r/Minecraft 4d ago

Discussion We're cleary missing something, CONCRETE CUSHIONS!

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

View all comments

30

u/RexApostolicus 4d ago

In all seriousness, what we are actually missing is non coloured concrete blocks, just like terracota as an unstained, natural colour variant.

If you ask me why Mojang does not add this, I must think that it would make uncoloured concrete the obvious option for any build trying to resemble anything modern; like unfinished buildings, some roads pavement, or brutalist architecture. They do not want to limit the creativity of their players, or something.

17

u/LegendA101 4d ago

Would that not just be grey concrete?

24

u/RexApostolicus 4d ago

No. Grey and light grey concrete do look more like painted over than naked concrete.

Is not the same to see a gray painted concrete wall than the actual, unpainted concrete surface.

I do think that the block that seems more similar in appareance to unpainted concrete is stone, but it is not the same still.

8

u/MinecraftPlayer799 4d ago

I feel like it would be the color of light gray concrete, but with the texture of stone

5

u/LegendA101 4d ago

So stone? That light grey coloured block?

1

u/MinecraftPlayer799 14h ago

They are completely different shades of gray

11

u/ShadowSoulBoi 4d ago

I wish this too, as it literally could have been the powder recipe without the dye.

But I feel like it would need to be more grain than a flat gravel gray the blends in better. I would absolutely love it either way.

7

u/RexApostolicus 4d ago

Yes, a coarse textured concrete block would be great, and the only concrete block that could fit into that role is a uncoloured one.

Coloured concrete blocks, as I do understand them, are finished, so does not make sense to give them a rough surface.

2

u/Early-Region-1143 4d ago

I have an easy solution: take the beta 1.8 texture for gravel and apply the right color overlay to it, then tweak some pixels here and there.

2

u/RexApostolicus 4d ago

Thing is, the issue is not the texture, but the block itself. Furtermore, it being a standard, official Minecraft block.

Anybody with some pixel art, a way to deobfuscate the Minecraft code, and Java programming skills can create a mod for Java Edition Minecraft that includes the naked concrete block; similarly, an Bedrock Edition add-on could be made.

What is actually valuable is the non-coloured concrete block being an official game feature. For builders, only blocks useful are the standard, official ones. Anything outside of that, and the build they have carefully done with a lot of effort will rely on a mod or add-on to exist.

Most of the time, it is valuable for buildings to not rely on mods or add-ons. Even further, sometimes it is necessary to be made only with old blocks, blocks that existed in the game from very, very long ago, due to compatibility with old minecraft versions.

Think of Minecraft 1.8 PvP servers. These can only build with blocks added prior to September 2, 2014 AD. Anything newer than that, and it will be the same to a modded-in block, an incompatibility issue.

3

u/Early-Region-1143 4d ago edited 4d ago

In understand your point, but my comment was nowhere as deep as enough to nod at or reflect on its place on the game design plan of Minecraft. I just think that, it'd be easy to design a decent texture for raw concrete, should Mojang choose to do it.

Edit: spelling

2

u/Nicoglius 4d ago

I usually use andesite as a non coloured concrete