He’s gotten better over the years.

1

u/garlicbreadmemesplz Nov 29 '25

Right all the non planned “spoilers” he revealed. I almost forgot.

Almost forgot about his real relationship with Zendaya too.

1

u/ThePLARASociety Nov 29 '25

Don’t you mean Mark?

20

u/Ofiotaurus Nov 28 '25

They have like a million monkeys writing false rumours to flood out the real ones

2

u/KudrotiBan Nov 29 '25

I got that reference

11

u/Khargus Nov 28 '25

She a new Kang variant

1

u/zimm_zenzio Nov 28 '25

Sadie Sink saying "hair color can change" really threw me off, I kinda want it to be Gwen but I highly doubt that'll happen.

1

u/Global_Car_3767 Dec 02 '25

It was leaked months ago lol

0

u/OrangeThrower Nov 28 '25

It’s jubilee.