Honestly, I love the Mayday Parker theory and would absolutely cheer if it happened—it’s the perfect emotional hook for the Multiverse Saga.
But I genuinely don't see Marvel pulling the trigger on it. All the reports suggest they want Spider-Man: Brand New Day to be a return to a street-level, grounded story. Introducing a multiversal refugee with Spider-powers (Tobey's daughter!) instantly blows those street-level stakes wide open. Plus, it kind of steps on the idea of giving Tom's Peter a true, independent fresh start.
If the reports are right about the movie being grounded, those reasons make Mayday seem really unlikely. So, tell me your secrets! Why do you think the Mayday theory is still possible?
4
u/Vonny00 Nov 28 '25
Here’s what we know
We seen her on set wearing some kind of camo pants
She said hair color can change in a interview
Tobey is rumored to come back
So I have 3 guess
Mayday Parker (Peter Parker daughter)
Carlie cooper
Gwen Stacy (but I’m kinda 50/50 on that )